Key Moments
Kim Bowes on the Economic Lives of Rome's Ninety Percent | Conversations with Tyler
Key Moments
Daily life in Rome was far more colorful and consumer-driven than previously thought, with ordinary citizens using gold coins and importing spices, yet a lack of formal economic reasoning and poor sanitation persisted.
Key Insights
Elite Roman houses were excessively decorated, with every surface covered in color and ornamentation, often to a degree modern eyes would find 'garish'.
The concept of 'going off to work' is largely 19th century; for most of history, work was integrated into the home, with Roman elite houses functioning as 'machines for the production of social status' and business.
Despite sophisticated infrastructure like sewers, Roman cities were densely populated, leading to persistent sanitation issues evidenced by stepping stones to avoid street refuse.
Gold coins were used for day-to-day transactions in Roman daily life, not just for ceremonial purposes or wealth saving, with a significant number circulating.
The Roman state’s ability to collect taxes and maintain the empire relied heavily on a 'privatized affair' of non-state networks of friends, family, and business, alongside a shared consumer universe.
Recent archaeological evidence suggests even poor Romans owned multiple sets of colorful clothing and elaborate shoes, indicating a higher standard of living and consumption than previously assumed.
Surprising levels of color and consumption in Roman homes
Roman elite homes were characterized by an astonishing amount of color and decoration, with nearly every surface adorned in ways that might appear 'garish' or 'kitsch' to modern sensibilities. Unlike contemporary practices where such decorations are preserved and kept separate, in Roman homes, these elements were integrated into daily life and heavily used. This extensive decoration extended to various aspects, including mosaic floors. Elite houses also served a dual purpose as centers for business and social status. They were designed as 'machines for the production of social status,' facilitating deals, client meetings, and the display of personal lives, blurring the lines between private and public, home and work, in a manner dissimilar to the 19th-century concept of commuting to an office.
Navigating Roman cities and sanitation challenges
Navigating ancient cities, even large ones like Rome with a population potentially reaching one million, relied on asking people for directions rather than modern systems like GPS or addresses. This was more feasible in smaller Roman cities, typically numbering a few thousand people. Sanitation in Roman homes was rudimentary; private bathrooms were uncommon, with Romans using pots, which were later discarded into drains in cities with public waterworks, or simply into the streets in others. Public latrines existed, some even bearing the name of an emperor who charged for their use. Despite Rome's investment in advanced infrastructure like sewers and drains, the sheer density of urban populations made sanitation a persistent, often insurmountable problem. The presence of stepping stones in cities like Pompeii, even those with good sanitation, served as a testament to the pervasive refuse in the streets, requiring visitors to literally step over it.
The economics of daily Roman life and currency
Contrary to the notion that gold coins were solely for ceremonial or hoarding purposes, new archaeological evidence from Pompeii indicates they were used for day-to-day transactions. The volume of gold coins circulating in the Roman Empire appears to be substantial. While bronze coins dominated ordinary daily use, gold played a more significant role than previously acknowledged. Furthermore, Roman economic thinking, while not formalized into distinct academic branches like modern economics, was sophisticated in practice. Romans understood supply and demand intuitively, adjusting to harvest prices, and engaged in planning around profit, though not always in a clearly quantified, future-oriented manner as understood today. They did not develop an 'Adam Smith' equivalent, but their economic activity was deeply interwoven with social structures of friends and family, influencing everything from a decentralized money-lending system to the use of banking.
Religious practices and the spread of Christianity
Even after Christianity gained imperial support following Constantine, its adoption was gradual, with few Christians in rural areas for centuries. Early Christians' beliefs centered on their God's special powers, particularly the promise of bodily resurrection, which was a novel concept in the Greco-Roman and Jewish worlds. However, a significant gap existed between what bishops intended Christians to believe and what ordinary people practiced. Many Christians adopted a syncretic approach, blending Christian practices with older traditions. The traditional Greco-Roman pantheon focused more on ritualistic actions and a 'quid pro quo' relationship with the gods rather than abstract belief, though by the 3rd and 4th centuries, belief began to gain importance, and interest in holy men with special powers grew across various religious groups.
Material culture and religious expression
Religious identity in the Roman world was expressed materially. While early Christians might not have had altars in their homes, they developed other forms of worship, such as lamps with Christian symbols, to express their religious identity. The cross symbol became prominent later; earlier Christian identification often used the Chi-Rho monogram (an X and P superimposed). Early Christian communities operated as private cults due to their unofficial status, meeting in houses. Archaeological evidence from Dura-Europos reveals well-organized groups practicing baptism, reading scriptures, and engaging in communal prayer, alongside Jewish synagogues and Mithraic temples in the same street, highlighting a diverse religious landscape. Contrary to the idea of hiding, these communities were often visible, with burials in catacombs not strictly segregated by religion.
Roman technology, trade, and consumption
Roman technological advancements, while not always inventing entirely new concepts, excelled at scaling up existing innovations from the Greek world, such as water-powered devices and underwater mortar. However, there is a noticeable lack of trickle-down effect of this technology to ordinary people's economic lives, unlike in later periods. The Roman Empire's vastness was maintained not just by taxation but significantly by a shared consumer universe, where participation in consumption acted as a binding force. This economic activity, fueled by high consumption levels, supported the tax apparatus. When this cycle of consumption and production broke down, often linked to population decline, the state's ability to function also faltered. Evidence shows ordinary people, even in cities, were using goods like peppercorns imported from the East, indicating participation in a globalized consumer economy, though the scale and type of trade differed from modern patterns.
Demographic shifts and the decline of the empire
The decline of the Roman Empire, or its significant transformation, may be better understood through a lens of economic and demographic changes rather than solely direct plagues. While plagues undoubtedly played a role, experts suggest they acted upon populations already in decline. Population numbers, particularly in Italy, may have started decreasing as early as the late 2nd century, with significant drops in the 5th century and beyond. This population decline, especially noticeable in rural areas, had profound consequences for the state's tax collection capabilities and disrupted the crucial cycle of local consumption and production. The hypothesis for the empire's fall points to a breakdown in the synergy between ordinary people's consumption and production, and the ability of the state, which ultimately led to economic collapse.
Landscape archaeology and future discoveries
Landscape archaeology utilizes non-excavation methods like surface ceramic collection, geophysics, and aerial photography to study vast rural areas and their changes over time. This approach offers insights into the broader patterns of settlement and land use. Future discoveries in Roman history are expected to come from new excavations driven by modern construction projects and the ongoing analysis of papyri, particularly from Roman Egypt. These sources are revealing significant economic data and challenging previous assumptions about Roman demographics, farming practices, and the overall economy. Even seemingly missed industrial areas, like the discovered brick factories supplying Rome, highlight how much remains yet to be uncovered about the ancient world.
Mentioned in This Episode
●Software & Apps
●Organizations
●Books
●Concepts
●People Referenced
Common Questions
Roman elite houses would have been covered in an extraordinary amount of color and decoration on every surface, which might appear garish or kitschy to modern eyes. Unlike today, these decorations were not treated as special and fenced off but were part of everyday use.
Topics
Mentioned in this video
Kim Bowes's affiliation as an archaeologist.
Rome's greatest enemies who sacked Dura-Europos in the late 3rd century, preserving the town's archaeological remains.
Mentioned as a modern concept of bank guarantee that was absent in the Roman world, making the distinction between family and bank lending less clear.
As of the discussion, the EU is not a relevant entity for archaeological cooperation, with work operating at the nation-state or provincial level.
Excavated the town of Dura-Europos, with artifacts displayed at the Yale Art Museum.
Archaeologist at the University of Pennsylvania and author of 'Surviving Rome: The Economic Lives of the 90%'.
Mentioned as an example of someone systematizing economic reasoning, which ancient Romans lacked in a comparable way.
A colleague of Kim Bowes who has thought about banking, particularly in the Athenian Greek world.
An auctioneer from Pompeii whose records are used as an example of someone facilitating monetary exchange, functioning somewhat like a banker.
Scholar who argued that Romans engaged in futures trading, primarily on agricultural surpluses.
Recommended for a tour, noted for Diocletian's Palace, which now houses cafes and shops.
Mentioned as an example of hyperinflation where people wheeled around wheelbarrows of money.
The Roman Empire's breadbasket and an important economic region from which papyri originate.
Location where a massive industrial belt of brick factories was discovered, suggesting a shift in brick production locations away from Rome.
Used as an analogy for the significance of discovering the brick factory locations in the Tyber Valley, implying it was a similarly large and previously missed industrial area.
Kim Bowes's hometown, which influenced her understanding of small communities and family businesses, relevant to her approach to Roman studies.
Suggested as a starting point for a tour of the Roman Empire, notable as a Roman border and for the archaeological site at Vindolanda.
An archaeological site on Hadrian's Wall offering insights into the daily lives of ordinary soldiers and people stationed there.
Mentioned as a significant Roman city to visit, alongside Segovia and Split.
Mentioned as a significant Roman city to visit, alongside Trier and Split.
The location of Diocletian's palace in Split.
An extraordinary frontier garrison town on the Euphrates, excavated by Yale University, preserved due to being sacked by the Parthians and showcasing religious and ethnic diversity.
More from Conversations with Tyler
View all 42 summaries
62 minArthur Brooks on Reinvention, Religion, and the Science of Happiness | Conversations with Tyler
53 minAndy Weir on the Economics of Sci-Fi and Space | Conversations with Tyler
70 minPaul Gillingham on Why Mexico Stays Together | Conversations with Tyler
65 minHarvey Mansfield on Machiavelli, Straussianism, and the Character of Liberal Democracy | CWT
Found this useful? Build your knowledge library
Get AI-powered summaries of any YouTube video, podcast, or article in seconds. Save them to your personal pods and access them anytime.
Get Started Free