What is 'workism' and why is it problematic for Americans?

Workism is the idea that many Americans, especially college-educated ones, treat their work as a religious identity, seeking community, purpose, and transcendence from their jobs. This is problematic because jobs are not designed to bear such a burden, can lead to disappointment due to sky-high expectations, and can cause neglect of other vital aspects of life like family, friends, and community, leading to a narrow sense of self-worth that is vulnerable if a job is lost.

How did the COVID-19 pandemic affect people's relationship with work?

The pandemic acted as an accelerant, magnifying existing unease with work culture. Remote work, in particular, stripped away the social elements of work, exposing the 'absurdities' of many digital knowledge jobs and leading to an 'existential slap in the face' for many. Facing mortality and experiencing a different life balance during lockdowns also prompted people to question the role work plays in their lives and seek more sustainable arrangements.

What is 'vocational awe' and how does it prevent fair treatment in 'dream jobs'?

Vocational awe refers to the perceived righteousness of certain fields (like teaching, healthcare, non-profits, or academia), making them seem 'beyond critique.' This can prevent workers from advocating for fair compensation and better conditions, as the good 'brand' of the job can obscure exploitation. The unspoken agreement is that passion for such 'God's work' should be its own reward, often leading to low pay.

How can individuals diversify their identity to reduce work-related stress?

To diversify identity and reduce work-related stress, individuals should proactively carve out space where they are not working, ensuring they don't exist in a 'perpetual state of half-work.' The second step is to actively invest time and energy in relationships, community, interests, and hobbies outside of work. This creates multiple sources of meaning, making individuals more resilient to professional setbacks and fostering creativity.

What are the two main forces behind lack of motivation for deep work, especially when working from home?

The two main forces are 'deep procrastination' and 'dopamine sickness.' Deep procrastination arises from a lack of intrinsic motivation for hard work, coupled with ambiguity. Dopamine sickness results from frazzling the brain with constant targeted distractions, making it difficult to engage in longer, more complex tasks.

What strategies can help overcome deep procrastination and dopamine sickness?

For deep procrastination, reduce task hardness, simplify obligations, and connect work to a bigger positive lifestyle vision. For dopamine sickness, implement 'boredom therapy' (e.g., phone-free walks), use a 'phone foyer' method, and retrain focus with interval training (e.g., 20-minute focused sprints). Also, create a distinct work location and radical rituals to separate work from non-work.

How should someone navigate a career shift out of Academia while applying lifestyle-centric planning and career capital?

First, conduct a reality check on which academic roles are truly accessible. If a shift is necessary, use lifestyle-centric career planning to define an ideal family lifestyle, then identify jobs that enable it, regardless of whether they leverage specific academic training. Career capital serves to open up more options, not to dictate that only directly related paths should be pursued. If a big swerve aligns with the desired lifestyle, it's not a waste but an intentional move.

Why is an 'extreme hyperactive hive mind' workflow identified as a major workplace red flag?

An extreme hyperactive hive mind, characterized by constant interruption, immediate response demands, and context-shifting, is physiologically and psychologically damaging. It induces constant stress and anxiety, mental fatigue, and prevents deep focus, akin to torture in its impact on cognitive well-being. It is a valid reason to leave a job, just like an unsafe or a disrespectful work environment.

What is the next big technology disruption likely to be, according to Cal Newport?

Cal Newport believes the next massive disruption in consumer technology will be augmented reality (AR), specifically see-through, non-descript glasses that project virtual elements onto the real world. This will eliminate the need for independent screens like laptops, phones, and TVs, allowing virtual interfaces to seamlessly integrate into any environment. Apple's experimental mixed reality headset is seen as a crucial step toward this future.

Key Moments

Ep. 249: The Good Enough Job (w/ Simone Stolzoff)

Deep Questions with Cal Newport

People & Blogs4 min read104 min video

May 22, 2023|13,958 views|284|22

Cal Newport Deep Work Deep Life Deep Questions TimblockPlanner Deep Questions Podcast the good enough job simone stolzoff work to live the good-enough life cal newport reading

Save to Pod

Key Moments

TL;DR

Simone Stolzoff's "The Good Enough Job" advocates for diversifying identity beyond work and finding meaning outside one's career.

Key Insights

Work is often overemphasized as a source of identity and self-worth, leading to disappointment and neglecting other life aspects.

A 'good enough job' mindset involves defining personal satisfaction rather than pursuing endless ambition, allowing for a balanced life.

The U.S. culture's strong tie between work and self-worth differs from cultures where work is a means to an end.

The pandemic highlighted the absurdity of some digital knowledge work and prompted a reevaluation of work's role in life.

Diversifying identity through relationships, community, and hobbies builds resilience and creativity.

Workplace systems and cultures, not just individual effort, need to support sustainable productivity and work-life balance.

THE PROBLEM OF WORK AS IDENTITY

The conversation introduces Simone Stolzoff's book, "The Good Enough Job," which challenges the notion that work should be the central axis of one's life. In the U.S., work is often the first identifier, leading individuals to fuse their self-worth with professional accomplishments. This intense focus can lead to significant disappointment when jobs change or fail to meet sky-high expectations and can cause individuals to neglect other vital aspects of their identity, such as being a neighbor, parent, or citizen.

HISTORICAL AND CULTURAL CONTEXT OF WORKISM

The pervasive emphasis on work, termed 'workism,' is explored from historical and cultural perspectives. Rooted partly in the Protestant work ethic and capitalism, its modern iteration has intensified over the past 40-50 years. The decline of other community and meaning-providing institutions, like organized religion, has led many to transpose their desire for purpose and belonging onto the workplace. Additionally, tying healthcare to employment and the high stakes of job loss in the U.S. further entrench work's central role.

THE PANDEMIC'S REVELATIONS

The COVID-19 pandemic acted as an accelerant, exposing the inherent absurdities and alienations of modern work. For many, remote work stripped away the social aspects of the job, forcing a confrontation with the more abstract nature of digital knowledge work. Facing mortality and observing the possibility of a more balanced life during lockdowns prompted widespread questioning of work's purpose and value, leading to phenomena like the 'Great Resignation' and 'quiet quitting'.

VOCATIONAL AWE AND THE 'DREAM JOB' FALLACY

The concept of 'vocational awe' describes the perceived righteousness or divine calling associated with certain professions, which can obscure exploitation and lead individuals to accept less than ideal conditions. Even perceived 'dream jobs,' like that of a Michelin-star chef, come with significant challenges, demonstrating that the content of work alone cannot guarantee fulfillment. True job satisfaction often stems from factors beyond the work itself, such as autonomy and control, as seen in the example of less prestigious but more satisfying trades.

DIVERSIFYING IDENTITY AND EMBRACING 'GOOD ENOUGH'

A core prescription is to diversify one's identity, much like an investor diversifies a financial portfolio. This involves actively cultivating interests, relationships, and community involvements beyond work. The 'good enough job' framework encourages individuals to define what 'enough' means for them, focusing on values and a vision for a well-lived life rather than relentless pursuit of more. This approach requires intentionally carving out non-work time and actively investing in other life domains, preventing work from subsuming one's entire existence.

PRODUCTIVITY AND STRUCTURAL CHANGE

The conversation delves into productivity, differentiating between organizational techniques and the pressure to produce more. While individual productivity systems can help establish boundaries, the context of work—whether it's a source of transcendent meaning or one facet of life—is crucial. The discussion also touches on the need for systemic changes within organizations, such as adequate staffing, managerial role-modeling, and clear transactional expectations, to create more sustainable work environments that don't rely solely on individual effort to achieve balance.

NAVIGATING CAREER CHOICES AND ACADEMIA

For those struggling with career choices, the advice is to adopt a lifestyle-centric approach, defining an ideal life first and then finding work that supports it. This is particularly relevant for individuals like academics facing a tough job market. The discussion stresses realism in assessing career options, whether in academia or alternative paths, and using 'career capital' as a tool to achieve lifestyle goals rather than an end in itself. The importance of intentionality and clarity in career pivots is emphasized, distinguishing them from aimless job-hopping.

RECOGNIZING AND ESCAPING TOXIC WORK CULTURES

Extreme 'hyperactive hive mind' work environments, characterized by constant demands for immediate responsiveness and digital interruptions, are identified as significant red flags detrimental to well-being. Escaping such cultures is validated as a reasonable and healthy decision. While drastic changes like accepting less pay might be considered, the advice also encourages exploring lateral moves to organizations with healthier cultures or shifting towards more autonomous work structures like freelancing or consulting, emphasizing that systemic issues require both individual awareness and organizational change.

Mentioned in This Episode

●Products

●Software & Apps

●Companies

●Organizations

●Books

●People Referenced

Common Questions

Recent graduates should adopt a lifestyle-centric career planning approach, focusing on creating a comprehensive vision for their desired lifestyle. This involves identifying key elements of a well-lived life beyond just work, and then strategically choosing a job that supports that broader vision, rather than seeking intrinsic fulfillment solely from the job itself. It encourages pragmatism and leveraging work as an instrument to achieve life goals.

Topics

Mental Health & Psychology Mindset & Self-Improvement Technology & Innovation Future Of Work Work-life Balance Augmented Reality Dopamine Regulation Job Satisfaction Work Culture Productivity Strategies Career & Skills Career Fulfillment

Mentioned in this video

Software & Apps

Wired

A publication where Simone Stolzoff freelanced, contributing to discussions on work culture.

Products

Oculus

A virtual reality headset mentioned as an example of a bulkier VR device, contrasted with Apple's smaller form-factor mixed reality glasses.

Microsoft HoloLens

An augmented reality headset mentioned as a prior attempt at AR technology using waveguide, indicating the challenges of the field.

People

Cal Newport

Host of Deep Questions podcast and author, who introduces the topic of life after school and the concept of lifestyle-centric career planning.

Derek Thompson

A colleague of Simone Stolzoff who coined the term 'workism,' describing the trend of Americans treating work as a religious identity.

Anne Helen Petersen

A colleague mentioned for her insight that passion for work often leads to low pay, challenging the romanticized view of 'dream jobs.'

Ben Casnocha

A friend of Cal Newport and co-author of 'The Alliance,' who wrote about a future of work based on fixed-term contracts.

David Chalmers

An expert on machine consciousness, recently interviewed on the 80,000 Hours podcast.

Simone Stolzoff

Author of 'The Good Enough Job: Reclaiming Life from Work', interviewed by Cal Newport to discuss his book's themes.

Esther Perel

A psychologist quoted by Simone Stolzoff, known for her phrase about people bringing the best of themselves to work and the leftovers home.

Mike Rose

Referenced for his TED Talk challenging vocational awe and "passion" in jobs, highlighting contentment in less 'glamorous' work.

Companies

BetterHelp

An online therapy platform designed to be convenient and flexible, matching users with licensed therapists.

IDEO

A design consultancy where Simone Stolzoff previously worked as a design lead, which represented a career crossroads for him.

ExpressVPN

A recommended VPN service for internet privacy, offering easy-to-use, secure, and encrypted connections.

Ladder

A long-time sponsor that offers 100% digital life insurance, simplifying the application process without doctors or paperwork.

Apple

Technology company releasing a new mixed reality device that Cal Newport believes signifies a major technological disruption in the consumer screen market.

Magic Leap

A company that attempted to develop augmented reality technology using waveguide technology, showcasing the difficulty of see-through AR.

Books

So Good They Can't Ignore You

Cal Newport's first general audience book from 2012, which first introduced the idea of Lifestyle-Centric Career Planning.

The Good Enough Job: Reclaiming Life from Work

Simone Stolzoff's new book, which challenges the idea of work being central to identity and advocates for a balanced approach to career and life.

The Alliance

A book co-authored by Ben Casnocha and Reid Hoffman, proposing a future of work based on short-term, mutually beneficial contracts between highly skilled workers and companies.

Deep Work

Cal Newport's book where he discusses boredom therapy as a technique to improve focus and combat dopamine sickness.

Organizations

The Atlantic

A publication for which Simone Stolzoff freelanced, writing about work culture.

80,000 Hours

A non-profit organization that helps people find careers that have a positive social impact, offering research, guides, and career advice.

Oxford University

Academic institution where 80,000 Hours has conducted research on optimizing career impact.

Media

Wall Street Journal

A publication that ran an article discussing Apple's new mixed reality headset, highlighting its experimental nature.