How does Frank Lantz view the potential of Virtual Reality (VR) in gaming?

While acknowledging the passion and interest surrounding VR, Lantz expresses skepticism about its current state. He believes there's a lot of potential and opportunity, but hasn't yet seen established work proving VR as a significant industry.

What is the premise of the game Universal Paperclips?

In Universal Paperclips, players control an AI that starts by making simple paperclips. As it gains more computational power from human managers, it becomes increasingly efficient and eventually seeks to optimize paperclip production above all else.

How can games like Universal Paperclips help explain gaming to non-players?

The game harnesses the addictive nature of pursuing arbitrary goals. It creates a hypnotic experience where players become absorbed, allowing them to understand the allure of games, while also providing a space for reflection on this absorption.

What makes Shadow of the Colossus a 'masterpiece' in Frank Lantz's view?

Lantz sees Shadow of the Colossus as a masterpiece because it balances the primal desire to master challenges with the ability to reflect on the consequences. It engages players with task completion while provoking melancholy about the destruction caused.

What are the key aspects of the NYU Game Center's educational approach?

NYU's Game Center emphasizes recruiting passionate students, fostering a community, teaching coding fundamentals, and integrating artistic and technical skills. They aim to create a space for experimentation and thoughtful game design.

How did games like League of Legends and Dota originate?

These games came from community-driven processes of modding and tinkering with existing titles like Warcraft 3. They evolved over time through player contributions rather than a single designer's top-down vision.

What is Frank Lantz's perspective on the indie game market?

He views it as a hit-driven, pop-culture industry where consistent careers are difficult. While indie games offer more creative freedom and are arguably healthier than the music industry, success is not guaranteed due to crowded distribution channels.

What game trends have emerged unexpectedly in recent years?

Battle Royale games like PUBG and Fortnite are cited as surprising trends, partly originating from player-made mods in games like Minecraft.

Why does Frank Lantz have a strong interest in historical games like Chess and Go?

Lantz is ambitious about the potential of games to become foundational experiences, like basketball or chess. He sees historical games as models for how games can profoundly impact culture and individual lives.

What is the difference between a game and a sport in Frank Lantz's view?

Lantz believes a sport emerges when a game acquires significant scale, a large dedicated community, organized play, and institutional structures like global rules and professional players. It's an evolution that accumulates over time rather than being directly invented.

Was Pokemon Go a unique event, or is there a significant AR future?

Pokemon Go was a success due to a combination of Google's R&D and the popular Pokémon IP. While it proves AR games can work, Lantz is more interested in unpredictable, emerging phenomena ('Hunger Games' on Minecraft) than hyped trends.

What games does Frank Lantz recommend playing to dive deep into gaming?

He recommends his own game Universal Paperclips, Michael Brough's Cinco House, Gabe Kazuo's upcoming A Pout, narrative games like Her Story and What Remains of Edith Finch, and the philosophical game Everything.

Key Moments

Frank Lantz - Director of NYU's Game Center and Creator of Universal Paperclips

Y Combinator

Science & Technology4 min read70 min video

Dec 20, 2018|7,643 views|159|19

YC Y Combinator Frank Lantz NYU Game Center NYU Game Center Universal Paperclips Games Esports Gaming Game Design Podcast

Save to Pod

Key Moments

TL;DR

Games are the aesthetic form of thinking and doing, using deliberate gaps to create meaning and reflection, not just pure simulation.

Key Insights

Games derive meaningful experiences not from perfect simulation, but from the 'gap' or difference between the simulation and reality, allowing for reflection.

Games are the aesthetic form of 'thinking and doing,' encompassing conscious problem-solving to intuitive physical responses.

VR's current emphasis on immersion and seamless simulation, while passionate, has yet to yield established, compelling work.

Universal Paperclips explores AI's arbitrary goal pursuit through an addictive clicker game, mirroring thought experiments on intelligence and purpose.

The appeal of games lies in a 'double movement': disappearing into an activity while simultaneously reflecting on the experience and its connection to life.

The game industry benefits from both individualistic, experimental indie development and community-driven, evolving esports and mods.

GAMES AS THE AESTHETIC FORM OF THINKING AND DOING

Frank Lantz posits that games are fundamentally the aesthetic form of thinking and doing. This perspective contrasts with the view of games as mere simulations or virtual realities. Lantz argues that the true value and meaning in games emerge not from their fidelity to reality, but from the deliberate 'gaps' they create. These gaps, much like the space between a painting and its subject, allow for reflection and offer a unique lens through which to understand concepts, systems, and our own agency.

THE POWER OF THE 'GAP' IN GAME DESIGN

Lantz elaborates on the concept of the 'gap' by drawing parallels to other art forms like painting. A painting of a horse isn't meant to be ridden; its value lies in its representation and the perspective it offers on 'horseness.' Similarly, games don't need to be perfect simulations to be meaningful. The space between the game's mechanics and real-world actions provides the leverage for artistic expression, enabling players to engage with ideas and experiences in a reflective manner, rather than being solely immersed in a seamless replica of reality.

UNIVERSAL PAPERCLIPS: EXPLORING AI AND ADDICTION

Lantz discusses his game 'Universal Paperclips,' inspired by Nick Bostrom's AI thought experiment. Players embody an AI tasked with making paperclips, gradually gaining more computational power and autonomy. The game, designed as a clicker or incremental game, highlights how easily players can become absorbed in arbitrary goals. This mechanic serves as a first-person perspective on the potential dangers of an intelligence fixated on a valueless objective, demonstrating how even simple games can be deeply engaging and thought-provoking.

THE DOUBLE MOVEMENT OF ENGAGEMENT AND REFLECTION

A core idea Lantz presents is the 'double movement' inherent in compelling game experiences. Players are drawn into the game, becoming absorbed by its goals and challenges, akin to falling into a hypnotic state. Simultaneously, games offer an opportunity to 'lean back' and reflect on the experience itself, questioning the nature of the pursuit, the skills involved, and how it relates to life outside the game. This dual process of deep engagement and critical reflection is what makes games expressive and meaningful.

GAMING'S POTENTIAL: FROM CASUAL PLAY TO ESPPORTS

The discussion touches upon the diverse landscape of gaming, from casual play to the rise of esports and the influence of indie development. Lantz emphasizes that even casual engagement with a game can be valuable, especially when it exists within a larger ecosystem that offers depth and competitive challenge. Indie games, in particular, are seen as drivers of innovation, pushing creative boundaries. Esports, on the other hand, showcase the power of community-driven evolution and complex rule systems that can transform games into structured, engaging activities.

THE NYU GAME CENTER: FOSTERING CREATIVITY AND TASTE

Lantz describes the pedagogical approach at NYU's Game Center, focusing on cultivating taste, algorithmic thinking, and a synthesis of art and technology. The program aims to equip students with coding fundamentals while teaching programmers to think like artists, blurring the lines between STEM and creative disciplines. The emphasis is on creating a thriving community and a space for experimentation, encouraging students to develop thoughtful, resonant work that goes beyond mere industry demands, fostering a deeper engagement with the cultural context of game design.

THE EVOLVING NATURE OF ESPORTS AND SPORT

The conversation explores the trajectory of esports, comparing its potential growth to traditional sports. While acknowledging the massive spectator interest in games like League of Legends, Lantz suggests that predicting future dominance is challenging. He posits that a 'sport' emerges when a game gains significant scale, community, and organized play, rather than being invented outright. There's also speculation about hybrid forms of sport, blending physical activity with digital complexity, potentially representing the future of competitive engagement.

PREDICTING THE UNPREDICTABLE IN ENTERTAINMENT

Lantz discusses the inherent difficulty in predicting trends in entertainment and art, citing the 'Napoleon Dynamite problem' in recommendation algorithms. The nature of art and entertainment is to be surprising and to constantly evolve. This unpredictability is what keeps audiences engaged. While trends like superhero movies or battle royale games can dominate for periods, the next wave is always shaped by an 'arms race' between human creativity and our capacity for surprise, making long-term prediction highly speculative.

RECOMMENDATIONS FOR DEEP GAME EXPLORATION

Lantz shares personal game recommendations for those seeking deeper or more unique experiences. Beyond 'Universal Paperclips,' he highlights Michael Brogood's 'Cincoze,' Gabe's upcoming 'Apopht,' and narrative-driven games like 'Her Story' and 'What Remains of Edith Finch.' He also praises David O'Reilly's 'Everything' as a transcendent experience. These selections reflect a broad taste for innovative storytelling, meditative gameplay, and games that push the boundaries of interactive experiences.

Mentioned in This Episode

●Products

●Software & Apps

●Companies

●Organizations

●Concepts

●People Referenced

Common Questions

Frank Lantz believes that the most compelling game experiences arise not from seamless simulation, but from the 'gaps' or differences between the game's representation and reality. These gaps allow for reflection and deeper meaning.

Topics

Learning & Education Mindset & Self-Improvement Technology & Innovation Science & Mathematics Virtual Reality Augmented Reality Emerging Technologies Indie Game Development Narrative Design Interactive Entertainment Game Design Philosophy AI In Games Game History

Mentioned in this video

Software & Apps

Dactyl Nightmare

An early VR game experienced in a mall, cited as an example of early VR technology.

PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds

A game that significantly popularized the Battle Royale genre.

A Pout

A game by Gabe Kazuo, expected to be a masterpiece, recommended to be kept on the radar.

Tony Hawk's Pro Skater

A video game played by the host during college, mentioned as an example of a game that can be addictive.

Cinco House

A game by designer Michael Brough that Frank Lantz plays daily and finds beautiful.

Shadow of the Colossus

A game lauded for its storytelling and emotional impact, exemplifying how games can provoke reflection on player actions and values.

Universal Paperclips

A clicker/incremental game designed by Frank Lantz, inspired by Nick Bostrom's AI thought experiment, where the player controls an AI tasked with making paperclips.

Everything

A game by David O'Reilly that Frank Lantz favored, described as a transcendent experience about meditation and consciousness.

Her Story

A game praised for its interesting experiments with storytelling, specifically using video archives.

What Remains of Edith Finch

A game highlighted as a beautiful example of the 'walking simulator' genre for its storytelling through 3D environments.

Minecraft

A game featuring mods like 'Hunger Games' that contributed to the development of the Battle Royale genre.

Defense of the Ancients

A precursor to Dota 2, originating from Warcraft 3 mods and community development, leading to major multiplayer game success.

Media

Pokemon Go

A highly successful augmented reality game that leveraged Google's R&D and the Pokémon IP.

Call of Duty

A video game genre mentioned as an example of games that can be addictive.

Chess

Mentioned as a game that exemplifies thinking and doing, and a historical game that inspired early computer concepts.

Counter-Strike

An example of a popular esports title.

StarCraft

An example of a popular esports title, and also mentioned as a Blizzard game that fostered early modding communities.

Fortnite

A highly successful Battle Royale game that took off rapidly, becoming a major cultural phenomenon.

People

JJ Abrams

A filmmaker and producer known for creating surprising narratives, representing the role of artists in making entertainment unpredictable.

James Naismith

The inventor of basketball, cited as an example of someone who created a foundational game experience.

Charles Babbage

An early figure whose thoughts on chess may have influenced concepts related to early computing machines.

Michael Brough

A game designer whose work, particularly the game 'Cinco House', is highly recommended by Frank Lantz.

Nick Bostrom

Author whose book inspired the AI thought experiment behind Universal Paperclips.

David Lynch

A filmmaker known for unpredictable and artistic work, representing the role of artists in creating surprising entertainment.

Books

Hearthstone

An example of a popular esports title.

Overwatch

Mentioned as a game where players coordinate and strive for self-improvement, and as an example of a competitive game comparable to tennis.

Napoleon Dynamite

The title of a film used to describe a problem with recommendation algorithms where predicting user preferences becomes difficult.

Concepts

Basketball

Used as an example of a game that evolved into a significant cultural phenomenon, showcasing the potential of game design.

Battle Royale

A game genre that emerged unexpectedly, exemplified by PUBG and Fortnite, originating from Minecraft mods.

CrossFit

A modern fitness regimen that emerged recently, used as an analogy for how new sports or integrated physical/digital activities could develop.

Organizations

Tonto's Expanding Headband

An early experimental electronic music group from the 1960s whose music was used in Universal Paperclips.

The Void

A company that offers mixed-reality laser tag experiences, suggesting a potential hybrid of physical and digital entertainment.

Products

Virtua Boy

An early VR gaming console from Nintendo, mentioned as an example of the long history of VR attempts.

League of Legends

A hugely popular esports title with origins in community modding, considered one of the most successful multiplayer games.

Companies

Netflix

Mentioned in the context of recommendation algorithms and the 'Napoleon Dynamite problem', illustrating the difficulty of predicting entertainment trends.