Is it true that we are not evolved to eat meat?

No, humans started eating meat about 2.5 million years ago, and it played a crucial role in our evolutionary history. We are ultimate omnivores, adapted to eat a wide range of foods, including meat, relying on technology like cooking and processing.

Should I only breathe through my nose, especially when exercising?

Daniel Lieberman is skeptical of the idea that you should only breathe through your nose, particularly during intense activity like running. Humans evolved to breathe through their mouths when running to dump heat, and no elite runner exclusively breathes nasally while running.

How does chronic stress impact our body and health?

Chronic stress, a mismatch condition, causes persistently high cortisol levels. Cortisol makes us hungry, particularly for sugar, and directs fat storage to visceral (belly) fat. This excess fat, especially visceral fat, then causes chronic systemic inflammation, leading to diseases like diabetes, Alzheimer's, and heart disease.

Why is dieting so difficult from an evolutionary perspective?

Our bodies never evolved to diet; we evolved to readily store fat for survival and reproduction. When in negative energy balance from dieting, the body enters a starvation response, elevating cortisol and attempting to defend the current weight, making weight loss difficult and often temporary.

How does our modern comfortable lifestyle affect our skeletal health?

Modern sedentary lifestyles and lack of sufficient physical activity, especially weight-bearing exercise, prevent the skeleton from accreting enough mass during youth. This leads to lower peak bone mass by age 25-30 and increased rates of bone loss later in life, contributing to rising rates of osteoporosis.

Is cultural evolution making our bodies 'de-evolve'?

Lieberman suggests that by treating the symptoms of mismatch diseases (e.g., glasses for myopia, pills for heart disease), we enable these diseases to remain prevalent and potentially worsen. This cultural evolution, rapidly changing our environment, prevents natural selection from 'correcting' these maladaptations, leading to a form of 'dis-evolution'.

How does a highly sanitized environment affect our immune system?

In highly sanitized modern environments, our immune systems are unchallenged by common pathogens we evolved to encounter. This can lead to them 'getting into trouble' and accidentally attacking our own bodies, increasing the likelihood of allergies (like peanut and milk allergies) and autoimmune diseases.

What is the evolutionary role of body fat in humans?

Humans evolved to have an unusually high level of body fat compared to other primates. This fat is crucial as an energy reserve, especially for brain development in infants (whose brains consume 50% of metabolic energy) and for supporting the energy demands of pregnancy and nursing in women.

Does eating hard foods as a child affect jaw development and wisdom teeth?

Yes, chewing harder, less processed foods can stimulate jaw growth, potentially providing more space for teeth. Modern soft diets contribute to smaller jaws and increased rates of malocclusion, often necessitating wisdom teeth removal.

Harvard Professor: They’re Lying To You About Running, Breathing & Sitting! - Daniel Lieberman

The Diary Of A CEO

People & Blogs4 min read94 min video

Jan 29, 2024|1,902,692 views|32,767|2,313

The Diary Of A CEO steven bartlett steve bartlett podcast the diary of a CEO podcast life lessons CEO

Save to Pod

Key Moments

TL;DR

Harvard Professor Daniel Lieberman discusses evolutionary biology and "mismatch diseases" caused by modern lifestyles.

Key Insights

Modern Western diseases like obesity, heart disease, and many cancers are "mismatch diseases" resulting from a gap between our evolved biology and modern environments.

Humans are remarkably adaptable omnivores, evolved for endurance running and efficient thermoregulation through sweating, not for sedentary lifestyles.

The 'Paleo fantasy' of hunter-gatherer utopia is inaccurate; while they avoided some modern diseases, they faced other challenges, including violence.

Our evolutionary adaptations, including storing body fat and having large brains, are primarily driven by reproductive success, not necessarily optimal health.

Cultural evolution has accelerated environmental change far beyond our biological capacity to adapt, leading to widespread health issues.

Treating symptoms of mismatch diseases rather than their causes ('dis-evolution') is a significant problem that bankrupts healthcare and lowers quality of life.

THE PROBLEM OF MISMATCH DISEASES

Daniel Lieberman explains that many chronic diseases prevalent today, such as obesity, heart disease, and certain cancers, are "mismatch diseases." These arise because modern environments, characterized by comfort, abundant processed food, and sedentary lifestyles, are fundamentally different from the environments our bodies evolved in. Our biology, adapted for a hunter-gatherer existence, struggles to cope with these novel conditions, leading to metabolic dysfunction, chronic stress, and increased susceptibility to illness.

EVOLUTIONARY ADAPTATIONS: RUNNING, SWEATING, AND DIET

Our ancestors evolved incredible endurance for long-distance running, enabling them to hunt effectively. This is coupled with a sophisticated sweating mechanism, turning our entire bodies into efficient radiators to shed heat, a major advantage over animals that rely solely on panting. As omnivores, humans can digest a vast array of foods, a flexibility that has been crucial for survival across diverse environments. However, modern diets often exploit this adaptability with processed, high-energy foods for which we are poorly equipped.

THE MYTH OF THE PERFECT HUNTER-GATHERER

The idea that simply returning to a hunter-gatherer lifestyle would solve all health problems, often termed the 'Paleo fantasy,' is an oversimplification. While hunter-gatherers generally avoided modern metabolic diseases, they were not free from violence, disease, or hardship. Their adaptations were primarily geared towards reproductive success, not necessarily longevity or constant happiness. Understanding their lifestyle provides valuable insights, but it's not a complete blueprint for modern health.

BRAINS, FAT, AND THE ENERGY EQUATION

The evolution of large human brains and our tendency to store body fat are intimately linked to energy availability. Big brains are metabolically expensive, requiring a constant supply of energy. Hunting and gathering strategies, along with cooking and food processing, increased energy intake. This surplus energy released the constraints on brain size. Similarly, body fat serves as a crucial energy reserve, vital for reproduction, nursing infants, and surviving periods of scarcity, making a certain level of body fat a fundamental human adaptation.

CULTURE'S ACCELERATION AND 'DIS-EVOLUTION'

Human culture has driven extremely rapid environmental changes, far outpacing biological evolution. This rapid alteration of our surroundings— from sedentary jobs and processed foods to the pervasive use of technology—creates mismatches. Lieberman terms the modern approach of treating symptoms of these diseases rather than addressing their root causes 'dis-evolution.' This cycle of treating symptoms (e.g., with pills for high blood pressure or glasses for myopia) enables these mismatch diseases to persist and even worsen.

THE CONSEQUENCES OF COMFORT AND SEDENTARY LIVING

Modern society's emphasis on comfort and convenience has led to increasingly sedentary lifestyles. Excessive sitting, particularly during leisure time, significantly increases the risk of disease. This lack of physical activity weakens muscles, reduces bone density, and contributes to chronic pain like back pain, which is the number one medical complaint globally. Encouraging sufficient physical activity, especially in children, is crucial for building a robust skeletal system and mitigating the ill effects of modern inactivity.

THE HYGIENE HYPOTHESIS AND IMMUNE SYSTEM IMBALANCE

Our immune systems evolved to interact with a diverse range of pathogens. In highly sanitized modern environments, the immune system, lacking sufficient external challenges, can become overactive and mistakenly attack the body's own tissues, leading to allergies and autoimmune diseases. This 'hygiene hypothesis' suggests that exposure to microbes, dirt, and even pets plays a vital role in training the immune system, while excessive sterility can have detrimental long-term health consequences.

HORMONE SENSITIVITY AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH

Body fat is not just an energy store; it's an endocrine organ that produces hormones like leptin and estrogen. For women, low body fat levels can disrupt menstrual cycles by reducing estrogen production, impacting fertility. The body's sensitivity to energy availability influences reproductive functions, prioritizing survival and reproduction when energy is abundant. Conversely, low energy availability or significant stress can suppress these functions, reflecting an evolutionary drive to conserve resources during challenging times.

RETHINKING MODERN HABITS: FROM DIET TO DAILY ROUTINES

An evolutionary perspective encourages skepticism towards modern conveniences and health fads. It suggests that our bodies are not adapted for continuous sitting, highly processed foods, or the constant use of antibacterial products. Simple actions like getting up frequently, choosing less processed foods, and embracing a moderate level of exposure to the environment can help mitigate mismatch diseases. The key is to understand our evolutionary heritage and make conscious adjustments to better align our lifestyles with our biology.

Mentioned in This Episode

●Supplements

●Products

●Companies

●Books

●People Referenced

Evolutionary Health Principles for Modern Living

Practical takeaways from this episode

Do This

Understand why mismatches occur in modern environments.

Get up more often and interrupt long sitting bouts (e.g., every 20 minutes).

Engage in regular physical activity, especially weight-bearing exercises to build and maintain bone mass.

Choose less processed foods with fiber, avoiding excessive sugar and saturated fat.

Be skeptical of products and quick fixes that promise to solve complex health problems.

Allow children to engage in plenty of physical activity to develop healthy skeletal systems.

Avoid This

Assume modern comfort is always beneficial for health.

Exclusively breathe through your nose during intense exercise like running.

Rely solely on pills to treat symptoms without addressing underlying causes of disease.

Adopt overly sanitized lifestyles, especially for children, which can lead to immune system overreactions (allergies, autoimmune diseases).

Believe that looking to hunter-gatherers provides all the answers for modern health without nuance (Paleo fantasy).

Allow prolonged sitting without interruptions.

Body Fat Percentage Comparison

Data extracted from this episode

Species / Population	Typical Body Fat (%)
Most Mammals	4-5%
Most Primates	4-5%
Skinny Human	10-25%
Hunter-Gatherer Male	10-15%
Hunter-Gatherer Female	15-25%
Newborn Human Baby	About 15%

Menstrual Cycles: Modern Women vs. Hunter-Gatherers

Data extracted from this episode

Population	Approximate Number of Menstrual Cycles in Lifetime
Typical Modern Woman	350-500
Typical Hunter-Gatherer Woman	About 50

Common Questions

Mismatch diseases arise from a disconnect between our evolved biology and novel aspects of our modern environment. They are common because cultural evolution has rapidly changed our environment, faster than biological evolution can adapt, leading to chronic stress, poor diet, and sedentary lifestyles for which our bodies are poorly suited.

Topics

Mismatch Diseases Physical Activity Hunter-gatherer Fat Storage Cultural Evolution

Mentioned in this video

productnasal strips

Used by the host's girlfriend to open airways during sleep. Lieberman is skeptical of their effectiveness as a long-term solution for issues like sleep apnea.

personDave Rienzi

A researcher who published a paper showing that the Hadza people sit as much as Westerners but get up frequently, highlighting the importance of interrupting sitting bouts.

productDaily Greens

A greens powder product from Hu that provides vitamins, minerals, adaptogens, and probiotics, recommended by the host for health benefits like energy, concentration, and immunity.

bookThe Story of the Human Body: Evolution, Health, and Disease

Daniel Lieberman's book, which is described as essential reading and used in educational institutions.

companyHu

A company the host invests in and is on the board of, which sponsors the podcast.