How did William J. Perry contribute to U.S. nuclear policy during the Cold War?

William J. Perry advised presidents anonymously and later as Secretary of Defense, overseeing strategic nuclear system development and directly contributing to intelligence assessment during the Cuban Missile Crisis.

What lessons did William J. Perry draw from the Cuban Missile Crisis regarding tactical nuclear weapons?

Perry learned that tactical nuclear missiles loaded with warheads were already operational in Cuba, and the local military commander had authority to use them, making the crisis far more dangerous than Kennedy or the public realized at the time, with a greater than 50/50 chance of catastrophic nuclear war.

How did President Truman's view on bombing Hiroshima and Nagasaki evolve?

Truman was not informed about the Manhattan Project until he became president. Generals initially misled him about military targeting, and it wasn't until reports of hundreds of thousands of deaths from Nagasaki came in that he intervened, stopped further bombings, and transferred nuclear authority from the military to civilian control.

Why is accidental nuclear war considered a greater threat than a deliberate first strike?

Decades of focus on a 'bolt out of the blue' surprise attack overlooked the real danger of accidental war from political miscalculation or technical errors. Multiple false alarms and incidents, such as a bear triggering an alarm during the Cuban Missile Crisis, demonstrate how easily such a blunder could occur.

What is the danger of nuclear terrorism and how has it been addressed?

Nuclear terrorism, even with a low-tech, single bomb attack, could cause catastrophic casualties, panic, economic collapse, and government decapitation. President Obama's program to improve safeguards on fissile material has substantially reduced the likelihood of terror groups acquiring nuclear bombs.

Why is presidential sole authority over nuclear weapons a concern, and what legislative changes are proposed?

Entrusting a launch decision to a single president, especially under rapid time constraints, is highly dangerous given potential psychological issues, misinformation, or personal derangement. Proposed legislation by Congressman Ted Lieu and Senator Edward Markey aims to end presidential sole authority and implement a no-first-use policy, requiring Congressional approval for a launch unless responding to an active attack.

What is the Nunn-Lugar program and what was its impact?

The Nunn-Lugar program, championed by William J. Perry, was a post-Cold War U.S. initiative to help former Soviet countries like Ukraine, Belarus, and Kazakhstan dismantle their nuclear weapons and secure fissile materials. It successfully eliminated all nuclear weapons in these countries and repurposed some material for nuclear power, with 10% of U.S. electricity for a decade coming from blended-down Soviet missiles.

What is the UN Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons and its significance?

This UN treaty, championed by ICAN (Nobel Peace Prize winner), aims to legally ban nuclear weapons entirely. While not yet ratified by all nuclear states, it sets a global standard and provides non-nuclear states a voice in an issue that affects everyone, drawing inspiration from the successful Landmine Ban Treaty.

What are the concrete steps that can be taken to reduce nuclear weapons dangers?

Achievable steps include ending presidential sole authority, prohibiting 'first use' and 'launch on warning' policies, retiring all ICBMs (maintaining deterrence with submarine and air forces), limiting strategic missile defense, and electing leaders committed to these issues. Public education and support for organizations like the Nuclear Threat Initiative and Ploughshares Fund are crucial.

Key Moments

The Logic of Doomsday: A Conversation with William J. Perry (Episode #210)

Sam Harris

Science & Technology5 min read107 min video

Jul 10, 2020|194,609 views|2,823|617

sam harris sam harris podcast waking up podcast waking up waking up with sam harris sam harris waking up waking up sam harris sam harris jordan peterson sam harris joe rogan author neuroscientist philosopher

Save to Pod

Key Moments

On this page

TL;DR

Nuclear war poses an existential threat; accidental war is more likely than deliberate attack.

Key Insights

The risk of accidental or miscalculated nuclear war is the greatest existential threat facing humanity, yet it is largely overlooked.

Despite the immense destructive power of nuclear weapons, humanity has developed a dangerous psychological capacity to ignore the threat, a phenomenon termed 'thinking about the unthinkable.'

The Cuban Missile Crisis was far more dangerous than publicly known, with the presence of operational tactical nuclear weapons significantly increasing the likelihood of full-scale nuclear war.

The logic of deterrence, while seemingly stable, is vulnerable to technical errors, misinformation, and irrational actors, making accidental war a persistent and grave danger.

Nuclear terrorism, though distinct from state-level deterrence, presents a significant threat, with efforts to secure fissile material being a crucial area of progress.

While complete nuclear disarmament may be distant, concrete steps like eliminating ICBMs, renouncing first-use policies, and limiting presidential sole authority can significantly reduce the immediate risks.

THE FORGOTTEN EXISTENTIAL THREAT

The conversation highlights that the most significant risk to humanity is not a deliberate nuclear attack, but rather stumbling into nuclear war through accident, miscalculation, or technical error. This danger is amplified by a widespread public and political ignorance of the issue, akin to living in a rigged environment without acknowledging the danger. The 75th anniversary of the atomic bomb serves as a stark reminder of this ongoing, yet largely ignored, peril.

LESSONS FROM THE BRINK: THE CUBAN MISSILE CRISIS

William J. Perry recounts his direct involvement in the Cuban Missile Crisis of 1962, revealing that the situation was far more perilous than understood at the time. Unbeknownst to President Kennedy, operational tactical nuclear weapons were already deployed in Cuba. Had the US initiated a military attack as advised by some, the use of these tactical nukes would have likely triggered a full-scale nuclear exchange, increasing the probability of catastrophe to over 50% in Perry's assessment.

THE PSYCHOLOGY OF DENIAL AND DETERRENCE

The discussion delves into the psychological difficulty of confronting the unthinkable nature of nuclear holocaust. Jonathan Schell's 'The Fate of the Earth' is cited, noting humanity's peculiar failure to respond adequately to the threat, a phenomenon that violates both self-interest and fellow-feeling. While denial is a survival mechanism, the persistent risk of accidental war, compounded by the logic of deterrence, makes the current status quo untenable, especially with the increasing threat of cyber attacks.

NUCLEAR TERRORISM AND THE NEED FOR GLOBAL COOPERATION

The threat of nuclear terrorism is examined as a distinct but equally grave concern. While states operate under a logic of deterrence based on rational actors, terrorist groups may not. The potential for a single nuclear detonation, even a relatively low-tech one, could cause catastrophic casualties, decapitate governments, and create widespread panic. Although securing fissile material is challenging, advancements made through programs like those initiated by President Obama have somewhat mitigated this risk.

CHALLENGING THE STATUS QUO: POLICY AND PRACTICAL STEPS

The conversation emphasizes that change is possible, contrary to a sense of fatalism. Concrete actions can significantly reduce the risk of nuclear catastrophe. This includes ending presidential sole authority over nuclear weapons, prohibiting 'launch on warning' and 'first use' policies, and retiring land-based ICBMs, which are inherently first-strike weapons. These steps would not only lower the risk of accidental war but also save immense financial resources.

REDUCING RISK THROUGH EDUCATION AND POLITICAL ACTION

The importance of public education is paramount, as ignorance fuels the continuation of dangerous policies. Organizations like the William J. Perry Project, the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, and the Nuclear Threat Initiative work to raise awareness and advocate for policy changes. Empowering individuals to educate themselves and support these organizations creates the political will necessary for leaders to enact measures that can lead to a world with reduced nuclear danger.

POLICY IMPLICATIONS AND THE ROLE OF TECHNOLOGY

The discussion touches upon the complexities of strategic missile defense, which is argued to be largely ineffective and potentially destabilizing by incentivizing offensive capabilities. Furthermore, emerging technologies like cyber warfare are seen as exacerbating risks by potentially disrupting command and control systems, rather than mitigating them. The development of low-yield tactical nuclear weapons is also a concern, as it may lower the threshold for their use and escalate conflicts.

THE GLOBAL MOVEMENT FOR NUCLEAR ABOLITION

The Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (TPNW), inspired by the success of landmine ban treaties, represents a significant effort by non-nuclear states to establish a global norm against nuclear weapons. While nuclear-armed states have not joined, this initiative provides a crucial framework and expresses the will of the majority of the world's nations who are subject to the risks posed by a few nuclear powers. This movement emphasizes that even incremental steps towards disarmament are valuable.

THE CATASTROPHIC CONSEQUENCES OF LIMITED NUCLEAR EXCHANGE

Even a limited nuclear exchange, such as between India and Pakistan involving around 100 nuclear weapons, could have devastating global consequences. Beyond the millions of immediate casualties, the resulting atmospheric debris could trigger a 'nuclear winter,' leading to a drastic drop in global temperatures, widespread crop failures, and mass starvation affecting billions. This underscores the interconnectedness of global security and the existential threat posed by any nuclear war.

THE UNTENABILITY OF THE STATUS QUO AND PATHWAYS FORWARD

The current status quo, characterized by a 'doomsday machine' poised to detonate due to misinformation, is fundamentally untenable. While complete nuclear disarmament may seem distant, maintaining the current level of risk is unsustainable. The conversation advocates for focusing on achievable steps, such as reducing nuclear arsenals, retiring ICBMs, and electing leaders committed to de-escalation, to significantly decrease immediate dangers while working towards the long-term goal of a world free from nuclear weapons.

Mentioned in This Episode

●Organizations

●Books

●Concepts

●People Referenced

Common Questions

The prospect of blundering into a nuclear war, either by accident or political miscalculation, is considered the greatest risk, compounded by public unawareness.

Topics

Nuclear Deterrence Nuclear War Mindset & Self-Improvement Science & Mathematics History & Geopolitics Nuclear Proliferation Presidential Power Nuclear Winter Politics & Policy Accidental Nuclear War Nuclear Terrorism Command And Control

Mentioned in this video

Books

The Fate of the Earth

A book that originated as an article in The New Yorker in 1982, it compellingly describes the potential horror of nuclear war and the human tendency to deny its implications.

The Button: The New Nuclear Arms Race and Presidential Power from Truman to Trump

William J. Perry's book that delves into the dangerous history and current terrifying status quo of nuclear weapons and presidential power.

Media

At the Brink

A podcast by Lisa Perry dedicated to discussing her grandfather's work and educating the public about the ongoing dangers of nuclear weapons.

Concepts

Doomsday Clock

A symbolic clock maintained by the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists that represents humanity's proximity to self-annihilation, currently at 100 seconds to midnight.

Hiroshima

The first Japanese city targeted by an atomic bomb in World War II, discussed for its historical significance and the number of casualties.

Locations

Ukraine

A former Soviet country that became the third largest nuclear weapon state overnight after the collapse of the Soviet Union, with its weapons dismantled under the Nunn-Lugar program.

Pakistan

A country mentioned as a nuclear power that acquired weapons for security reasons, and a potential site for a limited nuclear exchange leading to global effects.

Nagasaki

The second Japanese city to be hit by an atomic bomb, with its bombing's justification being debated in the context of the end of World War II.

Duluth, Minnesota

Site of an airbase incident during the Cuban Missile Crisis where a false alarm was triggered by a bear, nearly leading to a nuclear launch.

Iran

A country mentioned concerning its nuclear deal and potential for a dual-use nuclear program, and a possible blundering point for nuclear exchange.

North Korea

A country discussed as a nuclear power that sought nuclear weapons for security reasons against perceived threats, and a potential blundering point for nuclear exchange.

Turkey

The country from which U.S. nuclear missiles were secretly removed as part of the de-escalation deal during the Cuban Missile Crisis.

Kazakhstan

A former Soviet country whose nuclear weapons were dismantled under the Nunn-Lugar program.

India

A country mentioned as a nuclear power that acquired weapons for security reasons, and a potential site for a limited nuclear exchange leading to global effects.

Belarus

A former Soviet country whose nuclear weapons were dismantled under the Nunn-Lugar program.

People

Harry S. Truman

The U.S. President who made the decision to use atomic bombs against Japan and later established presidential sole authority over nuclear weapons.

Fred Kaplan

Author of a book focusing on each administration's nuclear policy, who discussed Kennedy's experience during the Cuban Missile Crisis.

Lisa Perry

Communications director for the William J. Perry project and granddaughter of William J. Perry, dedicated to raising public awareness about nuclear threats through her podcast 'At the Brink'.

Bill Clinton

The President under whom William J. Perry served as Secretary of Defense.

Jimmy Carter

Former U.S. President whom William J. Perry personally advised on nuclear issues; later, Carter was nearly woken up to make a launch decision during a false alarm.

Barack Obama

U.S. President who instituted a program for nuclear powers to improve safeguards on fissile material and also approved the nuclear modernization program.

Richard Nixon

U.S. President mentioned for heavy drinking in the last month of his presidency, raising concerns about compromised decision-making power over nuclear weapons.

Jonathan Schell

Author of 'The Fate of the Earth,' a book that explores the devastating consequences of nuclear war and the psychological challenge of confronting this threat.

William J. Perry

Former U.S. Under Secretary of Defense for Research and Engineering in the Carter Administration and Secretary of Defense under President Clinton, who founded the William J. Perry Project to educate the public on nuclear dangers.

Fidel Castro

The leader of Cuba during the Cuban Missile Crisis.

Edward Markey

U.S. Senator (misidentified as Congressman in transcript) who has put forth legislation to limit presidential sole authority to launch nuclear weapons.

Sam Nunn

U.S. Senator and namesake of the Nunn-Lugar program, who championed efforts to dismantle nuclear weapons in former Soviet countries.

Donald Trump

The U.S. President whose rhetoric and actions regarding nuclear weapons raised concerns about the risks of presidential sole authority.

Bruce Blair

A nuclear security professor and founder of Global Zero, who, as a former nuclear missileer, attested to the rigorous training of missile crews to launch weapons quickly and without question once an order is confirmed.

Zbigniew Brzezinski

President Carter's National Security Advisor who received a false alarm call about incoming missiles but waited for more information before waking the president.

Beatrice Fihn

Head of ICAN, a highly intelligent woman championing the ban on nuclear weapons.

Dwight D. Eisenhower

Former U.S. President during whose administration William J. Perry was involved as a consultant on nuclear issues.

Ronald Reagan

U.S. President who may have mistakenly believed that ICBMs could be recalled after launch.

John F. Kennedy

U.S. President during the Cuban Missile Crisis, who was under pressure to take military action and whose decisions ultimately averted nuclear war. Also mentioned for his heavy medication use.

Nikita Khrushchev

The Soviet leader during the Cuban Missile Crisis, who along with Kennedy, participated in a back-channel deal to de-escalate the situation.

Ted Lieu

U.S. Congressman who has put forth legislation to limit presidential sole authority to launch nuclear weapons.

Organizations

Stanford University

Where William J. Perry serves as an emeritus professor.

Carter Administration

The presidential administration during which William J. Perry served as Under Secretary of Defense for Research and Engineering.

William J. Perry Project

Founded by William J. Perry in 2015, this project aims to educate the public on the urgent need to reduce nuclear weapons dangers.

CIA

The U.S. intelligence agency whose Deputy Director called William J. Perry to Washington to help assess intelligence during the Cuban Missile Crisis.

The New Yorker

The magazine in which Jonathan Schell's 'The Fate of the Earth' was originally published.

Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists

The organization that maintains the Doomsday Clock and publishes assessments on nuclear dangers, based in Chicago.

North American Air Defense Command

The command center that issued a false alarm of 200 incoming Soviet ICBMs in 1979 to William J. Perry, illustrating the danger of accidental launch.

Global Zero

An international initiative for the elimination of nuclear weapons, co-founded by Bruce Blair.

National Military Command Center

The center through which presidential orders to launch nuclear weapons would pass, before reaching missile crews.

United Nations

The international body where a treaty banning nuclear weapons was passed, although it has not yet been fully ratified by all countries.

Nuclear Threat Initiative

An important Washington D.C.-based organization that works to eliminate nuclear dangers and minimize their risks, recommended for public support.

International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons

An organization that led the successful legal push for the UN Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons, for which it was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize.

Strategic Command

Former generals from this command claimed the military would not follow any unlawful order concerning nuclear launches, a claim debated for its legal interpretation.

Al-Qaeda

A terrorist organization discussed in the context of concerns about their potential acquisition of nuclear materials from former Soviet republics after 9/11.

Ploughshares Fund

A San Francisco-based organization specifically focused on reducing the danger of nuclear weapons by supporting other organizations working towards this goal, recommended for public support.

Legislation & Policy

Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons

A treaty passed at the UN to ban nuclear weapons entirely, currently awaiting ratification, championed by ICAN.

Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty

A treaty where non-nuclear powers agree not to go nuclear in return for nuclear powers working towards phasing out and decreasing their nuclear capabilities, currently under threat due to the actions of nuclear powers.

Nunn-Lugar Cooperative Threat Reduction Program

A program championed by William J. Perry during his tenure as Secretary of Defense, which helped secure and dismantle nuclear weapons in former Soviet countries after the collapse of the Soviet Union.

Iran Nuclear Deal

An agreement that gained the U.S. some nuclear security by constraining Iran's nuclear program. Its rescission was considered a major step backward.

Treaty to Ban Landmines

A successful treaty that served as the model for the UN Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons, demonstrating that such bans can be effective.

New START Treaty

A treaty that aimed to limit the number of deployed strategic nuclear warheads between the US and Russia, passed under Obama.