Key Moments

Carolynn Levy and Kirsty Nathoo - Startup Investor School Day 1

Y CombinatorY Combinator
Science & Technology4 min read60 min video
Mar 6, 2018|17,406 views|196|2
Save to Pod
TL;DR

Y Combinator explains the SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity) for startup investing, detailing its terms, conversion, and process.

Key Insights

1

The SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity) is designed for very early-stage startups to efficiently raise small amounts of money without needing legal counsel.

2

Key SAFE terms are the investment amount and the valuation cap; it is not debt and does not accrue interest.

3

There are different SAFE versions: capped, discount, uncapped, and MFN (Most Favored Nation), each with unique conversion terms.

4

SAFE conversion into equity occurs during a priced round, factoring in an options pool increase, pre-money conversion, and the new investment.

5

Calculating SAFE holder ownership is complex due to dilution from future funding rounds and options pools; modeling scenarios can clarify potential outcomes.

6

In acquisition or dissolution events, SAFE holders' rights depend on the deal's value, and in cases of company failure, they are prioritized over stockholders.

INTRODUCTION TO THE SAFE

The Y Combinator SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity) is a financial instrument designed to simplify early-stage startup investing, particularly for companies that have not yet raised a priced round. It allows investors to provide capital in exchange for future equity without the immediate need for complex legal documentation or valuation discussions. This makes it an efficient and cost-effective tool for founders to secure initial funding from friends, family, and angel investors, providing a clear, albeit often imprecise, path to future ownership.

KEY FEATURES AND MECHANICS OF THE SAFE

The SAFE is fundamentally a convertible security, not debt. It does not accrue interest and has no maturity date, distinguishing it from convertible notes. The primary negotiable terms are the investment amount and the valuation cap, representing the maximum valuation at which the SAFE will convert. After these terms are set, the SAFE document outlines conversion events and includes standard legal definitions and boilerplate provisions. Importantly, SAFEs do not grant immediate rights like voting or information rights; these are acquired upon conversion into preferred stock.

VARIATIONS OF THE SAFE INSTRUMENT

Beyond the standard capped SAFE, other versions exist to accommodate different investor and founder needs. A discount SAFE offers investors a reduced share price in the future priced round, typically between 10-20%, as compensation for early investment. An uncapped SAFE, less common, converts at the same price as the priced round, offering no explicit reward for early risk. The MFN (Most Favored Nation) SAFE allows investors to amend their terms to match more favorable terms secured by subsequent investors, ensuring they receive the best possible deal eventually.

SAFE CONVERSION INTO EQUITY

When a company raises a subsequent priced equity round (e.g., Series A, B, etc.), the SAFE converts into shares of stock. This process typically occurs on a pre-money basis, meaning the SAFE conversion is calculated before the new investor's money is factored in. Key events during conversion include the creation or increase of an employee stock option pool (often around 10% of post-round shares), the conversion of SAFEs into shares based on the agreed valuation cap or a lower valuation if the priced round is below the cap, and finally, the infusion of new capital from the lead investor and other participants.

CALCULATING OWNERSHIP AND DILUTION

Determining a SAFE investor's exact ownership percentage post-conversion can be complex due to calculations involving the valuation cap, the priced round's valuation, issued shares, and any increased option pools. Dilution from new money investments and the mechanics of option pool increases mean SAFE holders often own less than initially projected based on the cap alone. Tools like AngelCalc and provided spreadsheets can help investors model various conversion scenarios and understand potential ownership outcomes, emphasizing the importance of diligence.

CONVERSION IN OTHER EVENTS AND PROCESS CONSIDERATIONS

If a company is acquired or goes public (IPO), SAFEs typically convert into common stock, allowing investors to participate in the proceeds based on the target valuation. In an 'acqui-hire' scenario or if the company fails, SAFE holders may elect to be repaid. In dissolution, they are prioritized over stockholders after creditors. The investment process emphasizes a 'handshake protocol' for clear agreement, often managed via platforms like Clerke for signing and wiring funds, ensuring timely and transparent transactions. Reviewing conversion calculations and cap tables is crucial before signing final documents.

INVESTOR ADVICE AND LONG-TERM PERSPECTIVE

Effective angel investing, especially with SAFEs, requires a focus on potential upside over downside protection, embracing the power-law nature of startup returns. Being a helpful, supportive investor without being overbearing is key. Investors should tolerate company pivots and failures, understanding that the journey is long and success often lies in backing exceptional founders. Patience and a long-term view are essential, recognizing that realizing significant returns takes time and navigating the inevitable ups and downs of the startup lifecycle.

SAFE Investing Cheat Sheet

Practical takeaways from this episode

Do This

Use the SAFE for fast, cheap, and efficient early-stage investments.
Understand your rights, especially pro-rata rights.
Do your own modeling to understand potential ownership and dilution.
Verify all details in SAFE documents before signing.
Wire money promptly after signing the SAFE.
Review conversion calculations and cap tables carefully during priced rounds.
Be helpful to founders without being overbearing.
Tolerate founder pivots and unexpected company shifts.
Exercise pro-rata rights to maintain ownership percentage.

Avoid This

Do not call it a 'safe note' as it's not debt.
Do not expect repayment at a maturity date.
Do not back out after a 'handshake deal' without damaging your reputation.
Do not sign SAFE documents without verifying names and details.
Do not delay wiring money after signing a SAFE.
Do not sign conversion documents without understanding and agreeing to the terms.
Do not negotiate excessively on downside protection if focused on massive upside.
Do not ask to be on the board of directors for early-stage companies unless explicitly desired by founders.

SAFE Conversion Example Calculation

Data extracted from this episode

ItemValueCalculation/Notes
Founder Shares9,000,000Initial issued shares
SAFE Investment$800,000Amount invested via SAFE
Valuation Cap$8,000,000Negotiated cap for SAFE conversion
Priced Round Investment$4,000,000New money raised in priced round
Priced Round Pre-Money Valuation$16,000,000Valuation set for the priced round
Post-Money Options Pool10% of post-money sharesIncreased options pool
Increased Options Pool Shares (Approx)1,405,000Calculated number of shares for options pool
SAFE Capitalization10,405,000Issued Shares + Options Pool
SAFE Conversion Price$0.77Valuation Cap / SAFE Capitalization
SAFE Investor Shares~1,038,961SAFE Investment / SAFE Conversion Price
New Money Investor Capitalization11,470,000Issued Shares + Options Pool + SAFE Investor Shares
New Money Price Per Share$1.39Priced Round Pre-Money Valuation / New Money Investor Capitalization
New Money Investor Shares~2,877,000Priced Round Investment / New Money Price Per Share

Common Questions

A SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity) is a convertible security that allows investors to give money to a startup now in exchange for stock that will be issued at a later date, typically during a future priced funding round. It's used because it's faster and cheaper than traditional equity financing for very early-stage companies.

Topics

Mentioned in this video

More from Y Combinator

View all 362 summaries

Found this useful? Build your knowledge library

Get AI-powered summaries of any YouTube video, podcast, or article in seconds. Save them to your personal pods and access them anytime.

Try Summify free