What credit score do I need to get a mortgage for a rental property?

Ideally, you should aim for a credit score above 700, preferably above 740, to secure the best mortgage rates. Scores significantly below this range can result in higher interest charges, reducing your profitability.

How important are tax returns when applying for a rental property loan?

Lenders often look at your last two years of tax returns to average your income and determine loan eligibility. It's crucial not to deduct excessive expenses that artificially lower your reported income, as this can hinder your loan qualification.

Should I look at properties out-of-state for rental investment?

While investing out-of-state can be done, it carries risks due to the difficulty in understanding local trends and relying on others. It's generally advisable to invest in areas you can personally observe and understand day-to-day.

What type of property is best for a first-time rental investor?

Single-family homes, duplexes, triplexes, and fourplexes are often recommended because they qualify for conventional financing with potentially better terms than commercial loans for larger multi-unit buildings.

How do I calculate if a rental property will cash flow?

To determine cash flow, subtract all ownership costs (mortgage, taxes, insurance, maintenance, vacancy reserves) from the potential rental income. The property should ideally generate positive cash flow, meaning rent exceeds all expenses each month.

What kind of renovations should I look for or do in an investment property?

Focus on properties with good underlying structure (roof, foundation, plumbing, electrical) but outdated cosmetics (kitchens, bathrooms, flooring). Minor cosmetic fixes can significantly increase value and rentability without massive expense.

How much more do renovations typically cost and take longer than estimated?

Expect renovations to cost about 20% more and take 20% longer than initially estimated by contractors. Always budget and plan for these overruns to avoid financial surprises.

What is the recommended strategy for scaling up rental properties?

After a year to eighteen months with your first property, save for another down payment and repeat the process. Buying a duplex every other year, for instance, can lead to owning multiple cash-flowing units over a decade.

How To Buy Your First Rental Property (Step by Step)

Graham Stephan

Education6 min read28 min video

Nov 19, 2018|5,127,277 views|190,008|6,242

how to buy your first rental property how to invest in real estate how to invest in real estate 2019 how to invest in real estate 101 investing in real estate real estate investing strategies real estate investing 2019 real estate investing for beginners real estate investing with no money real estate investing 101 real estate investing podcast real estate investing audiobook

Save to Pod

Key Moments

TL;DR

Step-by-step guide to buying your first rental property, from preparation to scaling.

Key Insights

Preparation is crucial: ensure a sufficient down payment, good credit score (740+), and organized tax returns (last two years averaged).

Pre-approval is vital: talk to a lender first to know your budget precisely and act quickly on good deals.

Analyze thoroughly: properties on average lose money; focus on cash flow, calculate all ownership costs (mortgage, taxes, insurance, maintenance, vacancy), and aim for positive cash flow.

Target smart properties: prefer single-family homes or small multi-unit buildings (2-4 units) over condos. Look for minor cosmetic renovation needs for upside potential.

Negotiate effectively: use inspections as a second round of negotiation and always make reasonable offers based on numbers, not emotion.

Renovate and rent wisely: supervise renovations closely, budget for overages, and use durable, renter-proof materials. Take excellent photos and respond quickly to potential renters.

PREPARING FOR YOUR FIRST PROPERTY

Before diving into real estate investment, essential preparations are required. This includes accumulating a down payment, typically 15-20% for investment properties, which translates to $15,000-$20,000 per $100,000 of property value. Simultaneously, focus on improving your credit score to at least 740, ideally 760+, to secure favorable mortgage rates. Lenders will also need to review your last two years of tax returns, so ensure they are organized and reflect a realistic income, as lenders average these figures to determine loan eligibility. Having proof of employment and bank statements readily available is also a prerequisite.

FINANCIAL AND CREDIT READINESS

Securing financing is a cornerstone of buying a rental property. This necessitates a solid credit history; aim for a score above 740 for the best interest rates, as lower scores mark you as a riskier borrower, increasing costs. Building credit involves having active lines of credit that are consistently paid on time, with no late payments or collections. If your credit needs improvement, focus on paying off debts and disputing inaccuracies. For those new to credit, numerous resources exist to help establish a good score, which is fundamental for mortgage approval. Being prepared financially also means having your documentation in order, including tax returns, bank statements, and proof of income.

THE IMPORTANCE OF LENDER PRE-APPROVAL

Engaging with a lender early in the process, before property hunting, is critical. This step provides a clear understanding of your borrowing capacity, preventing wasted time on properties outside your budget. Inform the lender of your approximate credit score (checked via free services like Credit Karma) rather than having them run a hard inquiry, which can negatively impact your score. Pre-approval secures your position in a competitive market, allowing for swift action when a suitable property is found. Being prepared financially and having lender approval ready is key to capitalizing on opportunities, as desirable properties often attract multiple offers and move quickly.

PROPERTY SELECTION AND ANALYSIS

Once pre-approved, begin exploring properties within your budget, and slightly above to gauge the market. Seeing a broad range of properties, ideally 25-60, helps in understanding market value, reasonable upgrades, and property condition. For personal investment, focus on single-family homes, duplexes, or triplexes, as these often qualify for conventional financing with better terms compared to properties with five or more units. Avoid condos due to HOA fees and limited upside potential. Consider properties in the lower-middle price range within an area to maximize the buyer pool and increase potential for appreciation and easier renting.

UNDERSTANDING CASH FLOW AND PROPERTY COSTS

A critical step is accurately determining a property's cash flow. Most properties do not inherently cash flow, so meticulous analysis is vital. Calculate all ownership costs: down payment, mortgage principal and interest, property taxes, insurance, maintenance, potential repairs, and vacancy reserves. Use online mortgage calculators and research local rental rates on platforms like Craigslist or Zillow. For example, on a $400,000 property with 20% down, monthly expenses including mortgage, taxes, insurance, a buffer for miscellaneous costs, and vacancy could total around $2,600. To achieve positive cash flow, the rent must exceed these expenses, ideally providing a healthy return on investment.

IDENTIFYING PROPERTIES WITH UPSIDE POTENTIAL

Look for properties that, while potentially dated cosmetically, have sound underlying structures. Properties with issues like outdated kitchens, bathrooms, or flooring are often good candidates, as these are relatively inexpensive to update. Avoid properties needing extensive, costly hidden repairs like foundation or major electrical work, but ensure these core systems are functional. Estimating renovation costs requires getting multiple bids from reliable contractors (via sources like Yelp), and always budget for a 20% overage and extended timelines. The goal is to add value through renovations that increase rental income and property value, leading to a better return on investment.

NEGOTIATION AND TRANSACTION PROCESS

When making offers, focus on the numbers and don't get emotionally attached. It's crucial to work with a competent real estate agent who understands negotiation strategies and manages the contract process efficiently. Be prepared for offers to be rejected, and don't be afraid to make reasonable low offers if the numbers don't work at higher prices. Inspections are a key part of the negotiation; use any discovered issues to request credits or price reductions from the seller. Understand that closing costs, typically around 1% of the purchase price, will add to your initial outlay, and factor these into your total investment.

MANAGING RENOVATIONS AND PROPERTY PREPARATION

Once renovations are planned, meticulous supervision is paramount. Be present daily to ensure the project stays on track and to catch potential errors. Opt for durable, renter-proof materials like laminate flooring and robust countertops to minimize future repair needs and replacement costs, avoiding susceptible materials like carpet. This preemptive approach minimizes long-term expenses and tenant-related damages, contributing to sustained profitability and a smoother rental experience for both parties involved.

RENTING OUT YOUR PROPERTY EFFECTIVELY

After renovations, the next step is attracting and retaining quality tenants. Invest in professional photography to showcase the property attractively online. Respond promptly to all inquiries to capitalize on potential renters' immediate interest. Utilize multiple online platforms, including Craigslist, Zillow, and specialized rental sites, for broad advertising. Thorough tenant screening, a process detailed in separate resources, is essential to find reliable renters who will pay on time and care for the property, safeguarding your investment and ensuring consistent cash flow.

SCALING YOUR REAL ESTATE PORTFOLIO

The ultimate goal is to scale your investment portfolio. After holding the first property for approximately 12-18 months to gain experience and establish a track record, begin saving for another down payment. This 'rinse and repeat' strategy, where you buy a property every couple of years, can lead to significant wealth accumulation over time. For instance, acquiring five duplexes over ten years, all cash-flowing and eventually paid off, can provide substantial passive income and financial security for retirement. Consistent, disciplined investment in rental properties is a proven path to long-term financial independence.

Mentioned in This Episode

●Software & Apps

●Organizations

Your First Rental Property: A 12-Step Checklist

Practical takeaways from this episode

Do This

Save for a 15-20% down payment.

Improve your credit score to above 740.

Organize your last two years of tax returns and proof of income.

Talk to a lender to get pre-approved before looking at properties.

View at least 20-25 properties to understand market value.

Target median-priced homes or lower-middle range in an area.

Consider single-family homes, duplexes, triplexes, or fourplexes.

Calculate potential cash flow by considering all ownership costs.

Look for properties needing minor cosmetic updates.

Get multiple bids from contractors for renovations and add a 20% buffer for cost and time overruns.

Make renovations 'renter-proof' using durable materials.

Advantageously use inspections as a second round of negotiation.

Take high-quality photos for listings and respond to inquiries immediately.

Screen tenants thoroughly.

Keep your first property for 1-1.5 years before scaling up.

Avoid This

Expect to buy with less than 15-20% down for investment properties.

Assume lenders will approve loans with a low credit score or inconsistent payment history.

Deduct all possible expenses on tax returns if you plan to seek a loan soon after.

Start looking at properties before talking to a lender and getting pre-approved.

Overpay for a property; stick to your numbers.

Buy condos due to HOA fees and limited upside.

Invest in properties that do not cash flow or at least break even.

Attempt to change an undesirable location (e.g., next to a freeway, busy street).

Do not get emotional during the offer process; focus on the numbers.

Work with an incompetent or unresponsive real estate agent.

Expect renovations to stay exactly on budget or schedule; always budget for overruns.

Use expensive or easily damaged materials during renovations.

Buy properties that back up to large commercial or apartment buildings.

Underestimate the importance of your own on-site supervision during renovations.

Example Cash Flow Calculation on a $400,000 Property with 20% Down

Data extracted from this episode

Item	Cost per Month	Notes
Mortgage Payment (20% down on $400k, 30-yr fixed)	$1,717	Based on estimated interest rate and terms
Property Taxes (1.2% in CA)	$400	1.2% of $400,000 / 12 months
Insurance	$100 - $150	Varies by property and provider
Other Expenses (Gardener, fixes, pest control, etc.)	$200	Buffer for miscellaneous costs
Vacancy Reserve	$150	Average monthly cost for potential vacant periods
Total Ownership Costs	~$2,567 - $2,617	Approximate monthly expenses

First Year Return Calculation Example

Data extracted from this episode

Component	Amount	Details
Monthly Cash Flow	$800	Assuming $3,200 rent on $2,600 costs
Annual Cash Flow	$9,600	$800/month * 12 months
Principal Paydown (Equity Gain)	$4,700	Estimated equity built in the first year
Total First-Year Return	$14,300	($9,600 cash flow + $4,700 equity)
Return on Investment (ROI)	~17.9%	($14,300 / $80,000 down payment)

Common Questions

Generally, lenders require a 15-20% down payment for investment properties. This means for a $100,000 property, you'd need $15,000-$20,000 saved. Ensure you have enough for the down payment and closing costs.