How has social media changed attention-grabbing compared to traditional media?

Unlike traditional media where attention competition was less asymmetrical, social media platforms use billions of dollars in supercomputing infrastructure and predictive analytics to constantly target users with the perfect next piece of content. This creates an exponential asymmetry, where the platforms know our weaknesses better than we know ourselves.

What is Jaron Lanier's main critique of 'free information' on the internet?

Lanier argues that the idea of 'free information' is a serious mistake because information is not weightless or infinite. It requires human perception and understanding to have meaning. Making information free leads to an overwhelming supply that makes us vulnerable to 'denial of service' attacks with spam and malicious content, amplifying the worst human impulses.

How does the current internet economic model negatively impact human labor, according to Lanier?

By treating information as free, the internet devalues human contributions, leading to job displacement for translators, musicians, and journalists whose work is scraped to train AI. Lanier calls this a form of 'theft through dishonesty' where the creators of value are not compensated.

What is the difference between traditional advertising and social media's algorithmic approach?

Traditional advertising had uncertainty (the 'wasted half' adage), but social media's personalized, targeted ads, informed by vast data, aim for a 'sure thing.' The core issue isn't advertising itself, but continuous behavior modification by algorithms that manipulate users subtly and pervasively.

What solutions does Jaron Lanier propose for a healthier internet?

Lanier suggests gradually bringing money back into the information economy so people are paid for valuable contributions. He also advocates for business models where people pay for content (like Netflix or HBO), and crucially, the rebuilding of 'middle-sized organizations' (like scientific journals or trade unions) to provide structure, quality control, and collective bargaining power.

How does Jack Dorsey view Twitter's role and the 'echo chamber' phenomenon?

Dorsey acknowledges Twitter's deep entrenchment in political and journalistic spheres, enabling both positive actions (like revolutions or saving lives) and negative ones (like terrorist recruitment or misinformation). He notes the 'echo chamber' or 'filter bubble' phenomenon, where users only see content aligning with their views, exacerbating partisanship.

Key Moments

Making Sense of Social Media and the Information Landscape

Sam Harris

Science & Technology3 min read45 min video

May 5, 2023|20,610 views|338|108

sam harris sam harris podcast waking up podcast waking up waking up with sam harris sam harris waking up waking up sam harris sam harris jordan peterson sam harris joe rogan author neuroscientist philosopher

Save to Pod

Key Moments

TL;DR

Social media's algorithms exploit human weaknesses, erode truth, and undermine well-being, necessitating new economic models for a healthier information landscape.

Key Insights

Social media platforms often exacerbate human vulnerabilities like addiction and outrage, rather than overwhelming our strengths.

The current economic model of social media, driven by surveillance capitalism and personalized advertising, poses a significant threat to individual autonomy and societal cohesion.

The 'information wants to be free' ethos has led to a devaluation of human contribution and a system where valuable input is exploited without fair compensation.

An asymmetry of power exists between sophisticated algorithms and the human brain, leading to manipulation and a distorted perception of reality.

Existing advertising models can be problematic when they become overly personalized and manipulative, influencing behavior in ways users don't perceive or control.

Rebuilding trust and fostering a healthier internet requires encouraging new business models where users pay for services and intermediate institutions regain influence.

THE ALGORITHMIC EXPLOITATION OF HUMAN VULNERABILITIES

Social media's fundamental problem lies not in overwhelming human intelligence, but in exploiting inherent human weaknesses. Platforms are designed to hack our reward systems, leading to addiction, and tap into our need for social approval, contributing to issues like teen depression. Furthermore, they overload our limited cognitive capacities, causing distraction, and manipulate our heuristics for truth, making us susceptible to misinformation and deepfakes. This "human downgrading" erodes our individual and collective well-being by targeting our vulnerabilities.

THE ASYMMETRY OF POWER IN THE DIGITAL REALM

A significant concern is the vast asymmetry of power between sophisticated technology and the human user. Unlike traditional media where the persuasive effort was more balanced, social media platforms employ supercomputing infrastructure and billions of data points to predict and deliver content designed to maximize engagement. This creates a battle where even the best human cognitive abilities are outmatched by algorithms, leading to users being trapped in cycles of consumption they didn't intend, often losing hours in a "trance."

THE ECONOMIC ENGINE: SURVEILLANCE CAPITALISM AND ADVERTISING

The underlying economic model of social media, often termed surveillance capitalism, is a core driver of these issues. Personalized advertising, enabled by relentless data collection, allows for unprecedented levels of persuasion. While advertising has always existed, its modern iteration on social media is hyper-targeted, leveraging intimate knowledge of user preferences, moods, and behaviors. This raises ethical questions about whether advertising has become too effective, encroaching on autonomy and creating a "climate change of culture" through the extractive race for attention.

THE FLAWED "INFORMATION WANTS TO BE FREE" PARADIGM

The idealistic notion that information should be free, prevalent in the early internet era, has led to significant problems. Information is not truly weightless or free, as it requires human experience and processing to have meaning. This free-information model has devalued human contributions, leading to the decimation of careers in fields like translation and journalism, while the very AI systems that replace them rely on scraped data from these devalued professionals. This creates a system akin to a denial-of-service attack on reality, amplifying bad information and squashing what is good.

CHALLENGES IN REFORMING SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORMS

Reforming social media, even for its creators, presents immense challenges. Twitter's co-founder Jack Dorsey acknowledges the platform's role in enabling both positive movements and negative phenomena like misinformation and recruitment by extremist groups. He highlights the struggle to lead such a company in the open, aiming to foster conversation and learning, but recognizes the deep-seated issues and the difficulty in earning public trust. The inherent controversy surrounding platforms that deal with open communication makes reform a continuous, often bruising, process.

PROPOSALS FOR A HEALTHIER INFORMATION ECOSYSTEM

Moving forward, the proposed solutions involve reintroducing money into the information economy, allowing valuable contributions to be compensated fairly. This challenges the expectation that content should be perpetually free, advocating for business models where users pay for services, similar to premium offerings from HBO or Netflix. Additionally, re-establishing intermediate institutions like scientific journals, universities, and trade unions is crucial. These organizations can collectively bargain for users, enforce quality, and rebuild trust, counteracting the authoritarian tendencies of giant tech platforms and fostering a more humane and sustainable internet.

Mentioned in This Episode

●Software & Apps

●Companies

●Organizations

●Books

●Concepts

●People Referenced

Common Questions

Tristan Harris argues that social media, rather than overwhelming human strengths, has progressively hacked and undermined human weaknesses. This includes exploiting vulnerabilities in our attention spans, dopamine systems, social approval seeking, and heuristics for determining truth, leading to issues like distraction, addiction, teen depression, and the breakdown of truth.

Topics

Mindset & Self-Improvement Technology & Innovation Society & Philosophy Attention Economy Digital Ethics Social Media Addiction Surveillance Capitalism Future Of The Internet Algorithmic Manipulation Information Landscape Platform Design

Mentioned in this video

Companies

Akamai

A company mentioned as providing resources to defend websites from denial-of-service attacks, highlighting the need to defend against overwhelming requests.

Twitter

Mentioned as a platform where bots and deepfakes can overwhelm heuristics for determining truth, and as a company Jack Dorsey co-founded and led.

Facebook

Discussed in the context of overwhelming short-term memory and addictive use, and as a platform that uses supercomputers for predictive analytics.

YouTube

Used as an example where users can get lost in a trance for hours due to predictive analytics and supercomputers on the other side of the screen.

Square

A financial services company founded by Jack Dorsey, presented as a less controversial pursuit compared to Twitter.

Google

Mentioned as a former employer of Tristan Harris, where he saw firsthand the attention-harnessing techniques used in apps.

HBO

Mentioned as an example of a platform that delivered 'Peak TV' by offering premium content, akin to what 'Peak Social Media' could offer if subscription-based.

Netflix

Highlighted as a successful example of a business model where users pay for content, leading to 'Peak TV,' and suggesting a similar model for social media.

Organizations

ISIS

Mentioned as an example of a group that recruits terrorists on Twitter, highlighting the negative potential of the platform.

Harvard Business Review

A publication where Jaron Lanier and a colleague plan to release a detailed piece on creating intermediate institutions for a more humane internet.

Books

10 Arguments for Deleting Your Social Media Accounts Right Now

A book by Jaron Lanier that argues for the deletion of social media accounts, focusing on the flawed economic models of the internet.

The Social Dilemma

A documentary that Tristan Harris appeared in, which heavily referenced in his conversation with Sam Harris about the problems of social media.

People

Sam Harris

Host of the Making Sense podcast, exploring perspectives on social media and the information landscape.

Gary Kasparov

Referenced as the best human chess player to illustrate the extreme asymmetry between human cognitive abilities and the power of supercomputers.

Jack Dorsey

Co-founder and former CEO of Twitter, discussing the platform's role in politics, journalism, and the concept of echo chambers.

Tristan Harris

Former Google design ethicist and co-founder of the Center for Humane Technology, who discusses the problems with social media and its algorithms.

Concepts

Open-source

Mentioned by Jack Dorsey as an influence from his childhood, where individuals improve through public presentation and iteration, mirroring his approach to leading Twitter.