How is Trump's approach to immigration described as alarming?

While some agree with his policy goals, the alarm stems from the aggressive and often lawless manner of imposition, including masked ICE officers raiding workplaces and detaining individuals without proper charges. This is seen as a 'show of force' rather than strict adherence to law.

Is the current level of crime in the US a national emergency?

The discussion suggests that while crime is a concern, the portrayal of it as a national emergency is exaggerated, particularly regarding left-wing violence. Historical data shows homicide rates in major cities are significantly lower than in the past, and current left-wing activity does not resemble past periods of organized terrorism.

What is Steven Miller's role in the current political climate?

Steven Miller is described as a key advisor to Trump who is eager to use any sign of left-wing violence as a pretext to clamp down on political dissent. His rhetoric is characterized as inflammatory and the stories he tells about left-wing terrorism are considered 'delusional.'

How has the left responded to federal government actions like ICE raids?

Despite provocations such as masked ICE operations and aggressive tactics, the left has been 'remarkably restrained' in terms of widespread violence and riots. This is contrasted with the summer of 2020 protests, suggesting less extreme behavior now given the circumstances.

Why are some scholars accused of alarmism regarding political trends?

Scholars like Timothy Snyder and Applebaum are labeled alarmists by some because they draw parallels to historical authoritarian regimes or fascism. Critics argue that the current situation, particularly with Trump, is more akin to 'reality TV' or theater, and does not represent a genuine threat of systemic oppression.

What is the global context of right-wing populism?

The video notes that right-wing populism is not solely an American problem but a 'global sickness' observable across Western democracies. The 'woke' movement is mentioned as something that inadvertently fuels this populist movement.

Key Moments

How We're Losing Our Democracy (Making Sense Ep. 439)

Sam Harris

Science & Technology3 min read25 min video

Oct 14, 2025|36,132 views|793|467

sam harris sam harris podcast waking up podcast waking up waking up with sam harris sam harris waking up waking up sam harris sam harris jordan peterson sam harris joe rogan author neuroscientist philosopher

Save to Pod

Key Moments

TL;DR

Damon Linker and Sam Harris discuss the erosion of American democracy, focusing on Trump's tactics and their dangerous potential.

Key Insights

Trump's use of immigration policy and law enforcement displays is designed to provoke a left-wing reaction, justifying increased government power.

The rhetoric and actions of figures like Steven Miller, focusing on manufactured left-wing terrorism, contribute to a dangerous political climate.

While crime rates have decreased from historical highs, the Trump administration frames current issues as national emergencies to enable authoritarian measures.

The left has shown remarkable restraint in the face of federal government provocations, contrasting with past instances of left-wing unrest.

Right-wing populism is a global phenomenon, and its manifestation in the US, amplified by 'woke' culture, threatens democratic norms.

The political discourse suffers from a lack of shared reality, with some dismissing genuine threats as mere 'theater' or 'alarmism'.

DEFINING THE THREAT: TYRANNICAL SOULS AND CIVIL UNREST

Sam Harris and Damon Linker begin by acknowledging the shared concern over the state of American democracy. Linker, a political commentator and professor, describes himself as center-left, a shift from his earlier conservative roots. He frames his current political stance as an aversion to the current direction of the political right. Both commentators aim for a sober, clear-eyed analysis rather than alarmism, emphasizing the need to confront what their political opponents truly desire: the displacement of their adversaries.

TRUMP'S STRATEGY: IMMIGRATION AS A PRETEXT FOR POWER

A key concern is Donald Trump's approach to immigration and law enforcement, which Linker views as a calculated 'show of force' designed to elicit a violent response from the left. While acknowledging that Trump is implementing policies he campaigned on and that deportation numbers may not be historically astronomical, the method of enforcement—masked ICE officers, raids on employers, detention without proper charges—is seen as over-the-top and aggressive. This tactic, according to Linker, is intended to create a pretext for clamping down on dissent and justifying more radical measures.

MANUFACTURING ENEMY: THE ROLE OF STEVEN MILLER AND RHETORIC

Steven Miller is highlighted as a central figure in crafting a narrative of widespread left-wing terrorism. Linker dismisses this portrayal as delusional, contrasting it with the actual historical instances of left-wing bombings in the early 1970s. The administration's rhetoric, particularly Miller's, is accused of fabricating a crisis to justify authoritarian responses. This indulgence in conspiracy thinking and lack of civility is considered dangerous, raising the political temperature and making dire outcomes more likely.

THE MYTH OF NATIONAL EMERGENCY AND THE LEFT'S RESTRAINT

The discussion challenges the notion that current crime levels in cities like Portland or Chicago constitute a national emergency justifying federal intervention. Linker points out that crime rates, while a concern, are often lower than in previous decades. He argues that the administration's exaggeration of these issues serves to justify a militarized response. Paradoxically, despite heightened federal provocations, the left has demonstrated remarkable restraint compared to past periods of unrest, suggesting a resilience that counters the narrative of impending chaos.

DEMOCRACY'S DISSOLUTION: THEATER VERSUS AUTHORITARIANISM

A counterargument is presented, suggesting that Trump's actions are more akin to reality TV or theater than genuine authoritarianism, and that alarmists are drawing faulty analogies. The idea is that the political stakes are not as high as portrayed, and that figures like Trump and his enablers are not capable of true fascist actions. However, Harris and Linker push back, asserting that even if perceived as theater, the rhetoric and tactics are dangerous. The dismissal of these actions as mere words or exaggerated fears ignores the real-world consequences and the erosion of democratic norms.

GLOBAL TRENDS AND THE EROSION OF SHARED REALITY

The conversation touches upon the global nature of right-wing populism, describing it as a 'global sickness.' The 'woke' element is seen as fueling this movement, creating a dangerous feedback loop. A fundamental problem identified is the erosion of a shared reality and the difficulty in agreeing on basic facts. This fragmentation of truth makes coherent political response challenging, as different sides operate with entirely different sets of perceived realities, exacerbating the crisis facing democracy. The lack of commitment to reality-based discourse is a significant concern for the future.

Mentioned in This Episode

●Software & Apps

●Organizations

●Books

●Concepts

●People Referenced

Deportation Comparisons (Internal and Border)

Data extracted from this episode

President	Approximate Number Deported (Millions)
Clinton	Approx. 10+
Bush	Approx. 10+
Obama	Slightly less than 10
Trump	Yet to reach Obama's numbers

Homicide Rates in Major US Cities (Historical vs. Present)

Data extracted from this episode

City	Peak Rate (e.g., early 1990s)	Current Rate (approx.)
New York City	Over 2,000 murders/year	10-20% of peak
Philadelphia	Higher than NYC peak	Lower than historical peak

Common Questions

The primary fears discussed are the potential for Donald Trump to establish a dictatorship due to his 'tyrannical soul,' or the US spiraling into civil unrest characterized by sporadic violence from both the far-left and far-right, creating chaos.

Topics

American Democracy Left-Wing Violence Right-Wing Populism Steven Miller Civil Unrest Political Rhetoric Damon Linker

Mentioned in this video

Concepts

Same-sex marriage

Opposition to same-sex marriage was a Bush administration policy that frustrated Damon Linker and contributed to his break from conservatism.

New Atheists

A group Damon Linker was critical of, finding their writings dissipated over time. Christopher Hitchens is mentioned as part of this group.

People

Damon Linker

The guest on the podcast, a writer, political commentator, and senior lecturer in political science at the University of Pennsylvania. Author of 'The Theocons' and 'The Religious Test'.

Books

The Religious Test

Damon Linker's second book, which includes an essay critical of the new atheists.

Theocons

A book written by Damon Linker about his break from conservatism and the religious right.

Organizations

First Things

A magazine where Damon Linker worked as an editor, described as 'the intellectual nerve center of the religious right.'

George W. Bush administration

The administration under which Damon Linker became frustrated with policies like the Iraq War and opposition to same-sex marriage, leading him to break from conservatism.

Legislation & Policy

Insurrection Act

Mentioned as an act Trump has contemplated invoking, particularly in response to perceived unrest or violence.

Software & Apps

Notes from the Middle Ground

Damon Linker's Substack newsletter where he writes about politics.

Locations

Philadelphia

Damon Linker's home city, mentioned as having higher rates of violence than New York City but still lower than its historical peak.