How have economic shifts like digitalization contributed to social unrest?

The economy's shift from manufacturing and manual labor to finance and digital sectors has diminished the status and prospects of many, particularly the baby boomer generation. This slowdown in social mobility and the concentration of rewards in a small group fuels dissatisfaction.

Is wealth inequality the primary driver of modern populism?

While wealth inequality is significant, other factors like diminished social mobility, access to basic amenities (healthcare, education), and perceived unfairness in opportunity are more troubling drivers. These create a sense of grievance even if absolute living standards improve.

What is the difference between philanthropy and taxation in addressing inequality?

While philanthropy is voluntary giving, taxation is a mechanism to ensure broader societal contributions. Many wealthy individuals prefer philanthropy, but it's often insufficient compared to what could be raised through fair taxation, which funds essential public services.

How can trust in government be rebuilt?

Trust in government can be rebuilt through visible successes in tackling major problems like public health crises or climate change. It also requires elites to cooperate on common goals rather than engaging in partisan battles and ensuring the tax system is perceived as fair.

What is the negative impact of 'cosmopolitanism' on national cohesion?

While a global perspective isn't inherently bad, overemphasis on it can blind elites to suffering within their own countries. This detachment from domestic issues and people can erode the principles necessary for a functional democracy.

Why has life expectancy declined in the US and UK?

Declines in life expectancy between 2015-2018 in the US and UK were linked to 'deaths of despair,' including opioid addiction, alcoholism, and suicide. This trend was also a predictor of populist voting, indicating widespread community and personal dissatisfaction.

What can California do about the 'brain drain' due to taxes?

The migration of high earners to states with no income tax highlights how tax systems can be gamed. While specific solutions weren't detailed, the discussion points to the need for fair tax enforcement and potentially inter-state cooperation on taxation.

Key Moments

Inequality And Revolution: A Conversation with Jack Goldstone (Episode #232)

Sam Harris

Science & Technology4 min read43 min video

Feb 2, 2021|74,543 views|1,545|897

sam harris sam harris podcast waking up podcast waking up waking up with sam harris sam harris waking up waking up sam harris sam harris jordan peterson sam harris joe rogan author neuroscientist philosopher

Save to Pod

Key Moments

TL;DR

Rising inequality and loss of social cohesion fuel political instability, threatening democracy globally.

Key Insights

Societal collapse is often linked to elites prioritizing personal wealth over public welfare, leading to widespread anger and instability.

Donald Trump is more an exacerbator than a cause of current political instability, which stems from global economic shifts over the last 30 years.

Inequality isn't solely about wealth; disparities in opportunity, social mobility, and access to basic amenities like healthcare and education are critical drivers of discontent.

Elites' increasing detachment from broader society and focus on personal gain erodes trust in institutions and the concept of public service.

Restoring trust in government requires visible, successful public programs and cooperation among elites to find common ground for societal improvement.

Fairness in the tax system, where the wealthy pay their 'fair share' and systems aren't easily gamed, is crucial for public belief in governance.

THE HISTORICAL PATTERN OF SOCIETAL COLLAPSE

Jack Goldstone explains that historical patterns, dating back to ancient Rome, show that societies flourish when their elites work for the common good and national strength. Conversely, when the wealthy and powerful focus solely on accumulating and protecting their own assets at the expense of others, societies tend to decline. This pattern is exacerbated when elites become competitive, prioritizing personal status over societal well-being, leading to public anger as people feel left behind and neglected by their government.

GLOBAL TRENDS AND AMERICAN INSTABILITY

The current wave of populism, anti-globalism, and loss of trust in institutions is a global phenomenon. Goldstone argues that U.S. political instability, exemplified by events like the January 6th Capitol attack, is not solely due to figures like Donald Trump, but rather a symptom of deeper, longer-term shifts. These shifts include technological changes and economic restructuring over the past 30 years, which have altered the nature of work and wealth creation.

ECONOMIC SHIFTS AND THE EROSION OF SOCIAL COHESION

The transition from a manufacturing-based economy to one dominated by high finance and digital industries has left behind many in the post-war generations who valued manual labor. While large metropolitan areas may continue to thrive, smaller towns and rural areas that were once the industrial heartland have suffered. This economic displacement, coupled with challenges in accessing affordable education and healthcare, has reduced social mobility and diminished the life prospects for many, fostering a sense of grievance.

THE MULTIFACETED NATURE OF INEQUALITY

Goldstone clarifies that inequality extends beyond mere wealth disparity. Crucial factors include inequalities in opportunity, social mobility, and access to essential 'middle-class amenities' such as safe neighborhoods, quality education, and healthcare. Even if absolute living standards improve for some, a widening gap between the rich and the rest fuels public discontent. This is particularly true when the wealthy use their resources to influence government policy, rather than investing in societal improvements.

COSMOPOLITANISM AND THE DETACHMENT OF ELITES

The increasing cosmopolitanism of elites, characterized by global networking and participation in exclusive events, can lead to a detachment from the everyday concerns of their own societies. While a global perspective is necessary for addressing global challenges, it can inadvertently blind elites to critical domestic issues. This detachment is problematic when it coincides with declining life expectancies and 'deaths of despair' in certain populations, a trend that predates political figures like Trump and partially explains his rise.

RESTORING TRUST AND FAIRNESS IN GOVERNANCE

Addressing the current crisis requires three key actions: restoring public trust in government's ability to solve problems, fostering cooperation among elites across political divides, and ensuring a perception of fairness in the system. This includes implementing a tax code where the wealthy contribute their fair share and avoiding loopholes that allow assets and income to escape taxation. Visible successes in public programs, like effective pandemic response, can help rebuild trust, demonstrating that government can indeed be a force for good.

LEADERSHIP, EMPATHY, AND THE FUTURE OF DEMOCRACY

Rejuvenating democracy hinges on leaders demonstrating empathy and a genuine commitment to public service, working for the betterment of all citizens rather than specific interest groups. When governments are perceived as working for the broad public good, like through accessible healthcare or education, public trust can be rebuilt. Conversely, elite selfishness and a lack of understanding of the struggles faced by ordinary people can lead to societal decay and instability, underscoring the need for a return to principles of shared prosperity and collective well-being.

Mentioned in This Episode

●Organizations

●People Referenced

Common Questions

Jack Goldstone explains that societies often collapse when elites prioritize their own wealth over the well-being of the broader population. This leads to widespread anger and a search for radical movements, especially when social mobility declines and people feel left behind.