Is it a fallacy to say the cure (lockdown) is worse than the disease (COVID-19)?

Yes, according to the speakers, this is a fallacy because it often compares the economic costs of lockdown to the world before the pandemic, rather than comparing it to the much worse economic and life-threatening consequences of doing nothing or implementing minimal measures.

Will social interactions like handshakes disappear after the pandemic?

It's unlikely handshakes will entirely disappear, but they may become less common in certain circles. Some groups might adopt alternatives like fist bumps or bows, and political or social divides could influence adoption rates, potentially leading to a bifurcation of greeting customs.

Are children resilient to the psychological impacts of the pandemic?

Evidence suggests children are remarkably resilient to disruptions like those caused by the pandemic. While severe cruelty or indifference is harmful, the disruption of normal life is less likely to cause long-term trauma compared to other types of adversity.

How will the pandemic transform higher education?

The shift to online learning may lead to more online course availability for a broader audience, potentially benefiting those without access to top universities. However, in-person interaction remains crucial for motivation and engagement, and smaller colleges may struggle financially.

What are the long-term psychological effects of the pandemic?

The pandemic could lead to increased depression and anxiety, but also resilience. Historically, collective disasters can foster a sense of community and shared purpose, though the isolating nature of this pandemic hinders that particular positive outcome.

Could this pandemic permanently alter our perception of risk and contagion?

It's possible that the experience will permanently reset our perception of risk, leading to greater caution, increased hand-washing, and heightened anxiety around airborne illnesses, much like a personal negative experience with a dog can change how one views a neighborhood.

Will the pandemic lead to a shared global experience impacting us all similarly?

While the pandemic is a shared global condition, the experience is deeply unequal. Factors like wealth, location, and personal circumstances create vastly different realities, preventing a truly uniform 'shared fate' despite a common global event.

Key Moments

A Conversation with Paul Bloom (Episode #198)

Sam Harris

Science & Technology3 min read59 min video

Jun 4, 2020|8,182 views|98|14

sam harris sam harris podcast waking up podcast waking up waking up with sam harris sam harris waking up waking up sam harris sam harris jordan peterson sam harris joe rogan author neuroscientist philosopher

Save to Pod

Key Moments

TL;DR

Podcast discusses COVID-19, economic vs. public health trade-offs, education, and its psychological impacts.

Key Insights

Putting a price on human life is a constant, albeit implicit, necessity in societal decisions, starkly apparent in global wealth disparities.

The 'cure is worse than the disease' argument is fallacious, as it compares lockdown costs to a pre-lockdown world, not to the unmitigated economic/health costs of inaction.

The pandemic response has highlighted a 'turnkey totalitarianism' capability, offering lessons for future existential risks, though social distancing hinders traditional disaster-response cohesion.

The shift to online education may democratize access but risks diminished motivation due to the loss of in-person social cues and the ritual of attendance.

The pandemic's psychological impact may be significant, potentially resetting risk perception and societal habits, though resilience and shared experience could offer some protective mechanisms.

Despite a shared global experience, the pandemic's impact varies dramatically based on individual circumstances, wealth, and living conditions, impacting careers and relationships differently.

THE IMPLICIT PRICE OF HUMAN LIFE

The discussion begins by addressing a common misconception: that one cannot put a price on human life. The speakers argue this is demonstrably false, as societies constantly make implicit or explicit decisions that value lives differently based on economic constraints. This is evident in safety regulations, healthcare spending, and critically, in the vast disparity between the resources allocated to saving lives in wealthy versus developing nations, where trade-offs are starkly more severe.

FRAMING EFFECTS AND ECONOMIC FALLACIES

A significant fallacy identified is the argument that the pandemic's cure (lockdowns) is worse than the disease. This perspective often compares the economic and social costs of lockdowns to an idealized pre-pandemic world, rather than to the catastrophic economic and health consequences of allowing the virus to spread unchecked. The real comparison, they argue, is between different forms of human flourishing, not simply money versus lives, or lockdown versus normalcy.

THE 'TURNKEY TOTALITARIANISM' AND SOCIETAL RESILIENCE

The conversation touches upon the concept of 'turnkey totalitarianism,' the ability to rapidly implement restrictive societal measures when necessary, learned from this pandemic. This experience serves as a 'dress rehearsal' for potentially more severe future threats. However, a unique cruelty of this pandemic is that the very act of social distancing, which protects individuals, paradoxically hinders the traditional communal efforts that foster resilience and psychological well-being in the wake of disasters.

THE TRANSFORMATION OF EDUCATION AND WORK

The pandemic has accelerated the shift towards online education, presenting both opportunities for broader access and challenges in maintaining student motivation and engagement. While remote learning offers egalitarian benefits, the loss of in-person interaction and ritual may impact learning outcomes. Similarly, the economic fallout has severely impacted career trajectories, particularly for recent graduates, with long-term implications for various sectors, especially small businesses unable to weather prolonged closures.

PSYCHOLOGICAL IMPACTS AND PERCEPTION SHIFTS

Long-term psychological effects are anticipated, with potential increases in anxiety and trauma. While human resilience is noted, the pandemic's unique characteristic of enforcing isolation limits the communal coping mechanisms typically observed after collective disasters. There's also the possibility of a permanent 'reset' in the perception of contagion risk, leading to lasting changes in social behaviors like handshaking and a heightened awareness of public health, though the extent of this shift remains uncertain.

THE COMPLEXITY OF A SHARED GLOBAL EXPERIENCE

While the pandemic is a globally shared experience, its impact and the resulting isolation are experienced very differently. This ranges from relative comfort and quality time for some to immense hardship, loss of livelihood, and lack of basic resources for others, particularly in developing nations. The isolation amplifies suffering, preventing the communal bonding that typically helps societies recover from crises, leaving individuals to grapple with the consequences largely alone, despite the shared nature of the threat.

Mentioned in This Episode

●Software & Apps

●Organizations

●Books

●Concepts

●People Referenced

Common Questions

The discussion highlights that societies implicitly and explicitly put a price on human life through cost-benefit analyses in safety regulations, healthcare, and resource allocation. This becomes particularly stark when comparing wealthy and developing nations, where available wealth drastically alters life-saving resource expenditure.

Topics

Health & Longevity Mindset & Self-Improvement Society & Philosophy Pandemic Response Higher Education Economic Impact Societal Change Ethical Dilemmas Psychological Effects Risk Perception

Mentioned in this video

People

Andrew Cuomo

Mentioned for his statement that one cannot put a price on human life, which the speaker argues is factually incorrect in many societal contexts.

Bernie supporters

Mentioned in the context of potential political divisions and their impact on the election, specifically regarding their willingness to vote for Biden.

Salman Rushdie

Mentioned as an example of a notable figure whose talk at Yale would draw a crowd, highlighting the value of in-person events.

William Bennett

Cited for stating that 60,000 American deaths from COVID-19 is not a terrible outcome, which the speaker refutes by pointing out this number is lower precisely because of lockdown measures.

Sam Harris

Host of the Making Sense podcast, engaging in a conversation with Paul Bloom about the pandemic and its multifaceted implications.

Rebecca Solnit

Author whose book 'A Paradise Built in Hell' discusses how collective disasters can bring people together, a phenomenon contrasted with the isolating nature of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Axl Rose

Mentioned humorously in relation to the idea of digital health status avatars for dating.

Nick Bostrom

A philosopher whose concept of 'turnkey totalitarianism' is discussed in the context of society's ability to rapidly implement strict measures in response to existential risks like pandemics.

Phil Tetlock

Mentioned for coining the term 'taboo trade-offs,' referring to the difficult societal choices involving weighing risks and benefits, particularly in contexts like speed limits.

Rudy Giuliani

Mentioned for downplaying COVID-19 deaths by comparing them to the flu, a rhetorical framing that the speaker finds outrageous.

Paul Bloom

Guest on the podcast, a psychologist and cognitive scientist discussing the current situation, ethical dilemmas, societal impacts, and future considerations related to the pandemic.

Freeman Dyson

A physicist whose writings on children's resilience during the Blitz in London are referenced to illustrate the potential positive long-term outlook for children affected by the COVID-19 pandemic.

Organizations

New York Times

Mentioned for a headline about half the world being under lockdown, serving as a point of discussion for shared global experiences.

Kenya

Mentioned as an example of a developing country where the cost-benefit analysis of saving lives differs significantly from wealthy nations due to resource scarcity.

TSA

Mentioned in the context of potential changes to airport security procedures (like allowing liquids) post-pandemic, serving as an example of potential shifts in norms.

Concepts

Turnkey Totalitarianism

A concept by Nick Bostrom describing the rapid implementation of total societal control for survival during existential crises, discussed as a potential outcome or lesson from pandemics.

Human Flourishing

The overarching goal of human activity, presented as the true trade-off in pandemic responses, encompassing both economic well-being and individual happiness.

consequentialism

The ethical framework of evaluating actions based on their outcomes, discussed in relation to evaluating past events like Chernobyl and the pandemic.

Locations

London

The city where the children were exposed to the Blitz, used as a historical example to discuss childhood resilience during crises.

American soil

Used to contextualize the severity of the COVID-19 pandemic's impact on the United States.

United States

The country is discussed extensively regarding its economic trade-offs, death tolls, political response to the pandemic, and the differing experiences of its population.

Toronto

The location where one of the speakers is based, where controversies surrounding summer cottages and the presence of homeless individuals during lockdown are discussed.

Kansas

Used as an analogy for living in an area prone to natural disasters (tornadoes) and the inevitability of facing similar threats, like future pandemics.

China

Mentioned in the context of potential implementation of digital health passports or immunity verification on smartphones during the pandemic.

Software & Apps

Coursera

Referenced as an example of an online platform that provides lecture components for courses, highlighting the shift to online education.

Waking Up App

Mentioned as a source of subscriber-only content, including conversations hosted by Sam Harris.

Zoom

The video conferencing platform is mentioned as a tool used for conducting online class sections and discussions.

Sam Harris Network

The platform where listeners can subscribe for full episodes of the podcast and other exclusive content.

condition

COVID-19

The central topic of the discussion, exploring its economic, ethical, social, and psychological impacts, as well as societal responses and future implications.

Companies

Tinder

Mentioned as a platform that might see increased activity post-lockdown, sparking a discussion about potential shifts in sexual behavior.