What is David Frum's proposed solution for better immigration control?

Frum advocates for enforcing immigration through the workplace by requiring employers to check hiring eligibility, treating immigration as part of labor law, and imposing consequences on employers to reduce incentives for illegal entry.

Why does Donald Trump's trade policy fail to bring back manufacturing?

Trump's policy fails because it attempts to protect industries with higher costs without long-term guarantees, and because protecting one product increases the cost of all other products that use it as an input, creating a dysfunctional cycle.

Are there any positive aspects of the current political situation?

The situation is not entirely grim; Ukraine is still fighting with continued, albeit interrupted, support. The Trump administration has also improved support for Israel, and the economy has not yet fallen into recession as feared.

How does Trump's foreign policy differ from traditional approaches?

Trump's foreign policy is characterized by transactionalism, driven by personal slights and flattery, and the idea of decisive, one-off actions. This differs from traditional policy which requires sustained effort and relationship building.

What is the long-term damage to US global leadership?

The US announced to the world that its commitments are unreliable, capable of reneging on agreements within a four-year cycle. This makes allies question US trustworthiness and provides opportunities for adversaries like China.

Could the current political climate lead to nuclear proliferation?

The on-again, off-again support for Ukraine raises concerns. If nations feel they cannot rely on US security guarantees, they might seek their own nuclear deterrents, contributing to proliferation.

How Bad Is the State of American Politics, Really? (Making Sense #426)

Sam Harris

Science & Technology3 min read30 min video

Jul 23, 2025|353,157 views|7,005|1,750

sam harris sam harris podcast waking up podcast waking up waking up with sam harris sam harris waking up waking up sam harris sam harris jordan peterson sam harris joe rogan author neuroscientist philosopher

Save to Pod

Key Moments

TL;DR

US politics faces unprecedented corruption and damaged global standing under Trump's second term.

Key Insights

The second Trump administration exhibits corruption on a scale exponentially larger than the first, involving personal enrichment through business dealings and trade policy.

Trade disruptions and damage to international alliances have intensified, negatively impacting the global economy and America's standing.

Trump's immigration crackdown, characterized by ruthlessness and chaos, risks alienating key voter demographics like Hispanics.

Despite the scale of abuses, deep-seated tribal loyalties in American politics mean a significant portion of the electorate remains unmoved by facts.

Key areas like support for Ukraine and Israel, while not as bad as feared, are subject to the unpredictable personal whims of the President.

The damage to America's global leadership and reliability is profound and may be difficult to repair, impacting its ability to counter geopolitical rivals like China.

ESCALATING CORRUPTION AND SELF-DEAL

The current administration has seen a dramatic increase in corruption compared to the first Trump term. While previously involving smaller sums through resort usage and pressuring businesses to use his facilities, the current term features vastly larger sums, notably through meme coins. The President is actively promoting his international golf courses, directly benefiting from foreign governments seeking favor, essentially operating a protection racket that jeopardizes both the global and domestic economy.

INTENSIFIED TRADE DISRUPTIONS AND ALLIANCE DAMAGE

Trade disputes have escalated significantly, causing greater harm to the American and global economies than anticipated. The US has lost its position as the top soybean exporter due to alienated buyers. Furthermore, damage to long-standing alliances has worsened, and the immense debt incurred through fiscal policies poses a substantial threat to America's future standing on the world stage.

THE IMMIGRATION CRACKDOWN AND ITS POLITICAL FALLOUT

The implementation of immigration policies has been surprisingly ruthless and chaotic, leading to a crackdown that shocks the conscience. Despite arguments for stronger border control, the methods employed, including the creation of camps for undocumented individuals, risk alienating crucial voting blocs. This is particularly concerning given the trend of some Hispanic voters shifting towards Trump, many of whom have relatives in the country without legal status.

DEEP-ROOTED TRIBAL LOYALTIES IN POLITICS

Despite the evident corruption and policy failures, a significant portion of the electorate remains loyal due to deeply ingrained tribal identities. Historical parallels show that even during severe economic downturns, a core base remains unswayed by facts. Elections are decided at the margins, and events like the Epstein case have the potential, albeit rare, to shift these loyalties by disrupting the established tribal structures.

FOREIGN POLICY UNDER DURESS OF PERSONAL SLIGHTS

While direct support for Ukraine and Israel has continued, the underlying foreign policy decisions are increasingly driven by the President's personal reactions to perceived slights or flattery. This erratic approach, driven by personal grievances rather than principles, makes US foreign policy unpredictable. The focus on decisive, one-off actions, like confronting Iran, ignores the complex, long-term nature of global challenges.

LONG-TERM DAMAGE TO GLOBAL STANDING AND RELIABILITY

The most significant and lasting damage may be to America's global leadership and reliability. Allies question the consistency of US commitments, especially when facing geopolitical rivals like China. The announcement that a US administration can renege on all previous commitments within a four-year cycle undermines trust. While corruption can be cleaned up, the erosion of international confidence and the potential for a new wave of nuclear proliferation pose enduring threats.

Mentioned in This Episode

●Products

●Companies

●Organizations

●Concepts

●People Referenced

Common Questions

Corruption has escalated significantly in scale, with methods like using the Secret Service at resorts and pushing foreign governments to use Trump properties now dwart with much faster sums of money through mechanisms like meme coins.