How did Yasmine Mohammed's mother influence her upbringing?

After her parents' divorce, Yasmine's mother sought a support system at a mosque, becoming a born-again Muslim and marrying a polygamous man. This led to a strict, religious upbringing for Yasmin, involving covering hair, praying five times a day, and restricting normal childhood activities, which she resisted.

What is the problem with Quranic verses that mention beating wives?

The issue is that such verses are sanctioned within Islam. While not all Muslim men beat their wives, the scriptural support allows those who do to justify their actions, as seen when Yasmine's complaint about abuse was met with a reference to Quran chapter 4, verse 34.

How is the niqab different from the hijab and what is its effect?

The hijab is a head covering, while the niqab covers the full face, often along with gloves. Yasmine describes the niqab as dehumanizing, suppressing humanity, and creating a sensory deprivation chamber that disconnects a woman from the world.

Why does Yasmine Mohammed criticize Western feminists?

She criticizes Western feminists for a perceived double standard, celebrating practices like wearing a burkini while ignoring or downplaying the oppression faced by women forced to wear hijabs or niqabs. She argues this viewpoint treats Muslim women as a different species and fails to recognize their struggle for freedom.

What was Yasmine Mohammed's experience with the Canadian legal system regarding domestic abuse?

When Yasmine reported abuse at age 12 or 13, a judge ruled that her family's cultural practices of discipline were their right, denying her protection because her parents were born in Canada. This experience highlighted the issues of cultural relativism and how well-intentioned 'sensitivity' can harm vulnerable individuals.

Who was Yasmine Mohammed's ex-husband and what was his background?

Her ex-husband was a member of Al-Qaeda, trained by Osama bin Laden. He was sent to Canada to support operations related to 9/11. She discovered his true identity when CSIS approached her in a hospital waiting room.

Why did Yasmine Mohammed start speaking out publicly?

After escaping her abusive marriage and subsequent legal troubles, she initially wrote anonymously. However, after seeing the discourse surrounding Sam Harris's interview with Ben Affleck, and receiving requests from women worldwide to be their voice, she felt compelled to speak out openly, despite the risks.

What kind of backlash has Yasmine Mohammed faced from the left?

She has faced intense criticism, mass reporting, and attempts to silence her from liberals and 'woke' individuals. This is surprising and hurtful to her, as she feels attacked by those in the 'light' after escaping the 'darkness' of fundamentalism.

Why is it important to criticize other cultures, according to Yasmine Mohammed?

She argues that criticism is essential for progress in any culture. Refusing to criticize harmful practices in other cultures, she believes, is effectively saying those cultures do not deserve to progress or for their marginalized people (like women or LGBTQ+ individuals) to gain freedom and human rights.

How does Yasmine Mohammed view the concept of 'people of color'?

She views the term 'people of color' as a form of segregation and othering, no different from 'colored people.' She argues it creates a division between 'humanity' and 'people of color,' implying the latter are distinct and not fully part of the human collective.

Why does Yasmine Mohammed feel compelled to continue speaking out despite the risks?

She feels a deep responsibility to be a voice for the many people worldwide who have contacted her, especially women in oppressive regimes, who cannot speak out themselves. Silencing her means silencing their voices too, which she feels she would be failing.

Key Moments

Leaving the Faith (Rebroadcast): A Conversation with Yasmine Mohammed (Episode #298)

Sam Harris

Science & Technology4 min read81 min video

Sep 29, 2022|56,664 views|1,613|293

sam harris sam harris podcast waking up podcast waking up waking up with sam harris sam harris waking up waking up sam harris sam harris jordan peterson sam harris joe rogan author neuroscientist philosopher

Save to Pod

Key Moments

TL;DR

Yasmine Mohammed discusses escaping radical Islam and the hypocrisy of Western liberals.

Key Insights

Yasmine Mohammed's personal journey from indoctrination in conservative Islam to her advocacy for women's rights.

The double standards Western liberals employ when analyzing women's rights in Muslim communities versus Western contexts.

The role of Islamic texts and interpretations in sanctioning or encouraging practices like domestic violence and forced marriage.

The dangers of 'honor violence' and 'honor killings' linked to cultural and religious expectations.

The need for consistent application of human rights principles across all cultures, refuting cultural relativism.

Yasmine Mohammed's experience with systemic silencing she faces from both Muslim communities and, surprisingly, from Western progressives.

Her ex-husband's deep involvements with Al-Qaeda and Osama bin Laden, and how she discovered his past.

FROM SECULAR TO STRICT ISLAM: A CHILDHOOD REIMAGINED

Yasmine Mohammed's early life began in a secular household in Egypt and then Vancouver. Her parents, initially non-religious, experienced a shift due to her mother's vulnerability after her father's departure. Seeking community and support, her mother remarried within the Muslim community, leading to a drastic change in Yasmine's upbringing. Her childhood freedoms—playing with friends, listening to music, attending parties—were replaced with strict adherence to Islamic practices, including mandatory prayer, hijab, and an Islamic school, marking the beginning of her family's immersion into a conservative interpretation of Islam.

FORCED MARRIAGE AND THE DIMINISHING SELF

Resisting religious strictures from a young age, Yasmine eventually succumbed to pressure, including a forced marriage at 20. This marriage, to a man her mother approved of, led her to adopt the niqab, a full face covering. The niqab, described as a 'portable sensory deprivation chamber,' severely diminished her sense of self and connection to the world. It wasn't until the birth of her daughter that she resolved to break free, determined to prevent her child from enduring the same oppressive environment, especially with discussions of female genital mutilation (FGM) present.

ISLAMIC SANCTIONS AND WESTERN FEMINIST BLIND SPOTS

Mohammed highlights how certain Islamic texts, like Quran chapter 4, verse 34, are interpreted to sanction a husband's right to discipline a disobedient wife, including described as 'beating.' While interpretations vary, the core issue is the scriptural support that can be used to justify abuse. She contrasts this with the reaction of many Western feminists who, out of a concern for cultural sensitivity or a misunderstanding of the coercion involved, often celebrate or remain silent about practices like the hijab and niqab, viewing them through a lens that ignores the oppressive realities faced by many women in Muslim-majority contexts.

THE 'HONOR VIOLENCE' AND THE DOUBLE STANDARD IN CRITICISM

The podcast emphasizes the severe consequences of not adhering to strict religious and cultural codes, particularly concerning 'honor violence' and 'honor killings.' Mohammed recounts harrowing examples, including a 16-year-old girl murdered in Canada for refusing to wear a hijab. She criticizes the double standard where Western societies condemn such practices in their context (like the FLDS cult) but fail to apply the same ethical scrutiny to similar or worse situations within Muslim communities. This selective criticism, she argues, hinders progress and perpetuates harm.

ESCAPING AN AL-QAEDA OPERATIVE AMIDST CULTURAL RELATIVISM

A critical turning point in Yasmine's life was discovering her husband's deep ties to Al-Qaeda and Osama bin Laden. This revelation, facilitated by Canadian intelligence (CSIS), provided the necessary impetus to escape him. Her attempt to seek legal protection through a judge was met with a ruling based on cultural relativism, where his 'Arab' disciplinary practices citing religious rights were deemed acceptable. This experience, where a judge's well-intentioned but misguided cultural sensitivity denied her protection, profoundly shaped her views on the dangers of moral and cultural relativism.

THE SCANDAL OF WESTERN LIBERALS EMPOWERING RADICALISM

Mohammed's book title, 'Unveiled: How Western Liberals Empower Radical Islam,' directly addresses her central thesis. She explains that when secular liberals fail to apply universal human rights standards and instead excuse or celebrate practices that oppress women in Muslim contexts, they inadvertently embolden extremist elements. This is seen as a betrayal by those within these communities fighting for freedom. She argues that progress requires criticism, and the refusal to criticize certain cultures amounts to denying them the possibility of progress, effectively supporting the oppressors.

THE SILENCING EFFECT AND THE FIGHT FOR FREE SPEECH

Yasmine Mohammed faces significant backlash, not only from Muslim communities but also from Western progressives who often label her as bigoted or Islamophobic. This silencing campaign, often involving mass reporting on social media platforms, is deeply hurtful as she feels she is speaking for those who cannot. She contrasts her experience with that of Megan Phelps-Roper, who left the Westboro Baptist Church and received widespread support. Mohammed's struggle highlights the ethical scrambling on the left, where repudiating Christianity is accepted, but repudiating Islam invites accusations of prejudice, demonstrating a failure to apply consistent ethical principles.

THE UNIVERSALITY OF HUMANISM AND THE PATH FORWARD

Mohammed advocates for humanism and universal human rights, asserting that feminism and freedom are not confined to Western cultures. The 'people of color' framework, she argues, is itself a form of othering and racism. She calls for a society where individuals are judged by their character, not their skin color, echoing Martin Luther King Jr.'s vision. Her personal mission, driven by the pleas of individuals worldwide seeking a voice, compels her to continue speaking out despite the personal risks and the intellectual dishonesty she encounters from those who refuse to acknowledge the systemic issues at play.

Mentioned in This Episode

●Organizations

●Books

●Concepts

●People Referenced

Common Questions

Yasmine Mohammed grew up in a conservative Muslim household in Canada after her mother converted to Islam and married a second husband. She experienced strict religious rules and eventually a forced marriage. This led her to become a vocal critic of religious fundamentalism and an advocate for women's rights.

Topics

Mindset & Self-Improvement Society & Philosophy Women's Rights Religious Fundamentalism Cultural Relativism Criticism Of Islam Liberal Hypocrisy Human Rights Activism

Mentioned in this video

People

Ayaan Hirsi Ali

Somali-American activist and scholar, discussed as a feminist success story who faced backlash on a progressive college campus.

Yasmine Mohammed

Human rights activist, writer, and advocate for women in Islamic majority countries, critical of religious fundamentalism. Author of 'Unveiled: How Western Liberals Empower Radical Islam'.

Sam Harris

Host of the Making Sense podcast and author, known for discussions on consciousness, religion, and current events. He interviewed Yasmine Mohammed for this episode.

Ben Affleck

Actor and filmmaker. His appearance on Bill Maher's show, and the subsequent criticism Sam Harris received, prompted Yasmine Mohammed to speak out.

Mahsa Amini

Woman whose murder in Iran sparked widespread protests for women's secular freedom, a context that makes Yasmine Mohammed's conversation particularly relevant.

Megan Phelps-Roper

Former member of the Westboro Baptist Church who wrote a book about her experience. Her story is compared to Yasmine Mohammed's due to similarities in escaping cults.

Martin Luther King Jr.

Civil rights leader whose quote about judging individuals by the 'content of their character' rather than the 'color of their skin' is invoked in the discussion about race and post-racial ideals.

Osama bin Laden

Founder of al-Qaeda. Yasmine Mohammed's ex-husband was trained by him and sent money to bail him out of prison.

Bill Maher

Host of 'Real Time with Bill Maher'. An episode featuring Maher and Ben Affleck is mentioned as a catalyst for Yasmine Mohammed speaking out against the liberal response to criticism of Islam.

Anwar Sadat

Former President of Egypt who was assassinated for signing a peace treaty with Israel. His assassination trial was the largest in Egyptian history, with Yasmine Mohammed's ex-husband's terrorism trial being the second largest.

Organizations

Al-Qaeda

Terrorist organization founded by Osama bin Laden. Yasmine Mohammed's ex-husband was a member and trained by Bin Laden.

Sports Illustrated

Mentioned as a cultural reference point to highlight the double standard in Western media's reception of a 'Mormon underwear' feature versus a 'burkini' feature.

CSIS

The Canadian domestic intelligence agency that approached Yasmine Mohammed to inform her about her husband's true identity and involvement in terrorism.

Taliban

Mentioned as an example of an extreme religious regime to illustrate the point about criticizing other cultures and the implications of not doing so.

ISIS

Mentioned as a more recent extremist group that has somewhat supplanted the Taliban in discussions about religious extremism.

Westboro Baptist Church

A hate group known for its extreme anti-LGBTQ+ and anti-American stances, from which Megan Phelps-Roper escaped and is discussed as a comparable experience to Yasmine Mohammed's.

Books

Hadith

A saying or action attributed to the Prophet Muhammad. One Hadith is cited as being used to coerce women, stating that 'Heaven is at the feet of your mothers'.

Quran

Cited as a source for verses, such as chapter 4, verse 34, which is interpreted by some to sanction husbands beating disobedient wives.

Unveiled: How Western Liberals Empower Radical Islam

Yasmine Mohammed's book, which explores the complexities of women's rights in Islamic communities and the role of Western liberals.

Locations

Iran

Country currently experiencing protests in response to the murder of Mahsa Amini, a situation Yasmine Mohammed's conversation is highly relevant to.

Egypt

Country of origin for Yasmine Mohammed's mother and ex-husband. It's where her ex-husband was imprisoned for 15 years for terrorism.

Saudi Arabia

Mentioned as the source of the niqab and burqa that Yasmine Mohammed's husband had delivered; also referenced in the context of a school fire where religious police delayed rescue due to veiling issues.

Canada

Country where Yasmine Mohammed lived with her Al-Qaeda-affiliated husband and later escaped to start a new life, seeking legal protection.

Concepts

Islam

Discussed in the context of its doctrine, texts, and how it can be interpreted to sanction practices like domestic violence, and also as a global religion facing criticism.