Sumo Deadlifts, Procrastination, and Oral Contraceptives (Episode 85)
Key Moments
Discussion on sumo deadlifts, procrastination, weight cut strategies, and hormonal contraceptives.
Key Insights
Sumo deadlifting is a valid powerlifting technique, not cheating; individual advantages stem from biomechanics, not inherent unfairness.
Procrastination is a behavior driven by temporal discounting and task aversion, which can be managed by reducing friction and targeting the 'onset delay'.
Diet breaks can be beneficial for psychological and practical reasons during weight loss, but there's no mandated 12-week cycle.
A maintenance phase after bulking isn't physiologically necessary to retain muscle; it offers practical benefits for smoother transitions.
Current research suggests second and third-generation oral contraceptives have no significant negative impact on strength or hypertrophy.
The research on hormonal contraceptives has limitations, including potential selection bias and a lack of data on newer forms.
FEATS OF STRENGTH AND THE SUMO DEADLIFT DEBATE
The episode opens with a remarkable feat of strength: Kristof Will Bicky pulling 502.5 kg in a sumo deadlift, the heaviest ever. This impressive lift sparks a discussion about whether sumo deadlifting constitutes cheating. While some, like bodybuilder Chris Bumstead, have claimed it is, the podcast hosts and cited research argue against this. They explain that while certain biomechanical advantages exist for some individuals with specific body types (long arms, hip structure well-suited for sumo), it's not inherently unfair or cheating. The difference in strength curves between sumo and conventional deadlifts means some people are naturally better suited to one over the other, akin to genetic advantages in other sports, rather than a rule violation.
UNDERSTANDING AND OVERCOMING PROCRASTINATION
Listener questions lead to a discussion on procrastination. It's defined not just as delaying tasks but as voluntarily delaying an important activity despite anticipating negative consequences. This behavior is linked to 'temporal discounting,' where short-term rewards (like avoiding an unpleasant task) are prioritized over long-term benefits. Procrastination is also influenced by task aversion, anxiety, lack of self-efficacy, and low intrinsic motivation. Strategies to combat it include approaching tasks with curiosity, fostering intrinsic motivation, practicing mindfulness, and crucially, targeting 'onset delay' – the failure to start. This can involve making the initial step easier, such as preparing one's workspace or even drinking pre-workout before a gym session.
STRATEGIC DIETING: CUTS AND MAINTENANCE PHASES
The podcast addresses questions about weight loss strategies. Regarding the duration of a 'cut,' the popular 12-week benchmark is debunked as lacking strong evidence; the decision to take a diet break should be based on individual physiological and psychological needs, or practical life circumstances, rather than an arbitrary timeline. Similarly, the idea that a maintenance phase is strictly required after a 'bulk' to solidify muscle gain is also questioned. While not physiologically necessary, a maintenance period can offer practical benefits, such as a smoother transition from overfeeding to underfeeding and a clearer understanding of current calorie needs before initiating a cut.
HORMONAL CONTRACEPTIVES AND ATHLETIC PERFORMANCE
A significant portion of the discussion centers on Greg's article about the impact of hormonal contraceptives on female lifters. Countering common misinformation, the available research, comprising ten papers from eight studies, generally shows no meaningful difference in strength or hypertrophy outcomes between users and non-users of second and third-generation oral contraceptives. In fact, the literature may slightly lean towards a potential benefit for hypertrophy in users, though this is not a strong claim. This contrasts sharply with anecdotal social media claims suggesting negative impacts on gains.
LIMITATIONS AND NUANCES IN CONTRACEPTIVE RESEARCH
Despite the broad conclusion that current research doesn't support negative impacts of common oral contraceptives on gains, crucial limitations are highlighted. The studies are largely observational, not randomized controlled trials, introducing potential selection bias – those who discontinue contraception due to perceived negative effects might not be represented. Furthermore, the existing research primarily focuses on older generations of combined oral contraceptives, neglecting newer formulations like progestin-only pills, implants, and IUDs, whose effects remain unstudied. This leaves significant gaps in understanding the full scope of hormonal contraception's influence on female athletes.
THE ROLE OF BIOMECHANICS IN DEADLIFT SUCCESS
Delving deeper into the sumo deadlift debate, the hosts explain how biomechanics and 'leveraging' play a significant role in individual performance. For sumo deadlifters, the weakest point is often breaking the bar off the floor, whereas for conventional deadlifters, it's typically mid-shin. Individuals with longer arms and hip structures well-suited for sumo can effectively 'cut off' a larger portion of the difficult range of motion, essentially performing a partial lift. This is supported by comparing floor pulls to block pulls, where some individuals show disproportionately higher gains in sumo from low block pulls compared to conventional, pointing to the interaction between body proportions and the lift's strength curve.
ATHLETIC ADVANTAGES AND THE 'GENETIC LOTTERY'
The discussion on biomechanics extends to a broader point about fairness in sports. The hosts argue that while certain individuals may gain a significant advantage from specific techniques or body types (like sumo deadlifting or a basketball player's height and reach), this is not 'cheating.' It's framed as winning the 'genetic lottery'—possessing the physiological traits that best suit the rules and demands of the sport. This is compared to elite athletes in other sports like basketball (Giannis Antetokounmpo) or marathon running, where inherent physical advantages are celebrated, not condemned as unfair.
WEIGHT CLASS TRENDS AND DEADLIFT VARIATIONS
Further analysis reveals trends in deadlift technique preference based on body type and weight class. Shorter lifters, particularly lighter males and females, tend to favor sumo deadlifts, while heavier lifters, especially super heavyweights, often prefer conventional. This is attributed to the arbitrary nature of the deadlift's starting height relative to limb length; for shorter individuals, the bar starts higher, potentially making sumo more advantageous. Conversely, taller individuals may find the longer range of motion in conventional lifts more manageable, or sumo disadvantageous, akin to a shorter person attempting a deficit sumo deadlift. The discussion touches on proposed modifications to deadlift rules to equalize starting height, though acknowledges the inherent variation as part of the sport.
VEGETARIAN PROTEIN ALTERNATIVES AND CULINARY STAPLES
Addressing a listener's question about vegetarian protein sources comparable to shredded chicken, the hosts suggest cubed tofu as a versatile option. Prepared by baking with soy sauce and cornstarch for crispiness, it can be incorporated into various savory dishes. While not as universally adaptable as plain shredded chicken, it offers a good base for stir-fries, soups, and even tacos. Other vegetarian staples like chickpea curry are mentioned but noted for their strong, less interchangeable flavors.
ENTERTAINMENT RECOMMENDATIONS: SLOW HORSES SEASON FINALE
Concluding the episode, the hosts briefly discuss television recommendations. Greg reports enthusiastically that the Apple TV series 'Slow Horses' successfully 'stuck the landing' with its season finale and has been renewed for a second season. This is contrasted with the typical American TV model of running shows until they decline, highlighting a perceived difference in the British approach toward more contained, high-quality storytelling, often in limited series formats. The discussion also touches on the disappointing finales of shows like 'Game of Thrones' and the current trajectory of 'Westworld,' emphasizing the value of a satisfying conclusion.
Mentioned in This Episode
●Supplements
●Products
●Software & Apps
●Companies
●Studies Cited
●Concepts
●People Referenced
Common Questions
For those who experience digestive issues with common high-fiber foods, grains like bulgur wheat, freekah, and pearled barley are recommended. These are cooked similarly to rice and retain their fiber content without causing the same digestive upset for many people.
Topics
Mentioned in this video
A recommended whole grain source of fiber that agrees with the speaker's digestive system.
A whole grain recommended for its fiber content and pleasant taste.
The original British version of the TV show 'The Office', known for its short run.
A style of deadlift that is currently a hot topic in the fitness world due to claims of it being 'cheating'.
Powerlifter who recently achieved the heaviest deadlift in training history.
The voluntary delay of an intended and necessary activity, despite expecting negative consequences.
A study reviewed in the article concerning molecular markers of skeletal muscle hypertrophy in oral contraceptive users.
The psychological tendency to favor short-term outcomes over long-term ones.
A British crime drama thriller series on Apple TV+ that the host tentatively recommended and confirmed stuck the landing in its finale.
A segment title potentially related to fitness goals or progress.
A versatile vegetarian protein source prepared with soy sauce and cornstarch, suitable for bulk preparation.
The traditional style of deadlift, contrasted with the sumo deadlift in terms of technique and strength curves.
A study involving cyclic periods of dieting and maintenance (2 weeks on, 2 weeks off).
The American adaptation of 'The Office', known for its long run.
More from Stronger By Science
View all 119 summaries
1 minHow to avoid poor sleep due to caffeine use
1 minAre free-weight exercises really king?
1 minWhich exercises build the most muscle?
1 minDoes Being Overweight Really Make You Unhealthier?
Found this useful? Build your knowledge library
Get AI-powered summaries of any YouTube video, podcast, or article in seconds. Save them to your personal pods and access them anytime.
Try Summify free