What is 'the blue room' in podcast production, according to Dan Carlin?

Dan Carlin uses 'the blue room' to describe the point where a creator has heard their own work so many times that they lose the ability to judge it objectively, similar to how a new listener or reader would perceive it.

How does Dan Carlin research and prepare for Hardcore History episodes?

Carlin typically picks subjects he already has a strong foundation in, then thoroughly researches by reading numerous books, including new revisions and perspectives. He doesn't use a script but organizes ideas around 'pillars' and uses primary source accounts, allowing for improvisational tangents.

What advice does Dan Carlin offer for developing a unique vocal delivery for podcasting?

Carlin advises aspiring podcasters to polish their own unique style rather than trying to emulate others. He suggests finding a comfortable vocal range and even capitalizing on perceived 'negatives' in one's voice, turning them into signature stylistic elements.

Who are some of Dan Carlin's main influences in audio storytelling?

Dan Carlin admires figures like James Burke for his mind and ability to connect ideas, Gwynne Dyer for his war series, and Edward R. Murrow for serious reporting. He also draws inspiration from early audio pioneers like Orson Welles for their 'theater of the mind' approach.

How did Hardcore History become a full-time profession for Dan Carlin?

Hardcore History became a full-time profession thanks to listener donations. After being advised by experts that asking for donations wouldn't work, Carlin tried it anyway. Listeners' willingness to pay what they felt the content was worth allowed him to sustain the show professionally.

What is Dan Carlin's most popular Hardcore History episode or series?

According to Carlin, the most popular series is 'Ghost of the Ostfront,' which covers the Eastern Front of World War II. He attributes its popularity to it being a lesser-known but incredibly impactful part of World War II, a subject that is always of high interest.

What is Dan Carlin's definition of success and failure?

For Dan Carlin, success is equated with happiness. He views failure not as never achieving something, but as creating something successful and then 'screwing it up' or failing to deliver good quality work subsequently, implying a constant pressure to surpass previous achievements.

What would Dan Carlin tell his 20-year-old self if he could?

He would tell his 20-year-old self not to stress and that 'it's all going to work out.' He reflects on the immense emotional stress and worry he experienced in his twenties and wishes he could have known that things would be okay.

Which Hardcore History episodes does Dan Carlin recommend for new listeners?

Carlin recommends starting with newer episodes as they are more representative of the show's evolved style. He suggests picking based on interesting subject matter, including 'Blitz editions' which explore unique historical questions rather than specific events.

Key Moments

Dan Carlin Interview (Full Episode) | The Tim Ferriss Show (Podcast)

Tim Ferriss

Howto & Style4 min read91 min video

Nov 2, 2015|24,160 views|244|25

tim ferriss 4 hour workweek 4 hour body 4 hour chef forbes timothy ferriss entrepreneur author writer best-seller public speaker angel investor

Save to Pod

Key Moments

TL;DR

Dan Carlin discusses his "Hardcore History" podcast, covering its evolution, creative process, and the unique nature of niche audio content.

Key Insights

Hardcore History evolved from shorter episodes to its signature long-form style due to audience receptivity.

Carlin emphasizes finding one's unique voice and embracing 'imperfections' as strengths in podcasting.

Creative endeavors often involve extensive 'wasted' time that is crucial for eventual breakthroughs.

The internet and podcasting allow for 'narrowcasting,' catering to niche audiences without watering down content.

Success in creative fields is defined by personal happiness and producing high-quality work, not necessarily external validation or financial gain.

Carlin stresses the importance of passion-driven content, advising creators to focus on what interests them personally.

THE UNEXPECTED RISE OF HARDCORE HISTORY

Dan Carlin's "Hardcore History" podcast became a massive success despite its historical subject matter, initially surprising even host Tim Ferriss. Carlin reveals that the podcast's lengthy format wasn't an initial plan; early episodes were shorter, and the idea of exceeding an hour was daunting. The audience's positive reception, however, provided the freedom to explore topics more deeply, leading to the multi-hour productions now synonymous with the brand. This shows how audience engagement can shape and extend the creative ambitions of a podcast.

EVOLVING THE FORMAT AND FINDING A VOICE

Carlin likens the evolution of his podcast to early seasons of popular TV shows like Seinfeld, where the core concept gradually refines into its recognizable form. He identifies key ingredients and narrative elements that consistently resonate with listeners, using them as a 'checklist' for episodes. This includes incorporating drama, narrative drive, and what he calls 'Twilight Zone-kind of ideas' about history. The process involves experimentation, much like a jazz musician improvising within a structure, allowing for tangents that are integral to the show's unique appeal.

THE INTENSIVE CREATIVE AND PRODUCTION PROCESS

Creating "Hardcore History" is an arduous journey involving extensive research, writing, and editing, often leading to a state Carlin calls the 'blue room,' where the creator loses objective perspective. He emphasizes that there is no script; instead, he relies on notes for key ideas and primary source accounts, allowing for a free-form, improvisational delivery. The challenge of producing long episodes means re-listening, editing, and even scrapping entire segments, akin to a band re-recording a song multiple times. This dedication to quality, even at the cost of immense time and stress, is a hallmark of his approach. Carlin notes that while this process is demanding, having a solid foundation in a subject is crucial for tackling such in-depth explorations.

THE POWER OF AUTHENTICITY AND NARROWCASTING

Carlin advocates for authenticity in vocal delivery, suggesting that creators should embrace their unique voice rather than imitating others. He transitioned from a 'big voice' radio style to a more natural, conversational tone, which eventually became preferred. He argues that podcasting, unlike broadcast media, is about 'narrowcasting' – targeting specific niches. This allows creators to be themselves, attract a like-minded audience, and avoid watering down content to appeal to a lowest common denominator. His 'punchable people' segment highlights this by focusing on those who advocate for war without personal experience, demonstrating a strong, opinionated voice rooted in personal conviction.

SUCCESS AS HAPPINESS AND PERPETUAL IMPROVEMENT

For Carlin, success is intrinsically linked to personal happiness and the satisfaction of producing high-quality work. He contrasts this with external metrics like fame or wealth, emphasizing that the joy derived from the creative process itself is paramount. He acknowledges the business aspect of podcasting but finds managing it challenging. Failure, in his view, isn't in never starting, but in creating something successful and then failing to maintain that standard. This perspective drives an ambition to constantly improve and surpass previous benchmarks, viewing each episode as setting a new minimum standard for future work.

THE INFLUENCE OF MILITARY HISTORY AND STORYTELLING

Carlin's lifelong fascination with military history, which he studied in college, forms the core of many "Hardcore History" episodes. He believes that focusing on subjects one is passionate about will naturally attract a dedicated audience. He draws parallels between his work and passionate storytelling, suggesting that the ability to weave compelling narratives is a fundamental aspect of his appeal. This passion for military history, often dark and intense, is reflected in his work's artwork and thematic choices, resonating with listeners who share similar interests. He encourages aspiring podcasters to embrace their niche, even if it's unusual, as the internet provides a platform for these specialized interests to find an audience.

ADVICE FOR ASPIRING CREATORS AND LISTENERS

Carlin's advice for aspiring podcasters is to embrace their unique voice and passions, even if they feel unqualified. He shares his personal journey, shifting from a discouraged TV reporter to a successful podcaster, and emphasizes that the internet allows for creative endeavors that were previously impossible in mainstream media. For listeners, he recommends starting with more recent "Hardcore History" episodes that reflect the show's current style and picking subjects that pique their interest. He also highlights the value of "Blitz Editions" for exploring niche topics and encourages listeners to engage with the "theater of the mind" elements within the podcasts.

Mentioned in This Episode

●Books

●People Referenced

Common Questions

Dan Carlin started Hardcore History by conceptualizing it and letting it evolve. Initially, he was wary of hour-long episodes and never expected it to become a full-time profession. The audience's receptiveness allowed the show to expand in length and scope beyond his initial fears.

Topics

Mindset & Self-Improvement Learning & Education History & Geopolitics Business & Entrepreneurship Creativity & Media History Education Audio Storytelling Creative Process Personal Growth Career Change Media Evolution Historical Interpretation

Mentioned in this video

Media

Hardcore History

Dan Carlin's incredibly popular and influential history podcast, known for its long, in-depth episodes and compelling storytelling.

Wrath of the Khans

A multi-part Hardcore History series about the Mongol Empire, described as immensely challenging to create but very popular, and highly recommended by Tim Ferriss.

Step Stories

A Hardcore History episode that Dan Carlin believes was one of the first to hit 'the sweet spot' of incorporating all the necessary elements for a successful show.

Apache Tears

An early Hardcore History episode about the Apaches, which Dan Carlin remembered being afraid to release because it exceeded an hour in length.

Prophets of Doom

A Hardcore History episode that Tim Ferris highly recommends, despite Dan Carlin's personal misgivings about how it turned out production-wise.

The Wizard of Oz

Mentioned in a playful way, suggesting that the intricate audio design of early Hardcore History episodes wasn't as overt as syncing albums with movies.

Ghost of the Ostfront

A multi-part Hardcore History series focusing on the Eastern Front of World War II, which Dan Carlin considers the most popular episode due to its compelling subject matter and broad appeal.

Seinfeld

Used as an analogy for how creative projects, including podcasts, evolve and find their stride over time, often starting in a less polished form.

Ghostbusters

Referenced with the line 'don't cross the streams' as an analogy for keeping topics and tangents distinct during the complex production of a long-form history podcast.

Bubonic Nukes

A Hardcore History episode on the Black Plague, with a specific sound effect sequence at the end that Dan Carlin particularly enjoyed: a lab beaker dropping followed by a red alert alarm.

People

Joe Rogan

Mentioned as another podcaster whose early videos were hilariously amateur compared to his later, polished episodes, serving as an encouraging example for new podcasters.

Frank Sinatra

Dan Carlin jokingly cultivates an image of himself as a legendary, effortlessly productive artist like Sinatra, who can 'crank out' shows at the last minute.

James Burke

Famous host of The Connection series and The Day The Universe Changed, admired by Dan Carlin for his mind and ability to string ideas together.

Orson Welles

Looked up to by Dan Carlin for his work in audio, especially his 'theater of the mind' approach, which Carlin tried to recreate in early Hardcore History episodes.

Gary Owens

Mentioned as a representative of the 'big voice era' of radio broadcasting, a style Dan Carlin actively moved away from to find his own unique vocal delivery.

John Bolton

Former U.S. Ambassador to the UN, used by Dan Carlin as an example of a public figure who advocates for war despite avoiding military service themselves, sparking Carlin's anger.

Jerry Lee Lewis

Mentioned by Dan Carlin as embodying a 'punk rock' attitude, illustrating his philosophy that music is about attitude and soul rather than technical expertise.

Edward R. Murrow

Journalistic legend whose soul 'runs deep' at CBS, serving as an important role model for serious reporters like Dan Carlin during his TV news career.

Eugene Sledge

A U.S. Marine veteran from World War II's Pacific Theater featured in the series 'Hell in the Pacific', known for his view that only those on the front lines truly understand war.

Eddie Murphy

Used as an example of a naturally gifted comedian who, in the current media landscape, could achieve fame and fortune through a podcast without needing traditional gatekeepers like Saturday Night Live.

Dan Carlin

The guest of the podcast, known for his Hardcore History podcast, praised for his storytelling and unique approach to history.

Gary Vaynerchuk

Friend of Tim Ferriss who started Wine Library TV, and whose early episodes were subdued before he grew into his bombastic, authentic persona.

Steve Jobs

Cited for his quote 'Your time is limited, so don't waste it living someone else's life.'

Gwynne Dyer

A Canadian journalist whose series on war deeply influenced Dan Carlin during his upbringing.

Richard Pryor

Compared to Eddie Murphy as another naturally gifted comedian who could leverage direct-to-public media like podcasts to achieve success in the modern era.

Lou Reed

Musician mentioned as part of Dan Carlin's appreciation for 'old stuff' that he considers to embody a punk rock attitude.

Books

The 4-Hour Workweek

Tim Ferriss's first book, which he discussed struggling with writing several drafts of before finding his voice.

Locations

Mount Fuji

Mentioned as an example of an interesting fact (12,365 feet in altitude) that Tim Ferriss remembers with a mnemonic.