What are the three main types of reinforcement for dogs?

The three main types of reinforcement are food, toys (like a ball or frisbee), and 'permission' to do desired activities (e.g., chasing a squirrel, going through a door). Permission-based rewards are often overlooked but are very powerful.

How does the 'It's Your Choice' game work and what does it teach?

In 'It's Your Choice,' a handler holds treats, closing their hand if the dog paws or barks, and opening it when the dog stops. This teaches the dog that the handler controls good things and that desired behavior leads to rewards. It's a foundational game for teaching self-control.

Why are Crate Games so important for dog training?

Crate Games provide a safe comfort zone for dogs and teach many skills beyond just liking a crate. By controlling access to rewards through the crate door, it builds confidence and teaches dogs to stay in position until released, which can be generalized to other behaviors like staying on a dog bed when guests arrive.

What is the 'Collar Grab Game' and why is it beneficial?

The Collar Grab Game involves grabbing the dog's collar before giving them a treat or desired item. This classically conditions the dog to associate the collar grab with positive experiences, ensuring they don't fear being grabbed in emergencies or try to evade when in a hurry.

What should be prioritized during the first 24 hours with a new puppy or rescue dog?

The first 24 hours are critical for setting expectations. Key steps include playing tug to build interaction, providing a crate for sleeping (ideally by your bed), having good quality chew toys and food, and being intentional about establishing positive routines for potty breaks and sleep.

How can I prevent a puppy from peeing in the house?

Prevent mistakes by confining the puppy (crate, X-pen) when not directly supervised. When taking them out, always use a leash and reward them immediately with a click and treat as they finish their business. Avoid interaction during nighttime potty breaks to prevent reinforcement of waking up.

What is a clicker and how is it used in dog training?

A clicker is a precise 'marker' or 'bridge' that communicates to the dog the exact moment they performed a desired behavior. It's a conditioned reinforcer, always followed by a high-value reward, and is excellent for isolating small, specific slices of behavior.

Why is positive reinforcement more effective than punishment?

Punishment can suppress behavior when the punisher is present, but it often has 'fallout' by creating negative emotional associations and doesn't fix the underlying behavior. In contrast, positive reinforcement builds a desired behavior by creating positive associations and a cooperative relationship.

What general principle should I apply when my dog is doing an unwanted behavior?

Instead of focusing on 'don't,' identify 'where's the value' or 'where's the reinforcement' for the unwanted behavior. Then, remove or control that reinforcement and actively train a desired, incompatible behavior that the dog can 'do' and be rewarded for.

What are the '3 Ds' for proofing dog behaviors?

The '3 Ds' stand for Distance, Duration, and Distractions. To failure-proof behaviors, you gradually increase the distance from the dog, extend the duration of the behavior, and add more distractions. This builds resilience and reliability in real-world scenarios.

How can I make my dog more focused and engaged during training?

Before training, engage your dog in some tugging or running to get their heart rate and 'arousal state' up. This helps them get "in the zone," making them less susceptible to environmental distractions and more focused on the task at hand.

What essential tools should new dog owners prepare?

Recommended tools include a crate with a partition, a Kong toy, Nature's Miracle cleaner for accidents, a clicker, a buckle leash (avoiding pinch/chain collars), and good quality dog food, possibly including a head halter like a Gentle Leader for exuberant dogs.

Key Moments

Susan Garrett (Full Episode) | The Tim Ferriss Show (Podcast)

Tim Ferriss

Howto & Style4 min read127 min video

Dec 9, 2016|22,782 views|260|16

tim ferriss 4 hour workweek 4 hour body 4 hour chef forbes timothy ferriss entrepreneur author writer best-seller public speaker angel investor

Save to Pod

Key Moments

TL;DR

Susan Garrett & Tim Ferriss discuss choice-based dog training and reinforcement learning, applicable to humans too.

Key Insights

Choice-based dog training emphasizes positive reinforcement and allows dogs to make choices, with consequences for those choices.

The four foundational games ('It's Your Choice,' Crate Games, Restraint Recalls, Collar Grab Game) build essential skills and a strong bond.

Understanding reinforcement zones and intentionally delivering rewards in specific areas can shape desired behaviors like heeling.

Mistakes in training often stem from a mismatch in expectations and a lack of intentionality, leading to unwanted behaviors.

Clicker training acts as a 'bridge' or 'marker' that precisely communicates desired actions and is a powerful tool for shaping behavior.

Punishment can suppress behavior but has significant negative fallout and is less effective long-term than positive reinforcement.

UNDERSTANDING CHOICE-BASED TRAINING

Susan Garrett introduces choice-based dog training, contrasting it with punishment-based and lure-based methods. In this model, dogs make their own choices, and positive reinforcement is applied when they make the desired one. This approach, inspired by Garrett's own upbringing and applied to marine mammals, focuses on creating a relationship of fun and trust. It’s about setting up an environment where good choices are naturally more appealing to the dog, much like a child choosing to come for supper to avoid a canceled TV show.

THE FOUR FOUNDATIONAL GAMES

Garrett outlines four crucial games for building a strong foundation with dogs. 'It's Your Choice' teaches dogs that the handler controls resources, rewarding the choice to stop unwanted behaviors. Crate Games establish a safe space and build confidence. Restraint Recalls train a reliable return to the handler, and the Collar Grab Game conditions dogs to accept handling positively, preventing panic in emergencies. These games, when practiced consistently, lay the groundwork for all subsequent training and better behavior.

THE POWER OF REINFORCEMENT ZONES AND PERMISSION

The concept of the 'reinforcement zone' or 'reward zone' is vital. By consistently delivering rewards and resources from a specific position (e.g., the dog's left side for heel work), handlers create a highly valued area. This intentional placement of reinforcement, rather than random distribution, transfers value to the handler and shapes desired behaviors. This also extends to 'permission,' such as requiring a 'sit' before a dog receives a meal or exits a door, turning everyday actions into opportunities for reinforcing good choices.

SHAPING BEHAVIOR AND THE ROLE OF THE CLICKER

Shaping behavior involves guiding an animal's actions through a series of small, rewarded steps. The clicker, or a verbal marker like 'yes,' acts as a precise 'bridge' or 'scalpel,' marking the exact moment a desired behavior occurs, followed by reinforcement. This is particularly effective for complex behaviors or isolating specific actions. Unlike punishment, which can suppress behavior and cause fallout, positive reinforcement with clear markers builds confidence and a stronger partnership, ensuring behaviors are learned correctly from the start.

PREVENTING MISTAKES AND THE FIRST 24 HOURS

A core principle is preventing mistakes by managing the environment. This means removing temptations, such as shoes for a puppy to chew, and using confinement like crates or ex-pens. The first 24-48 hours with a new dog are critical for setting expectations. Intentionality is key: instead of reacting to unwanted behavior, proactively create an environment where the dog is set up for success, reinforcing desired actions early and consistently.

THE FALLOUT OF PUNISHMENT VS. THE BENEFITS OF REINFORCEMENT

Garrett strongly advocates against punishment, illustrating its negative long-term effects and limited success through analogies like speeding tickets. Punishment may suppress behavior temporarily but creates anxiety and can damage the handler-dog relationship. Conversely, consistent positive reinforcement, even for simple actions like going to the bathroom, builds a strong bond, increases the dog's desire to cooperate, and creates a more enjoyable experience for both. The 'chicken camp' analogy highlights how pure behavioral observation and reinforcement are essential, as chickens, like dogs, will shape the trainer if the mechanics are wrong.

MANAGING AROUSAL STATES FOR EFFECTIVE TRAINING

A dog's arousal state significantly impacts their ability to learn. Before formal training sessions, it's beneficial to elevate the dog's heart rate through play like tugging or short recalls. This 'gets them in the zone,' making them more focused and less susceptible to environmental distractions. Conversely, if a dog is over-aroused ('red-lining'), stepping back and simplifying the request in a less intense environment can help them regain composure. This principle of understanding and managing arousal applies to both training and preventing undesirable behaviors.

TRANSFERRING VALUE AND BUILDING A STRONG BOND

The core of successful training lies in transferring value to the handler. This is achieved not just by providing resources but by making the dog 'earn' them through desired actions. Hand-feeding meals, as Tim Ferriss experienced with his dog Molly, creates a powerful bond and reinforces the handler's value. This intentional use of reinforcement, where the handler becomes the source of all good things, is transferable to all relationships, making one a better partner, parent, and colleague by fostering a mindset of setting others up for success.

Mentioned in This Episode

●Supplements

●Products

●Software & Apps

●Companies

●Organizations

●Books

●Concepts

●People Referenced

Susan Garrett's Dog Training Principles Quick Reference

Practical takeaways from this episode

Do This

Be intentional and purposeful about what you want your dog's behavior to be.

Use choice-based, reinforcement-focused training methods (like Marine Mammal training).

Play foundational games: 'It's Your Choice,' Crate Games, Restraint Recalls, and Collar Grab Game.

Identify all forms of reinforcement for your dog: food, toys, and especially 'permission' to do desired activities.

Control access to reinforcement, ensuring desired behaviors are earned.

Make good things happen from the 'reinforcement zone' (e.g., your side) to build value for that position.

Use high-value treats in distracting environments and lower-value treats for easier tasks at home.

Conduct short, frequent training sessions (e.g., 3-5 minutes, 3-4 times a day).

Prevent mistakes by managing the environment (e.g., no shoes on floor, confined spaces).

Establish consistent potty training protocols: on-leash, quiet until completion, then reward.

Use a clicker as a precise 'marker' or 'bridge' for specific desired behaviors, always followed by a reward.

Start training early, as soon as a puppy or rescue dog comes home (first 24 hours are critical).

Elevate your dog's heart rate or 'arousal state' before training to enhance focus and engagement.

View failures as learning opportunities and adjust the training environment (e.g., reduce distractions).

Frame commands positively; tell your dog what to 'do,' not what 'don't' do.

Continuously teach your dog to offer behaviors, engaging them in problem-solving.

Avoid This

Avoid punishment-based training methods, as they suppress behavior and create negative fallout without fixing the root cause.

Do not leave food out for free access; make food and other reinforcements earned.

Do not reinforce unwanted behaviors (e.g., letting a dog pull on a leash and then releasing them to chase a squirrel).

Don't have marathon training sessions, especially with puppies, as they are ineffective.

Avoid interacting or playing with a puppy during nighttime potty breaks, as this reinforces waking up at night.

Don't reprimand your dog for house accidents; instead, immediately take them to the desired potty spot and reward success.

Do not use tethering to create a bond, as it removes choice and inspiration.

Don't jackpot with treats in expectation of better training results, as science suggests it has little value and can increase response variability.

Do not allow your dogs to act as 'Hooligans' and jump on guests; instead, train an alternative greeting behavior.

Avoid trainers who advocate being the 'boss' or using physically punishing or mentally intimidating methods.

Don't let dogs learn to tune out their name by overusing it without a reward; use a 'magic key' (treat) if kids use their name.

Common Questions

Susan Garrett's approach is choice-based and reinforcement-based, similar to training marine mammals. Dogs are given choices, and positive consequences follow desired behaviors, rather than using punishment.

Topics

Mental Health & Psychology Human Performance Mindset & Self-Improvement Relationship Building Animal Behavior Positive Reinforcement Operant Conditioning Dog Training Puppy Raising Behavioral Modification Agility Training

Mentioned in this video

People

Arnold Schwarzenegger

Public figure who wrote the foreword for Tim Ferriss's book, Tools of Titans.

Laird Hamilton

Skilled acrobat who introduced Tim Ferriss to Chaga mushroom.

Susan Garrett

Renowned dog trainer and competitor with a Bachelor's of Science in Animal Science, specializing in reinforcement-based, choice-driven training methods.

Greg Louganis

Gold medalist Olympic diver, competitive dog trainer, and Susan Garrett's student and friend; used clicker training for diving.

Peter Thiel

Public figure mentioned as a guest in Tools of Titans.

Gary Priest

Trainer credited with successfully shaping the behavior of a diabetic mandrill baboon at the San Diego Zoo to voluntarily receive insulin shots and blood draws.

Jason Nemer

Co-founder of AcroYoga, whose coaching philosophy Tim Ferriss compared to Susan Garrett's dog training principles.

Tony Robbins

Public figure mentioned as a guest in Tools of Titans.

Bob Bailey

A preeminent animal trainer and scientist, co-founder of dating back to Pavlovian experiments on animal training and a mentor to Susan Garrett.

Jamie Foxx

Public figure mentioned as a guest in Tools of Titans.

B.F. Skinner

Psychologist and behaviorist, mentioned as Marian Breland Bailey's graduate professor, known for his work on operant conditioning (Skinner box).

Ian Dunbar

Dog trainer who talks extensively about 'life rewards' or non-food-based rewards, and whose PDF on puppy preparation Tim Ferriss found helpful.

Karen Pryor

Author of 'Don't Shoot the Dog' and a pioneer in clicker training and marine mammal training, from whom Tim Ferriss learned about clickers.

Marian Breland Bailey

Graduated student of B.F. Skinner and preeminent animal trainer, co-founder of dating back to Pavlovian experiments on animal training and a mentor to Susan Garrett.

Companies

YouTube

Platform where Susan Garrett hosts a video called 'The Journey' about dogs teaching owners, and other free resources.

Apple

Technology company mentioned as a place where technologists from Wealthfront have worked.

Wealthfront

An investing service that uses software to provide services typically reserved for the ultra-wealthy at lower costs, mentioned as a disruptive sponsor.

Organizations

San Diego Zoo

Zoo where a drill (mandrill baboon) with diabetes was successfully trained using positive reinforcement for medical procedures.

SEC

Government body whose regulations prevent companies managing client money from using client testimonials.

Toronto Zoo

Zoo where Susan Garrett's students train animals using the same choice-based reinforcement premise.

Products

ORIJEN

A brand of high-quality kibble used by Susan Garrett as a lower-value treat for training in less distracting environments.

X-pen

A portable, collapsible pen used to create a 'gated community' or contained area for puppies to prevent mistakes and manage their environment.

Kong

A durable, stuffable dog toy recommended as an essential tool for new dog owners.

Nature's Miracle

A cleaning product recommended for cleaning up pet accidents to eliminate odors that attract dogs back to the same spot.

Stella & Chewy's

A brand of freeze-dried dog food patties (lamb or rabbit) that Tim Ferriss uses for hand feeding Molly, emphasizing its quality.

Gentle Leader

A brand of head halter recommended as a good tool for managing exuberant rescue dogs.

Books

Tools of Titans

Tim Ferriss's book featuring tips, tricks, tools, and tactics from over 200 guests on his podcast, including new material and insights applied to his own life.

Don't Shoot the Dog

A book mentioned by Tim Ferriss in relation to behavioral modification and conditioning, which he borrowed an analogy from.

Shaping Success

Susan Garrett's book which was voted the 2005 dog training and behavior book of the year.

Supplements

Chaga Mushroom

A powerful antioxidant mushroom considered a superfood, used in For Sigmatic coffee.

Lion's Mane mushroom

A mushroom considered a nootropic or smart drug, also found in For Sigmatic products.

Software & Apps

Clicker

A training device that acts as an 'audio scalpel' or 'bridge' to precisely mark desired behaviors, promising a subsequent reward.

dogslisten.com

Susan Garrett's website where listeners of the podcast can access a complimentary ebook version of 'It's Your Choice' and learn more about her training philosophy.

Susan Garrett Dog Agility

Susan Garrett's blog and website, offering a ton of free resources and valuable content on dog training and agility.

Concepts

Flyball

Another dog sport where false starts are a significant part of the equation, in which Susan Garrett won World Championships.

Kettlebell Challenge

A fitness challenge mentioned by Tim Ferriss to illustrate the importance of good form from the start, akin to dog training.

AcroYoga

A practice involving partner acrobatics, whose co-founder (Jason Nemer) emphasized telling partners what you *do* want, not what you *don't* want, similar to dog training.

Media

The Chipmunks

A video by Bob Bailey documenting some of his animal training experiments.

ESPN

Sports television channel that used to broadcast dog agility events.