Why is X showing me content I don't like?

X's algorithm is optimizing for engagement metrics like dwell time, which can lead to showing content that grabs attention but doesn't align with user preferences or provide genuine value.

How can I improve my X feed if I don't like the content?

Users can utilize features like the 'not interested in this post' option. Curated lists are also mentioned as a high-quality, ad-free way to consume content on specific topics.

What lessons can startup founders learn from Twitter's changes?

Founders should focus on the core problem their product solves and prioritize genuine connection or value over blindly optimizing for engagement metrics, which can lead to a less satisfying user experience.

Why was Twitter renamed X?

The name change to X is largely attributed to Elon Musk's obsession with the letter. It's seen as a confusing move, especially since 'Twitter' had become a verb, signifying product success.

How has the blue checkmark changed on X?

Originally a signal of credibility, the blue checkmark can now be obtained by paying a subscription fee, diluting its meaning and making it harder to distinguish verified accounts from regular users.

What's the deal with the Grok AI on X?

Grok is an AI chatbot integrated into X, discussed as an example of product expansion that deviates from what users might expect from a social media platform.

What advice is given for choosing a product name?

Opt for something short, catchy, easy to say, and spell. Ideally, it should relate to the product's function, but the best companies often build meaning into their names over time, like Monzo or Google.

Key Moments

Twitter vs. X: Product Lessons For Startup Founders

Y Combinator

Science & Technology5 min read23 min video

Nov 21, 2024|40,640 views|968|142

YC Y Combinator

Save to Pod

Key Moments

On this page

TL;DR

X (formerly Twitter) offers product lessons on engagement vs. value, algorithmic feeds, and branding.

Key Insights

Optimizing solely for engagement metrics like dwell time can lead to a decline in overall user satisfaction and long-term retention if the content doesn't provide genuine value.

Algorithmic feeds, while potentially increasing engagement, can alienate users with irrelevant or low-quality content if not carefully curated and if user feedback mechanisms are unclear.

A strong brand identity, epitomized by Twitter becoming a verb, is invaluable; rebranding to something meaningless like 'X' can dilute this hard-won recognition.

The "blue check" system, once a signal of credibility, has been devalued by a paid subscription model, blurring the lines between legitimate users and bots/parody accounts.

Product leaders and founders must clearly articulate the product's purpose and target audience to avoid feature creep and maintain a consistent user experience.

While features like editing tweets or community notes can function well, radical changes without clear user benefit or communication can be detrimental.

THE SHIFT FROM CHRONOLOGICAL TO ALGORITHMIC FEEDS

Twitter's most significant change under new ownership is the move from a user-curated chronological feed to a TikTok-style algorithmic feed. This shift prioritizes engagement over explicit user choice, leading to content that may capture attention through superficial means, like viral fights or trending topics, rather than fulfilling a user's specific interests or needs. This raises questions about how platforms measure true user value versus mere time spent on the site.

MEASURING VALUE VS. ENGAGEMENT METRICS

A critical takeaway for founders is understanding how to gauge genuine user value beyond simple engagement metrics like dwell time. While increased watch time might seem positive, it doesn't necessarily equate to user satisfaction or fulfillment if the content consumed is not what the user truly desires. Founders must consider the harder-to-measure aspects like content quality, educational value, and user happiness to avoid inadvertently optimizing for negative experiences.

THE PERILS OF OPTIMIZING FOR A SINGLE METRIC

When a product team or company focuses excessively on a single metric, such as engagement or time spent, it can lead to unintended negative consequences. This "optimization rabbit hole" can result in a strategy that maximizes superficial interaction but degrades the overall quality and desirability of the product. This is particularly true for ad-supported models where longer user sessions theoretically mean higher ad revenue, potentially at the expense of user satisfaction and long-term retention.

BRAND IDENTITY AND THE VALUE OF "THE VERB"

Twitter achieved remarkable success by becoming a verb – 'to tweet.' This organic integration into everyday language signifies a powerful brand identity that is incredibly difficult to replicate. The rebranding to 'X' represents a significant loss of this established recognition, especially when the new name lacks inherent meaning or connection to the product's function. Founders are cautioned to protect and leverage such valuable linguistic assets.

DEVALUATION OF CREDIBILITY SIGNALS

The introduction of a paid subscription model for the 'blue check' verification mark has drastically diluted its original purpose as a signal of credibility and authenticity. What was once a mark of verified identity now often signifies nothing more than a willingness to pay, blurring the lines between genuine accounts and bots or parody. This misstep complicates user trust and the ability to discern reliable information on the platform.

CLARITY OF PURPOSE AND USER EXPERIENCE

Product leaders and founders have a responsibility to clearly articulate their product's purpose and intended use to both their team and their users. The proliferation of complex and often unnecessary features, such as AI chatbots integrated directly into the main feed, can detract from the core user experience. This suggests a potential disconnect between the product's evolution and a cohesive, user-centric vision, as demonstrated by the perceived mismatch between Tesla and X's product strategies.

LEARNING FROM SOCIAL MEDIA EVOLUTION

Examining the history of social media platforms like Facebook and Instagram reveals a pattern: initial success is often built on connecting people, but growth can lead to a dilution of that core purpose in favor of broader engagement. While the introduction of algorithmic feeds was once seen as an innovation (like Facebook's Newsfeed), when taken to extremes, as potentially with X and TikTok, it can result in an 'empty calories' experience that lacks genuine connection or satisfaction.

THE FOUNDER'S ADVANTAGE IN VISION AND AUTHORITY

Founders possess a unique advantage in steering a product's direction due to their inherent 'moral authority' and deep belief in the company's mission. This allows them to enforce a consistent vision, even when faced with pressure to optimize for short-term metrics. The ability to define what the product 'is for' and to resist the temptation of purely engagement-driven changes is crucial for building a sustainable and valuable product, akin to Steve Jobs's unwavering direction for the iPhone.

EFFECTIVE USER FEEDBACK AND CURATION TOOLS

While X has introduced tools for users to provide feedback, such as marking posts as 'not interested,' these mechanisms are often not explicit enough and require users to actively seek them out. Paradoxically, helpful features like curated lists or strong community notes can be obscured by the noise of the algorithmic feed. Making it easier for users to control their experience and provide meaningful feedback is essential for product improvement.

STRATEGIC REBRANDING AND NAME CHANGES

Changing a product's name, particularly after achieving significant brand recognition and becoming a ubiquitous verb, is an extremely risky endeavor. The decision to rebrand from Twitter to X, driven seemingly by a founder's personal affinity for the letter, overlooks the established value of the original name. When considering a rebrand, founders are advised to choose names that are easy to say, spell, and remember, ideally with some relevance to the product, but recognizing that enduring brands often imbue their names with meaning over time.

REVENUE IMPLICATIONS OF PRODUCT CHANGES

The controversial changes to Twitter/X have had a significant impact on its revenue streams. Advertisers, wary of their ads appearing alongside undesirable content, have withdrawn their support, leading to a likely decline in ad revenue. While subscription revenue may be growing, it's unlikely to fully compensate for the loss in traditional advertising. This highlights the direct correlation between product strategy, user trust, and financial performance.

FOUNDER'S ROLE IN DEFINING PRODUCT SUCCESS

Ultimately, founders must define success beyond mere metrics. While metrics are a tool in the product development process, mindlessly optimizing for a single one can lead a product down a path that looks successful on paper but feels devoid of genuine value to the end-user. A clear vision, a focus on core user problems, and the authority to maintain that vision are paramount to building a product that users genuinely benefit from and continue to value long-term.

Mentioned in This Episode

●Products

●Software & Apps

●Tools

●Companies

●Concepts

●People Referenced

Common Questions

The primary change discussed is X's shift from a chronological feed to an algorithmic feed, similar to TikTok, which prioritizes engagement over user-defined interests.

Topics

Algorithmic Feeds Platform Evolution X Metrics Optimization

Mentioned in this video

Companies

Monzo

Discussed as an example of a company that successfully crowdsourced and adopted a new name, highlighting the importance of a catchy and memorable brand.

Concepts

MAGA rally

Mentioned as an example of content that has appeared more frequently in the X feed, which the speaker had not previously engaged with.

dopamine hit

Used to describe the short-term satisfaction some users get from engaging with certain types of content, like viral videos, even if it's not ultimately valuable.

Software & Apps

Bump

An older app mentioned as an example of a product that achieved 'verb' status, where the product name became a verb.