What were the biggest mistakes The Muse made early on?

The Muse initially aimed to build a highly complex product with many features, delaying their launch past the point of market readiness. They also hired talent without sufficient culture fit vetting.

What does 'evolution from suck to suck less' mean for startups?

It means that most startups begin in a rough, unpolished state (suck) and gradually improve over time, becoming less problematic (suck less). It acknowledges the scrappy MVP roots that are often hidden in successful companies.

Why is it important to launch an imperfect product?

Launching an imperfect product allows for crucial user feedback and data collection. Waiting for perfection can lead to running out of resources or missing market opportunities, as seen with The Muse's early approach.

How did The Muse acquire users when they were on a tight budget?

The Muse focused on cost-effective strategies such as reaching out to like-minded groups, making it easy for people to share their content, and acting as their own PR machine by writing guest posts.

What is key to building a strong startup team?

Beyond salary, a strong team is built by recruiting individuals passionate about the mission and focusing on their personal and professional development goals. Leading by example is also crucial.

Why should founders not believe the startup hype?

The startup world often features vanity metrics and external validation like funding announcements. True success comes from deeply meeting user needs, which can be seen through user acquisition and retention, not just media buzz.

Key Moments

Kathryn Minshew at Female Founders Conference 2014

Y Combinator

Science & Technology6 min read19 min video

Mar 12, 2014|7,176 views|70

Female Founders Conference Y Combinator YC Female Founders Kathryn Minshew The Muse

Save to Pod

Key Moments

TL;DR

The Muse founder learned that launching an ugly MVP and seeking user feedback, even from those who criticize it, is crucial for startup survival and growth, as vanity metrics and hype are ultimately irrelevant.

Key Insights

The Muse launched with a customized WordPress theme, not a custom-built product, and saw 20,000 visitors in the first month, demonstrating early product-market fit.

Y Combinator partner Paul Graham famously told The Muse founders, 'that's ridiculous. you will never get that out the door. You need to just [expletive] launch already,' a pivotal moment for their MVP approach.

The Muse initially focused testing on user engagement with videos, but realized through YC office hours that core metrics like application rates and site sharing were more important for success.

To acquire users, The Muse personally reached out to niche groups like 'Stanford Women in Law Group' and 'Baldwin Scholars of Duke,' making it easy for them to share.

Kathryn Minshew highlighted that if The Muse had waited until its product looked like its current version (as shown in a comparison) before launching, they would have failed.

Minshew cited her own experience pitching Forbes for guest posts over a full year before getting published, emphasizing persistence in content creation as a PR strategy.

From personal pain to a career platform for the lost

Kathryn Minshew's journey to founding The Muse stemmed from her own career uncertainty. Initially aspiring to join the CIA after being inspired by the TV show 'Alias,' her internship at a US embassy in Cyprus and subsequent work in vaccines revealed a significant disconnect between career expectations and reality. This personal pain point, shared with her co-founders Alex and Melissa, highlighted a gap in the market for a platform that could guide individuals through non-linear career paths. Before the Muse, they had tried another startup and even gained admission to Y Combinator, but decided to pivot to The Muse, recognizing a substantial need for accessible career advice and company insights.

The 'ugly duckling' MVP and the power of launching early

The Muse's initial product was far from polished, described by Minshew as an 'ugly duckling.' Built on a customized WordPress theme in September 2011, it offered career advice and, through a hacked-together form, job listings from companies like Uber. Despite its rudimentary state, the site attracted significant user growth, with 20,000 visitors in the first month, escalating to 75,000 by the third. This early traction validated their concept, even as investors initially dismissed their target market as too small. The lesson was clear: an imperfect Minimum Viable Product (MVP) launched quickly can provide invaluable user data, a stark contrast to the myth of perfecting a product in isolation. Minshew recalled Y Combinator partner Paul Graham's blunt advice post-acceptance: 'that's ridiculous. you will never get that out the door. You need to just [expletive] launch already.' This was a critical turning point, pushing them to release a basic version within 13 days of getting accepted into YC, later launching officially on TechCrunch.

Focusing on core metrics, not vanity experiments

Early in The Muse's development, the team became engrossed in tracking granular user behavior, using tools like Mixpanel and Crazy Egg. They noticed that a segment of users weren't watching the embedded employee testimonial videos on company profiles, and began extensive A/B testing to increase video engagement. However, during Y Combinator office hours, a partner questioned the fundamental importance of video watch rates. This prompted a crucial reflection: were these experiments driving the core business goals? The team realized that while video engagement might correlate with other positive actions, it wasn't a primary success metric itself. Their focus shifted to understanding what truly drove user acquisition, retention, and job applications, redirecting efforts from optimizing secondary features to those that directly impacted the company's bottom line.

Acquiring users through targeted outreach and frictionless sharing

Minshew emphasized that user acquisition requires proactive effort, particularly when starting from scratch with limited resources. The Muse employed several cost-effective strategies. First, they identified and personally contacted like-minded groups, such as 'Stanford Women in Law' and 'Duke's Baldwin Scholars,' to introduce The Muse and request feedback and sharing opportunities. This personalized approach made users feel valued and encouraging. Second, they made word-of-mouth sharing incredibly easy. Instead of simply asking people to spread the word, they provided ready-to-use sample tweets and social media posts. This drastically reduced the effort required for endorsement, significantly increasing the likelihood of users sharing the platform. This strategy acknowledged that while people are often willing to help, making the process effortless is key to converting that willingness into action.

Building brand presence through content and persistence

Recognizing that media outlets were initially uninterested in a new startup, Minshew adopted a proactive PR strategy: becoming her own content creator. She began writing guest posts for platforms like The Huffington Post and eventually pitched other publications, including Forbes and the Harvard Business Review. While some pitches were initially rejected, Minshew persisted, demonstrating the value of long-term content marketing for building brand recognition and improving Search Engine Optimization (SEO). Even after a year of outreach, she was willing to follow up, eventually securing opportunities that provided backlinks and visibility for The Muse, a testament to the power of consistent outbound effort.

Assembling a mission-driven team

The Muse prioritized building a team united by passion for the mission rather than solely offering high salaries. Minshew admitted they often couldn't compete with top offers from larger companies. Instead, they focused on understanding individual team members' personal and professional growth aspirations. During the hiring process, they asked candidates about their broader interests outside their core job functions, such as speaking to women in tech or learning more about marketing. The company committed to supporting these ambitions, recognizing that fostering individual development is a powerful motivator. Minshew and her co-founders also led by example, taking lower salaries than their employees, reinforcing their commitment to the long-term vision and fostering a strong, dedicated team culture.

Navigating the startup landscape: ignore the hype

Minshew concluded with a strong caution against being swayed by the 'hype' prevalent in the startup world—funding announcements, inflated user numbers, and media attention. She stressed that 'vanity metrics' are often misleading and can distract from the fundamental goal of building something users genuinely need and love. The true measure of success, she argued, is a deep understanding of the user base and consistent delivery of value that resonates with them. By focusing on authentic user needs and organic growth, a startup can slowly but surely build a substantial user base, becoming resilient and difficult to ignore, regardless of external validation or media narratives. She encouraged founders to trust their user data over external opinions, asserting that those who initially doubted or dismissed their efforts become irrelevant once success is achieved.

Mentioned in This Episode

●Software & Apps

●Companies

●Organizations

●People Referenced

Startup Launch and Growth Strategies

Practical takeaways from this episode

Do This

Start with an MVP, even if imperfect.

Seek feedback from your target demographic.

Test key metrics that drive success.

Create user acquisition velocity.

Focus on building a passionate team.

Write guest content for media platforms.

Make it easy for people to share your product.

Target like-minded groups for initial outreach.

Understand individual employee goals and connect them to opportunities.

Lead by example, especially regarding compensation.

Lurk on platforms like Hacker News and Twitter for potential hires.

Focus on the user and the needs you fulfill.

Avoid This

Wait for a perfect product before launching.

Rely solely on friends and family for feedback.

Get distracted by vanity metrics.

Expect users to find you without effort.

Offer the highest salary as the primary draw.

Ignore potential hires from struggling startups.

Believe all the startup hype; focus on user value.

Common Questions

The Muse is a career platform and job discovery tool founded by Kathryn Minshew. It provides career advice, insights into company cultures, and day-in-the-life perspectives from employees.