Key Moments

#148 - Richard Miller, M.D., Ph.D.: The gold standard for testing longevity drugs: the ITP

Peter Attia MDPeter Attia MD
People & Blogs3 min read135 min video
Feb 8, 2021|12,905 views|295|29
Save to Pod
TL;DR

ITP is the gold standard for longevity drug testing in mice, with surprising results for rapamycin and acarbose.

Key Insights

1

The Interventions Testing Programs (ITP) is considered the gold standard for testing longevity drugs in mice due to its rigor, large sample sizes, and multi-site approach.

2

Rapamycin showed significant lifespan extension in mice, even when started in middle age, challenging previous assumptions that interventions must begin early in life.

3

Acarbose and canagliflozin, both used for diabetes, extended lifespan in male mice, suggesting a role for managing high glucose peaks in longevity.

4

17 alpha estradiol significantly extended lifespan in male mice, highlighting sex-specific effects of certain compounds and potential for interventions that don't feminize males.

5

Metformin, despite strong human data in diabetics, failed to show a significant lifespan extension in mice within the ITP framework, underscoring species differences and the need for precise testing parameters.

6

Nicotinamide riboside (NR), a popular NAD+ precursor, did not extend lifespan in the tested mice, indicating that not all popular supplements deliver on longevity promises.

7

The ITP's use of genetically heterogeneous mice (Het3) is crucial for ensuring findings are broadly applicable and not specific to particular inbred strains.

8

Late-life interventions can be effective, with some drugs showing similar or significant benefits when started in middle age compared to youth, which has implications for human application.

THE INTERVENTIONS TESTING PROGRAMS (ITP)

The Interventions Testing Programs (ITP), a multi-institutional effort involving labs at the University of Michigan, Jackson Labs, and UT San Antonio, is presented as the gold standard for testing potential longevity drugs in mice. Its design emphasizes statistical power through large numbers of genetically heterogeneous mice and parallel testing across sites to ensure reproducibility. This rigorous methodology aims to provide reliable answers on whether specific compounds can extend lifespan, making its findings highly influential.

KEY FINDINGS: RAPAMYCIN AND LATE-LIFE INTERVENTIONS

Rapamycin emerged as a standout success, demonstrating significant lifespan extension in both male and female mice. Remarkably, its efficacy was maintained even when initiated in middle-aged mice (around 19-20 months), challenging the prevailing notion that longevity interventions must start early in life. This finding suggests that some aging processes may still be reversible or significantly impacted even in later stages of life, offering hope for interventions in older individuals.

GLUCOSE METABOLISM AND LONGEVITY: ACARBOSE AND CANAGLIFLOZIN

The ITP tested acarbose, a drug that slows starch digestion, and canagliflozin, an SGLT2 inhibitor, both used for diabetes management. Both drugs showed lifespan extension, particularly in male mice, linking improved glucose regulation and avoidance of high post-meal glucose spikes to longevity. While these drugs didn't alter overall hemoglobin A1c in mice, their impact on peak glucose levels suggests a mechanism that benefits male longevity, though the precise reason for sex specificity remains unclear.

SEX-SPECIFIC EFFECTS: 17 ALPHA ESTRADIOL

17 alpha estradiol, a synthetic estrogen derivative designed to have lower affinity for classical estrogen receptors, showed a powerful lifespan-extending effect specifically in male mice. This finding highlights the significant sex-specific biological differences relevant to aging and longevity. The drug's ability to increase lifespan in males beyond that of normal females, without causing feminization, presents an intriguing avenue for research into sex-based hormonal influences on aging.

DISAPPOINTING RESULTS: METFORMIN AND NICOTINAMIDE RIBOSIDE

Despite compelling human data, especially in diabetics, metformin failed to demonstrate a significant lifespan extension in the ITP studies. Possible explanations include species differences, suboptimal dosing, or administration schedules. Similarly, nicotinamide riboside (NR), a popular NAD+ precursor, did not extend lifespan in mice, suggesting that not all compounds with a strong theoretical basis or popular appeal translate into tangible longevity benefits in rigorous animal models.

THE VALUE OF FAILURE AND FUTURE DIRECTIONS

The ITP's rigorous testing also identifies compounds that do not work, which is as valuable as identifying those that do. Examining failures like metformin and NR helps refine our understanding of aging biology and directs future research. The program continues to explore new molecules and mechanisms, including the role of hormones, glucose metabolism, and mTOR signaling, aiming to unravel the complexities of aging and discover interventions that promote healthy lifespan.

Common Questions

The ITP is a gold-standard scientific program funded by the NIA, which rigorously tests potential longevity-extending molecules/drugs in genetically heterogeneous mice. It aims to identify reliable and reproducible interventions for slowing the aging process, serving as a critical bridge between basic research and potential human applications.

Topics

Mentioned in this video

Supplements
SGLT2 inhibitor

A class of drugs including canagliflozin, used for type 2 diabetes, which block glucose reuptake in the kidney. ITP results show it extends lifespan in male mice, possibly by reducing peak glucose levels.

Aspirin

An initial ITP candidate drug that showed a small lifespan extension in male mice at a very low dose, but did not replicate the effect at higher doses.

NAD

A coenzyme central to metabolism and DNA repair, whose levels are often linked to aging, and is targeted by many supplements.

Nicotinamide Riboside

A popular NAD+ precursor supplement tested in the ITP, which did not extend lifespan in mice at the tested dose, and did not consistently show increased NAD+ levels in tissues.

Resveratrol

A compound popularized for alleged anti-aging benefits, especially in relation to red wine. ITP studies (at high doses on normal diets) found no significant lifespan extension, debunking earlier findings in mice poisoned with high-fat diets.

green tea extract

A popular supplement believed to be healthful; tested in the ITP, but did not extend lifespan in mice.

Curcumin

A popular supplement that was tested in the ITP and failed to show longevity benefits.

Ursolic Acid

A compound suggested to the ITP, potentially related to bile acids and retinoid receptor activation, but Dr. Miller isn't certain about its rationale. It was mentioned as being not orally bioavailable in a human supplement context.

Acarbose

An FDA-approved diabetes drug that blocks starch digestion and glucose absorption. In ITP, it extends lifespan in both sexes, especially males, likely by reducing glucose peaks, and is effective even when started in middle age.

Methylene blue

A compound that caught Dr. Miller's eye on the list of ITP-failed compounds.

Glycine

An amino acid that, when tested in the ITP, showed significant but tiny lifespan effects in both males and females.

Concepts
Caloric Restriction

A dietary intervention known to extend lifespan across many species, serving as early proof that aging is malleable, though it typically needs to be initiated early in life.

Daf-2

A gene mutation in C. elegans, an analog of the IGF-1 receptor, shown to extend lifespan, a foundational discovery in aging.

mTOR complex 1

One of two protein complexes containing mTOR; its inhibition by Rapamycin is believed to be the primary driver of longevity benefits.

Hayflick Hypothesis

The concept that normal human cells divide a limited number of times in culture before stopping (replicative senescence), which Hayflick incorrectly linked to organismal aging.

Telomeres

Protective caps at the ends of chromosomes whose shortening limits cell division; a fundamental biological discovery, but its role as a central cause or biomarker of aging is often overemphasized.

Snell dwarf mutation

A genetic mutation in mice that extends longevity by 30% and is associated with reduced mTORC1 activity and elevated mTORC2 activity.

Daf-16

A gene mutation in C. elegans, an analog of FoxO3a/3b, which blocks the lifespan-extending effect of Daf-2 mutations when combined, indicating interaction.

Sirtuins

A family of proteins believed to play a role in cellular health and aging, and targeted by Resveratrol. Research on their importance in aging remains controversial.

hemoglobin A1C

A clinically useful measure indicating average glucose levels over weeks; observed to decrease with Acarbose and SGLT2 inhibitors in humans, but not consistently in ITP mice.

mTOR complex 2

One of two protein complexes containing mTOR; its inhibition by Rapamycin is associated with negative consequences, and its elevation in some dwarf mice is linked to longevity.

Growth hormone receptor knockout mutation

A genetic mutation in mice that extends longevity by 30% and is associated with reduced mTORC1 activity and elevated mTORC2 activity.

Estrogen receptor beta

One of the classical estrogen receptors, for which 17-alpha Estradiol has a much lower affinity than 17-beta Estradiol.

C. Elegans

A nematode worm, commonly used model organism in aging research, where Daf mutants were first shown to extend lifespan.

Ames dwarf mutation

A genetic mutation in mice shown to extend lifespan by about 40%, serving as critical evidence that aging can be slowed in mammals.

mTOR

Mammalian target of Rapamycin, a protein kinase that regulates cell growth, proliferation, and survival, and is inhibited by Rapamycin.

Estrogen receptor alpha

One of the classical estrogen receptors, for which 17-alpha Estradiol has a much lower affinity than 17-beta Estradiol.

Alzheimer's disease

A neurodegenerative disease that does not ordinarily occur in mice but can be studied in engineered mouse models, where anti-aging drugs have shown postponement of the disease.

Hydrogen sulfide

A gas that some researchers hypothesize is an important controlling element in the aging process; a drug designed to produce it is being re-tested in the ITP after an initial methodological error.

People
Linda Partridge

A scientist who initially argued against the possibility of single gene mutations extending lifespan, then modified her stance to exclude C. elegans.

Richard Weindruch

A researcher who demonstrated that caloric restriction works best when initiated at a younger age in mice, failing when started later in life.

Gonzalo Garcia

A scientist in Dr. Miller's lab who has studied the activity of mTORC1 and mTORC2 in long-lived mutant mice and ITP-treated mice.

Vera Gorbunova

A scientist at the University of Rochester who has done work on how different species with varying body sizes and lifespans differ in their anti-cancer mechanisms, including telomere reliance.

Scott Pletcher

A mathematical biodemographer who carefully compared the survival curves of early-start vs. late-start Rapamycin-treated mice, finding them statistically indistinguishable.

David Allison

A researcher who, with Daniel Smith, initially suggested Acarbose for ITP testing based on its caloric restriction-mimicking effects.

Raphael de Cabo

A close friend and colleague of David Sinclair, who also provided advice on Resveratrol dosing for the ITP research.

Cynthia Kenyon

A researcher whose early work in C. elegans demonstrated that single gene mutations (Daf-2 and Daf-16) could dramatically extend lifespan, challenging prevailing scientific beliefs.

Bruce Carnes

A researcher who, with J.L. Shansky, estimated the impact of abolishing specific diseases on human lifespan.

Dave Sharp

A colleague of Randy Strong and an expert on mTOR, who suggested Rapamycin as an ITP candidate based on invertebrate data.

Jay Mitchell

A scientist interested in hydrogen sulfide as a controlling element in aging, who suggested a hydrogen sulfide-producing drug (SG1002) for ITP testing.

Matt Kaeberlein

A friend of Dr. Miller, conducting an important study giving Rapamycin to dogs.

Vittorio Defendi

Chair of Pathology at New York University and a colleague of Hayflick, who shared an anecdote about the origins of the Hayflick Hypothesis.

Arlan Richardson

A colleague of Dr. Miller at Texas (now Oklahoma) who collaborated on sketching out the initial plan for the ITP.

George Martin

A friend and colleague of Dr. Miller, who held a differing view on whether aging is a unitary process at a Gordon Research Conference.

Marty Javers

A colleague of Randy Strong at the University of Texas who conducted studies on Rapamycin blood levels in male and female mice.

Daniel Smith

A colleague of David Allison, who collaborated on the Acarbose suggestion for the ITP.

Randy Strong

A collaborator in the ITP, leading one of the three testing labs at UT San Antonio.

Elizabeth Blackburn

A Nobel Prize-winning scientist known for her foundational work on telomeres.

Nancy Nadan

Deputy to Huber Warner in the NIA's Division of Aging Biology, involved in the early discussions about the ITP.

Holly Brown-Borg

A colleague of Andre Bartke, co-author on the paper demonstrating Ames dwarf mutation extends mouse lifespan.

Robin Holliday

An Australian scientist who continued to argue against the possibility of single gene mutations affecting longevity, even after evidence to the contrary emerged.

John Herrera

A colleague of Mike Garrett, co-author on the paper showing beneficial effects of 17-alpha Estradiol.

Huber Warner

A visionary guy who headed NIA's Division of Aging Biology and conceived the idea of a program to test interventions, which evolved into the ITP.

David Harrison

Leader of one of the three ITP labs at The Jackson Laboratory, a collaborator with Dr. Miller and Randy Strong.

David Sinclair

A Harvard researcher whose lab published early work on Resveratrol, showing longevity benefits in metabolically ill, overfed mice.

David Stipp

A science journalist who wrote a book about the Resveratrol story, 'The Youth Pill'.

Andre Bartke

A researcher who, with Holly Brown-Borg and colleagues, showed that the Ames dwarf mutation could extend lifespan in mice, providing "second shoe" to C. elegans findings.

Richard Hodes

The director of the NIA, who Dr. Miller and his colleagues were trying to convince to carry genetically heterogeneous mice, and who later directly ordered the ITP to test Resveratrol.

Jim Simpkins

A pharmacologist interested in estrogen receptors who synthesized 17-alpha Estradiol and proposed it for ITP testing.

Charlene Day

A colleague of Mike Garrett, co-author on the paper showing beneficial effects of 17-alpha Estradiol.

Mike Garrett

A former student of Dr. Miller and independent researcher who, with colleagues, published a paper showing beneficial effects of 17-alpha Estradiol on muscle strength, glucose tolerance, and muscle structure in mice, even with late initiation.

Gretchen Darlington

A researcher who made claims about retinoid receptor activation and bile acids in long-lived Ames dwarf mice, possibly relating to the suggestion of ursolic acid.

Aubrey de Grey

A well-known figure in anti-aging research, whose views on rapid solutions to aging were satirized by Dr. Miller in an MIT Technology Review article about 'flying pigs'.

Organizations
National Institutes of Health

A major funder of biomedical research in the US, mentioned in the context of hypothetical funding for expanded longevity research.

University of Michigan

Academic institution where Dr. Richard Miller is a professor of pathology and director of the Paul F. Glenn Center for Aging Research.

National Institute on Aging

A component of the NIH that funds research on aging, including the Interventions Testing Programs (ITPs).

Interventions Testing Program

A set of rigorous, multi-site studies funded by the NIA to test potential longevity-extending molecules in genetically heterogeneous mice, considered the 'gold standard' for longevity drug testing.

UT Health San Antonio

Academic institution where Randy Strong runs one of the three ITP testing labs.

American Federation for Aging Research

An organization for which Dr. Miller served in editorial and advisory positions, supporting aging research.

NIA (National Institute on Aging)

The institution that funds the ITP, initially through a Nathan Shock center where Dr. Miller conducted early drug testing.

MD Anderson Cancer Center

The institution where Dr. Miller did a postdoc after Yale, referred to as Memorial Sloan Kettering (MSK).

Boston University

The institution where Dr. Miller set up his first independent lab, focusing on immunology and aging.

Nature

A prominent scientific journal that published early papers discussing why single gene mutations couldn't extend lifespan, and then later, papers showing that they could.

Paul F. Glenn Center for Aging Research

A research center at the University of Michigan directed by Dr. Richard Miller, focusing on aging research.

Cell

A scientific journal where a subsequent paper on Resveratrol from David Sinclair's lab revealed the cause of death for the mice in the original study.

More from Peter Attia MD

View all 247 summaries

Found this useful? Build your knowledge library

Get AI-powered summaries of any YouTube video, podcast, or article in seconds. Save them to your personal pods and access them anytime.

Try Summify free