How did Stoicism influence modern psychotherapy?

Stoicism is a historical precursor to modern psychotherapy. Pioneers like Albert Ellis (REBT) and Aaron T. Beck (CBT) explicitly drew on Stoic principles, particularly the idea that our opinions about events, not the events themselves, cause distress.

What are some practical Stoic techniques for managing emotions?

Stoicism offers techniques like Prosoche (mindful attention to thoughts), Socratic questioning to challenge beliefs, contemplating the sage (a wise ideal), and rehearsing potential misfortunes (mental rehearsal).

What does 'apatheia' mean in Stoicism?

Apatheia in Stoicism is often mistranslated as apathy. A more accurate translation is 'freedom from pathological desires and emotions,' representing a state of balanced emotional resilience achieved through philosophical practice.

How can Stoicism help with dealing with misrepresentation online or in media?

Stoicism suggests focusing on your own reaction rather than the misrepresentation itself, recognizing it's your opinion that causes distress. It also encourages adopting the perspective of admired wise individuals (modeling) and accepting that external opinions are beyond your control.

What is Prosoche in Stoicism?

Prosoche is a Stoic practice of continuous attention and self-observation, focusing on how we use our minds and the value judgments we make from moment to moment. It's akin to a Stoic form of mindfulness.

Did ancient philosophers think philosophy should be a way of life?

Yes, ancient philosophy, both Western and Eastern, was intrinsically viewed as a way of life. Philosophers were expected to embody wisdom and demonstrate mastery in living, contrasting with the more academic or linguistic focus found in some modern philosophy.

Stoicism and the Good Life | Sam Harris & Donald Robertson (Making Sense #417)

Sam Harris

Science & Technology4 min read23 min video

May 28, 2025|45,104 views|817|197

sam harris sam harris podcast waking up podcast waking up waking up with sam harris sam harris waking up waking up sam harris sam harris jordan peterson sam harris joe rogan author neuroscientist philosopher

Save to Pod

Key Moments

TL;DR

Stoicism offers a framework for emotional resilience and a good life by focusing on virtue and rational thought.

Key Insights

Stoicism is fundamentally an ethical worldview centered on virtue as the only true good.

External factors like wealth and reputation are considered indifferent, not intrinsically good.

Stoicism provides a framework for emotional resilience by managing reactions to events, not events themselves.

Ancient Stoicism included sophisticated psychotherapeutic practices for managing emotions like anger and fear.

Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) draws heavily from Stoic principles, particularly the idea that opinions about events cause distress.

Stoic practices like 'prosoche' (mindful attention) and Socratic questioning aid in self-awareness and challenging irrational beliefs.

THE INTELLECTUAL AND PHILOSOPHICAL JOURNEY

Donald Robertson's intellectual path began with a desire to combine philosophy and psychotherapy, initially exploring existential philosophy and psychoanalysis. Dissatisfied, he shifted focus to Stoicism and cognitive behavioral therapy, pursuing a clinical career rather than academia. This led him to write extensively on Stoicism, a philosophy that experienced a recent resurgence in popularity, partly due to figures like himself, Bill Irwin, and Ryan Holiday. His personal interest in Stoicism was sparked by its presence in Masonic writings, which referenced ancient Greek philosophy and virtues. He sought a Western equivalent to Eastern philosophies offering a guide to life, finding it in Stoicism after his university studies.

STOICISM AS A WAY OF LIFE

Ancient philosophy, including Stoicism, was inherently conceived as a way of life, imbuing practitioners with wisdom and mastery over living. This contrasts with modern academic philosophy, which often focuses on language analysis and may not imply personal wisdom, as exemplified by figures like Nietzsche. While Wittgenstein saw philosophy as a form of therapy, it differed from the ancient approach. The ancient world recognized philosophers by their conduct, treating them as 'Western yogis.' This tradition presented a dichotomy between academic approaches, like Plato's, and more character-focused practices, like the Cynics', with Stoicism attempting to bridge this divide.

THE CORE TENETS OF STOICISM

At its heart, Stoicism is an ethical worldview positing that virtue is the sole intrinsic good, a concept articulated by thinkers like Cicero. Things commonly valued, such as wealth and reputation, are deemed 'indifferent' – not inherently good, but potentially useful. This ethical foundation leads to a decoupling from external possessions and public opinion, fostering emotional resilience in the face of adversity. Consequently, modern interpretations often associate Stoicism with emotional fortitude, a direct outcome of its core ethical teachings focused on inner character.

STOICISM AS ANCIENT PSYCHOTHERAPY

A central Stoic tenet, famously quoted by Epictetus, states, "People are distressed not by events but by their opinions about events." This highlights the cognitive model of emotion, a concept alien to the idea that psychotherapy began solely with Freud. Ancient Stoics practiced elaborate therapeutic techniques to overcome destructive emotions, or 'passions.' Figures like Marcus Aurelius mentioned gaining 'therapeia' (psychotherapy) from his Stoic mentor. Seneca's treatise 'On Anger' exemplifies this focus, aiming for 'apatheia' – freedom from pathological desires and emotions – rather than mere apathy. Key targets for Stoic therapy included irrational desire, anger, fear, and sadness, particularly when they arose from overvaluing externals.

THE HISTORICAL LINK TO COGNITIVE BEHAVIORAL THERAPY

The connection between Stoicism and modern psychotherapy is historically significant and directly acknowledged by pioneers of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT). Albert Ellis, the founder of Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy (REBT), explicitly cited ancient Stoics like Epictetus and Marcus Aurelius as major inspirations for his work, which emerged in the 1950s. Later, Aaron T. Beck, instrumental in popularizing CBT, also repeatedly identified Stoicism as the primary philosophical origin of his approach. This lineage underscores the enduring relevance of Stoic insights into the cognitive shaping of emotional experience and well-being.

PRACTICAL STOIC TECHNIQUES FOR SELF-MASTERY

Stoicism offers a diverse toolkit for self-improvement, including 'prosoche,' a practice of continuous mindful attention to one's thoughts and judgments. This resembles Stoic mindfulness, encouraging reflection on how one uses their mind and the value judgments being made. The Socratic method, involving questioning beliefs to uncover irrationality, is also integral, mirroring CBT's challenge to cognitive distortions. Stoics also employed contemplative practices like meditating on the ideal sage ('sophos'), contemplating one's own mortality, and mentally rehearsing potential misfortunes to build resilience, paralleling modern CBT techniques like mental rehearsal and imaginal exposure.

NAVIGATING MISREPRESENTATION AND EXTERNAL JUDGMENT

A common challenge, particularly for public figures, is the misrepresentation of one's views. The Stoic approach suggests first considering how a wise person would handle such a situation, employing 'cognitive modeling.' This involves imagining how admired figures or even hypothetical exemplars like Buddha or Socrates would respond. This perspective-shifting technique helps overcome personal blind spots, akin to the Epictetus fable of two sacks – one for others' flaws visible in front, and one for one's own flaws hidden behind. Furthermore, Stoics emphasized the value of mentorship and transparent dialogue with a wise elder or therapist to gain an objective viewpoint and address these unseen flaws.

Mentioned in This Episode

●Tools

●Organizations

●Books

●Concepts

●People Referenced

Stoic Practices for Emotional Resilience

Practical takeaways from this episode

Do This

Practice continuous attention to your thoughts and value judgments (Prosoche).

Use Socratic questioning to challenge irrational beliefs that cause distress.

Contemplate the character of a sage to model virtuous behavior.

Imagine potential misfortunes in advance to prepare yourself mentally.

Seek out a wise mentor or therapist for an outside perspective.

Consider how admired wise figures would handle your challenges (modeling).

Avoid This

Do not attribute distress solely to external events; focus on your opinions about them.

Avoid excessive attachment to external possessions and reputation.

Do not expect wisdom to be readily available in modern academic philosophy departments.

Be aware of the 'blind spot' regarding your own flaws, as illustrated by Aesop's fable.

Common Questions

Stoicism is an ethical worldview and ancient philosophy that emphasizes virtue as the sole good and teaches emotional resilience. Unlike much modern academic philosophy which focuses on language analysis, Stoicism was intended as a practical way of life.

Topics

Socratic Method

Mentioned in this video

personBill Irwin

Mentioned as one of the contemporary figures contributing to the popularity of Stoicism.

personRobert Burns

Scottish national bard and master Freemason, whose connection to Freemasonry sparked Donald Robertson's early interest in philosophy.

toolProsoche

A Stoic practice of continual attention and mindfulness towards one's thoughts and judgments.

personDonald Robertson

Author and psychotherapist who specializes in Stoicism and its connection to cognitive behavioral therapy.

personAaron T. Beck

Pioneer of Cognitive Therapy, who repeatedly stated that its philosophical origins lie in ancient Stoicism.

bookHow to Think Like Socrates

Another book by Donald Robertson, presumably exploring Socratic philosophy.

bookHow to Think Like a Roman Emperor

A book by Donald Robertson on Stoicism, exploring its principles through the life of Marcus Aurelius.

organizationFreemasonry

A fraternal organization mentioned as a source of life philosophy and references to ancient Greek philosophy for Donald Robertson's father and his community.

bookEnchiridion

A handbook by Epictetus containing key Stoic teachings, including the famous quote about opinions and events.

personJunius Rusticus

Marcus Aurelius's Stoic mentor, who provided him with 'therapeia' or psychotherapy.

bookOn Anger

A surviving work by Seneca detailing Stoic psychotherapy for the emotion of anger.

conceptSocratic method