Key Moments

Dmitri Dolgov: Waymo and the Future of Self-Driving Cars | Lex Fridman Podcast #147

Lex FridmanLex Fridman
Science & Technology5 min read144 min video
Dec 20, 2020|101,856 views|2,127|263
Save to Pod
TL;DR

Waymo CTO Dmitri Dolgov discusses self-driving tech, from Google's early days to Waymo's scaled operations.

Key Insights

1

Waymo's journey began with Google's self-driving car project in 2009, evolving into Waymo in 2016.

2

The Darpa Urban Challenge was a pivotal event, sparking significant advancements and attracting talent.

3

Waymo's development prioritized learning and iteration, with ambitious early milestones like driving 100,000 autonomous miles.

4

The pivot to fully driverless vehicles, rather than driver-assist, was a crucial strategic decision made around 2013.

5

Waymo's operational philosophy emphasizes safety, reliability, and user experience, aiming to delight customers.

6

Scaling autonomous technology requires advancements in core tech, evaluation processes, and commercial operations.

EARLY FORAYS INTO TECHNOLOGY AND ROBOTICS

Dmitri Dolgov's fascination with technology began at a young age with computers, leading him to programming and game development in Russia. While he didn't pursue game development professionally, this early exposure to coding laid the foundation for his future engineering path. His academic journey included studying physics and mathematics at MIPT (Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology), a rigorous institution that instilled a strong understanding of fundamental principles. This academic background, combined with his early programming experiences, set the stage for his eventual deep involvement in robotics and artificial intelligence.

THE DARPA URBAN CHALLENGE AND THE BIRTH OF WAYMO

Dolgov's entry into robotics and self-driving cars began seriously with his postdoctoral work at Stanford, where he joined the Darpa Urban Challenge team in 2006. This competition, designed to test autonomous vehicles in a simulated city environment with other vehicles, was a crucial catalyst for the field. The success of teams in this and previous challenges, particularly the insights gained, inspired Google's founders to launch the self-driving car project in 2009, which eventually became Waymo. This project aimed to tackle the complex problem of driving with ambitious learning-focused milestones.

WAYMO'S EVOLUTION AND STRATEGIC PIVOTS

The initial Google self-driving car project focused on extensive learning through milestones like completing 100,000 autonomous miles and special test routes with no human intervention. After achieving these, the project pivoted around 2013 from a driver-assist focus to the bolder vision of fully driverless vehicles. This strategic shift was critical, recognizing that building a fully autonomous system presented fundamentally different engineering challenges than driver assistance. The formation of Waymo as an independent company within Alphabet in 2016 marked the next phase, dedicated to scaling this technology commercially.

LANDMARK MILESTONES AND OPERATIONAL DEPLOYMENT

Waymo achieved several significant milestones, including the world's first fully driverless trip on public roads in 2015 with their 'Firefly' vehicle, carrying a blind passenger. This was followed by the launch of regular driverless operations in 2017 and the public commercial service, Waymo One, in Phoenix in 2018. A key distinction of Waymo's approach is its focus on 'driverless' operations, meaning no safety driver is present, differentiating it from many other autonomous vehicle efforts. This rider-only mode was opened to the public in Phoenix in October 2020, signifying a major step towards mainstream adoption.

TECHNOLOGICAL FOUNDATIONS AND HARDWARE DEVELOPMENT

Waymo's success is built on a robust technological stack, with a strong emphasis on developing proprietary hardware, including lidar, cameras, and radar. The company highlights its fifth-generation sensing hardware as a qualitative leap forward, designed for manufacturability at scale and improved unit economics. This in-house development strategy allows for deep integration and optimization, moving beyond off-the-shelf components to create systems specifically tailored for autonomous driving challenges, including pedestrian and cyclist safety.

THE ROLE OF MACHINE LEARNING AND DATA

Machine learning (ML) is central to every aspect of Waymo's system, from basic perception tasks like object detection to complex prediction and decision-making. Dolgov emphasizes a hybrid approach, combining supervised and unsupervised learning with rule-based systems where appropriate, such as traffic light interpretation. The ability to process vast amounts of sensor data in real-time, combined with extensive off-board data for training and simulation, is critical. Breakthroughs in areas like language models are also being explored for their applicability to behavioral prediction and decision-making in driving scenarios.

SCALING OPERATIONS AND NAVIGATING COMPLEXITIES

Expanding Waymo's service beyond Phoenix involves scaling three key dimensions: core technology, evaluation and deployment processes, and product/commercial excellence. The fifth-generation hardware is designed for massive scale, and continuous improvements are being made to software for robustness and generality. The company is refining its evaluation and deployment frameworks to enable confident, regular releases of new software across its fleet. Learning from real-world operations in Phoenix, including user feedback on everything from grocery loading to pickup locations, is crucial for iterating and improving the product.

USER EXPERIENCE AND THE FUTURE OF TRANSPORTATION

Waymo aims to create a seamless, frictionless, and delightful transportation experience. User feedback mechanisms, including in-car prompts and a 'live help' customer support system, are integral to this. The goal is for users to 'fall in love' with the predictability, safety, and convenience of Waymo's service, making it a reliable part of their daily lives. This involves not only moving people and goods efficiently but also considering subtle aspects of user interaction, like real-time car status updates during pickup, to enhance the overall experience.

ADDRESSING ETHICAL QUESTIONS AND REAL-WORLD CHALLENGES

While the 'trolley problem' is often discussed, Dolgov views it as more of a philosophical thought experiment than a practical engineering concern for autonomous vehicles. The focus in development is on building a safe, capable, and defensive driving system that proactively avoids dangerous situations. The rigorous engineering process, detailed testing, and extensive data collection are geared towards ensuring the safety of all road users, especially vulnerable ones like pedestrians and cyclists, often detecting hazards earlier than human operators. Waymo's approach prioritizes moving the entire capability curve upward rather than making difficult trade-offs in extreme hypothetical scenarios.

BROADENING HORIZONS: TRUCKING AND GLOBAL EXPANSION

Waymo is also applying its autonomous driving technology to commercial trucking through Waymo Via, recognizing that the core technical challenges—perception, decision-making, and infrastructure—transfer across domains. While the hardware configurations might differ (e.g., sensor placement on trucks versus passenger vehicles), the fundamental engineering principles remain consistent. The company is strategically building on its core technology and specializing it for different applications. Plans for global expansion are underway, with Phoenix serving as a foundational platform for learning and refinement before scaling to new cities and markets.

Common Questions

Dmitri first got into computer science at a fairly young age in the late 1980s when his family got their first IBM computer. His leap to robotics, specifically self-driving cars, happened much later after grad school and a postdoc at Stanford University.

Topics

Mentioned in this video

People
Sergey Brin

Co-founder of Google, who believed in autonomous vehicle technology after the DARPA Urban Challenge.

George Hotz

Founder of comma.ai, described as an entertaining human being, who is working on an end-to-end machine learning approach to autonomous driving.

Larry Page

Co-founder of Google, who believed in autonomous vehicle technology after the DARPA Urban Challenge.

Mikhail Bulgakov

Russian author of 'The Master and Margarita,' one of Dmitri Dolgov's favorite books.

Ray Bradbury

Science fiction author mentioned alongside Isaac Asimov and the Strugatsky Brothers.

Mike Montemerlo

The software lead for the Stanford DARPA Urban Challenge team, credited with writing most of the code.

Dmitri Dolgov

CTO of Waymo, involved in the Google self-driving car project since 2009. The main guest of the podcast.

Steve Mahan

The first blind passenger to take a fully driverless trip on public roads in a custom-built Waymo Firefly vehicle in Austin, Texas.

Strugatsky Brothers

Russian science fiction authors (Arkady and Boris Strugatsky) whose works, like 'Roadside Picnic' and 'Hard to Be a God,' made a strong impression on Dmitri Dolgov and are compared to Isaac Asimov and Ray Bradbury.

George Orwell

Author of '1984' and 'Animal Farm', whose works highlight the fragility of society and the dangers of bureaucracy, incompetence, and misinformation.

Isaac Asimov

Science fiction author, compared to the Strugatsky Brothers, and whose short story 'The Last Question' is quoted by Dmitri Dolgov regarding the meaning of life.

Elon Musk

CEO of Tesla, known for his view that lidar is a 'crutch' in autonomous driving technology.

Books
The Snail on the Slope

A book by the Strugatsky Brothers that Dmitri Dolgov considers their most important work, although he admits he found it difficult to understand.

Beetle in the Ant Hill

A science fiction novel by the Strugatsky Brothers, mentioned among their other works.

Brave New World

A dystopian novel mentioned by Lex Fridman alongside '1984' as works that help in understanding how societies can go wrong in non-obvious ways.

The Master and Margarita

A novel by Russian author Mikhail Bulgakov, cited by Dmitri Dolgov as one of his favorite books that can be reread and enjoyed at different stages of life, revealing deeper meanings.

Monday Starts on Saturday

A humorous science fiction novel by the Strugatsky Brothers, noted for its parallels to serious research in a magical setting.

Roadside Picnic

A science fiction novel by the Strugatsky Brothers, mentioned as one of their works enjoyed by Dmitri Dolgov.

Nineteen Eighty-Four

A dystopian novel by George Orwell, cited by Dmitri Dolgov as a book that made a strong impression and contains crucial lessons about doublethink and societal fragility that resonate with current world events.

The Last Question

A short story by Isaac Asimov about a supercomputer attempting to answer how entropy can be reduced, used by Dmitri Dolgov as an analogy for the meaning of life.

Hard to Be a God

A science fiction novel by the Strugatsky Brothers that explores deep ethical questions, discussed as one of their works enjoyed by Dmitri Dolgov.

Animal Farm

An allegorical novella by George Orwell, recommended by Lex Fridman as a companion piece to '1984' and a thought experiment on how societies can go wrong.

More from Lex Fridman

View all 505 summaries

Found this useful? Build your knowledge library

Get AI-powered summaries of any YouTube video, podcast, or article in seconds. Save them to your personal pods and access them anytime.

Try Summify free